The Reformed Perspective

The opening lecture of this series articulates the distinctive perspective of the Reformed theological tradition: its commitments, its sources, and its enduring relevance to the life of the church.

Recorded
Length
Series
Columbia Forum Alumni Lectures, 1 of 3
Skip to the transcript

The Reformed PerspectiveDr. John H. Leith, 1978

0:00 of 52:58

Download MP3

Keyboard shortcuts
Space or K
Play or pause
Left arrow or J
Back 15 seconds
Right arrow or L
Forward 15 seconds
Home
Back to the start
M
Mute or unmute

The letters and arrows work anywhere on this page except in a text field or on another link or button. Space and Home act on the recording only while the player has focus, so they still scroll the page as usual.

Transcript

Transcribed from the 1978 recording. Corrections are welcome. The text was produced automatically from the audio and may contain errors; section headings were added only as reading aids. The attached audio recording is the authoritative source.

In this lecture

So I’m going to talk about Augustine today and Calvin. I suppose I should say that, refer to that Spanish proverb that is surely Augustinian and Calvinist, when it says that every person is as God made him or her, only a little worse. In any case, I am the better for my association at Columbia Seminary and grateful to the institution One of the problems when you get older is that institutions change and the continuity of institutions, really not in the buildings but in the persons and I believe the only two professors at Columbia Seminary who taught me, who are still here, Dr. Richards and Dr. Cartlidge. I did have a note from Dr. Robinson about a month ago saying that he would not be here, but that he would be praying for this particular week at Columbia Seminary. in any case let me say as sincerely as i can that it is a real joy to be back here an institution to which i feel indebted and with you as colleagues in the presbyterian church i have always been a presbyterian the distinction between arp and presbyterian in due west is quite as critical as racial distinctions in some southern communities.

Albert Brown once said in the Presbyterian Outlook that I was a product of the ARP church, which made it almost impossible for me to go home again. But I feel greatly indebted to my association with ARPs, and I certainly am a better person if I hadn’t grown up in Due West than I would have been if I had grown up most anywhere else. But I’m glad to be with so many of you whom I’ve known in other situations and other places.

How Theology Is Taught in the Congregation

The invitation specified that these lectures should seek to answer the question, how can theology be taught in the local congregation? And it further specified that the answer should at least point to specific methods and procedures, that it should be as concrete as possible, and this is surely a valid request. But the teaching of theology, as the invitation was surely aware, is never simple, nor is it a matter of technique, of procedures and methods. There may be some new and easy way of teaching theology, but I do not know what it is, and I have continually asked those who say there are such new and easy ways to tell me what they are, but I have not yet received an answer. The teaching of theology, it seems to me, takes place in the local church as good, responsible, self-conscious theology informs the life of the congregation and those practices that we have traditionally called the means of grace. this shaping of a congregation’s life by theological concern happens best when it is not planned or programmed but when it flows spontaneously and naturally out of the theologically informed lives of church leaders in particular ministers when theology has been assimilated into the persons into the thought processes of church people it enriches the total life and form of the congregation in a quite fundamental sense the teaching of theology in a congregation cannot be programmed contrived or arranged and certainly it never takes place by committee or bureaucratic decree.

It happens when the church happens, when the situation is right, when certain theological ingredients are present in the life of the congregation. Now, a procedure in these lectures will be, first of all, to identify Four theological ingredients in the congregational situation that provide the context in which theology can be assimilated, learned, and taught.

Four Classical Theological Documents

And as a basis for our reflection, we shall take as our starting point four classical theological documents that relate theology to the congregation and to the pastorate. Augustine’s On Nature and Grace, Calvin’s Institutes, Karl Barth’s Church Dogmatics, the section Reconciliation, and Reinhold Niebuhr’s Nature and Destiny of Man. There are two reasons for approaching the teaching ministry on the basis of these four theological documents and doctrines. First, they illustrate how theology actually informs and shapes the life of a congregation. And theology is taught by the way in which theology is actually embodied in the life and practice of a congregation. and secondly these four particular documents or doctrines when embodied in the life of a congregation provide the context in which the teaching of Christian doctrine can actually take place.

So, first, the teaching of theology in the church begins with an awareness of the holy, a sense of the numinous. The church is not a club, not a therapy group, not an educational institution, not an agency for social change. The church is a people of God who live in the awareness of the mystery that encompasses human existence and who believe that that mystery has been transmuted into meaning in Jesus Christ. And no one has ever said this better than John Calvin did in the Institutes of the Christian religion and no one has ever put more emphatically the life and work of the church teaching and pastoral care in this particular perspective of the holy the perspective is apparent in Calvin’s very understanding of theology the theme that holds Calvin’s theology together is the dialectical relationship of God in man, God’s relationship to man and man’s relationship to God.

As he put it in those remarkable opening words of the Institutes, nearly all the wisdom we possess, that is to say true and sound wisdom, consists of two parts, the knowledge of God and of ourselves. But while joined by many bonds which one precedes and brings forth the other is not easy to discern. He then goes on to say it is certain that man never achieves a clear knowledge of himself unless he has first looked upon God’s face. In theology, everything has to do with God and with the relationship of man to him. The same theme also runs through Calvin’s understanding of the Christian life. the christian life is the fact that every human being has every moment to do with the living god as calvin put it now the great thing is this we are consecrated and dedicated to god in order that we may hereafter think and speak and meditate and do nothing except to his glory for a sacred thing may not be applied to profane uses without marked injury to him we are not our own let not our reason nor our will therefore sway our plans and deeds we are not our own let us therefore not set it as our goal to seek what is expedient to us we are not our own insofar as we can let us therefore forget ourselves and all that is ours conversely we are gods let us therefore live for him and die for him we are gods let his wisdom and will therefore rule all our actions we are Let this, therefore, be the first step that a man depart from himself in order that he may apply the whole force of his ability to the service of God. i call service not only what lies in obedience to god’s word but what turns the mind of man empty of its own carnal sense only to the bidding of god’s spirit now a third illustration of this pervasive theme in calvin’s thought is his doctrine of the church the church differs radically from every human organization in that it is constituted by the acts of God through his word and his spirit.

Martin Luther and John Calvin knew with a clarity that shaped their lives that only one thing is really necessary for the existence of the church, the word of God in preaching and sacrament. Everything else is expendable. however desirable other aspects of the church’s life may be. In the formula that has become a cliché, but that was and may still be the deepest understanding of the reality of the church, wherever we see the word of God purely preached and heard in the sacraments administered according to Christ’s institution, there it is not to be doubted a church of God exists now Calvin said the same thing about the church in his doctrine of predestination and in his doctrine of justification the church is not first of all a human organization but the creation of God brought into being by the divine activity by the word and by the spirit.

The church is, to be sure, secondarily a human activity, a human activity that corresponds to God’s work by his word and spirit, namely faith and love. Now, someone may protest that the church depends upon many other activities, pastoral visitation, church suppers, building programs, budgets, and financial campaigns. many other human activities some of which take place in all human communities but in the church these are all ancillary to that which is the essence of the church’s life the action of God through his word and spirit and the responding human actions of faith and love now these three illustrations drawn from Calvin’s understanding of the nature of theology of the Christian life and of the church all mean that in the church we have to do with the living God, creator of heaven and earth.

The church is not a school, not a therapy center, not a social action agency. It is a community of faith standing in the presence of the Holy Other. In the church, and in all of its activities there must always be the sense of the numinous the all-filled mystery at once frightening and fascinating but in whose presence we stand in awe and devotion. The teaching of theology in the church begins with this awareness and this sensitivity. Now Karl Barth has made this point about the holiness of the church with typical clarity and vigor. Holy means set apart and all this with a final definiteness decisively unalterably because it is God who does it. The term indicates the contradistinction of the Christian community to the surrounding world and in particular to other gatherings and societies which exist in the world the church is not a natural society after the manner of nations nor is it based on social contracts and agreements or temporary and permanent understandings and arrangements it is not a society of necessity and compulsion like the state nor is it a free society for a particular purpose like an order Or a club, or an economic or cultural union. It has its own basis and its own goal. It cannot, therefore, understand itself in the light of the basis of other societies or follow their goals.

The Holy Spirit and the Church

Without this awareness of the holy, or to put it another way, without the presence and gifts of the Holy Spirit, the whole character of the church and teaching in the church are changed. teaching in the church must always be in the context of the holy which only the Holy Spirit can give and here Barth puts it with remarkable directness and clarity without this gift of the Holy Spirit Barth declares even the most holy work is profane the church’s preaching is simply a kind of explanation and instruction or enthusiastic protestation. Is baptism and large supper religious rites like others? Is theology a kind of philosophy? Is mission a species of propaganda? They all may have their interests and importance and practical value from other standpoints, intellectual, moral, psychological, sociological, but they cannot be holy without the work of the living Lord of the community. no institutions within which its activity is done no goodwill on the part of men who act no old or new techniques which are used can make them holy or prevent them again from becoming secular the community is entirely in the hands of its Lord and that means that it is thrown back on his having mercy upon and making its unholy activity holy and acknowledging it as such.

Well, that paragraph from Barth is precisely what I wish to say in the first half of this particular lecture. Now, this awareness of the holy is no human achievement. Certainly, it cannot be programmed or contrived or commanded it always comes as does the church as a gift there is something trite in saying this and all of us know on the top of our minds that the church is God’s gift and that in the church we have to do with the living God and all of us can say the formula the problem is knowing it existentially knowing it in our viscera as it were the problem is having it happen in the congregation the church as an organization the preaching service as an exercise of human skill can all happen by human ingenuity and human planning.

The Pastor as Catalyst of the Holy

But the church in its reality always comes as a gift. There are some things that we can do, and it is more likely to happen if we do them. But finally, the church is always a gift of God. but Calvin was convinced that the pastor is on the human level the catalyst of this experience and of this awareness of the holy the holy must not be construed certainly in moralistic terms and most emphatically not in terms of obedience to certain rules and laws all ministers as Calvin surely know are creatures limited by time and space and more than that they are sinners yet in his lofty doctrine of the ministry he believed that ministers by their persons by the manner in which they carry out their responsibilities were and are a means by which congregations know that they have to do in the life of the church not with another human endeavor but with the Lord God creator of heaven and earth.

For this reason Calvin could speak of ministers as the mouth of God. Now ministers in our time are acutely aware of the danger of being the mouth of God, representatives of God, and this is surely for the good. And yet it is disconcerting that in a time when we do not like to think of ourselves As catalysts of a sense of the holy, we have no similar hesitancy in accepting other signs of privilege, such as titles, jewelry, robes, and the perquisites of an affluent society. When I finished Columbia Theological Seminary, it took some courage to preach in a robe. Now it takes some courage to preach in a business suit. The serious teaching of theology in the local congregation only begins when there is an awareness of the presence of the holy, an awareness that in the church one has to do with the Lord God, creator of heaven and earth.

And apart from this awareness, the church may do many useful things for human well-being, and the church may make the human plight on this planet more bearable but it cannot teach theology or embody theology in its life and practice or experience the personal serenity or the sense of destiny that Christian faith distills from the raw stuff of life. Now, let us come a step further, and let us note that the teaching of theology takes place in the Catholicity, in the context of the Catholicity of the Church. Catholicity has a wide reference, including doctrine itself. But here our concern is with Catholicity in reference to the human situation, the human condition, and with Catholicity as it relates to the holiness of the church. And the classical doctrine document that will serve as our point of reference will be Augustine’s treatise on grace and nature.

Pelagius and the Augustinian Controversy

The Pelagian-Augustinian controversy was next to the Arian debate, the most serious dispute in the history of the church. it had to do with human nature and with the human will with sin and with grace and yet it was also a controversy quite fundamentally about the nature of the christian life and about the nature of the church and for this reason it is important to us Pelagius, according to the little that we know about him, was a great hulk of a man, native of Britain, who arrived in Rome about 384 and remained there until 409, one of those critical transition periods of human history. His physical size was impressive, his personality was also impressive he found a place in sophisticated theological circles among the nobility he was a friend of Rufinus came under the influence of theology of Origen from the east he had arrived in Rome at an opportune time when an old way of life was breaking up and a new way of life was it yet powerless to be borne.

There was little personal discipline, little sense of destiny. The realm of Virgil’s Aeneid, of Romanitas, a society ordered by reason and justice that once inspired the messianic poetry of Virgil was gone and the church was not much better good pagans with their mediocrity or their moral sensitivity came into the church either sensitive or mediocre and in this situation there was inside and outside the church a widespread striving as Peter Brown has put it to create an aristocratic elite. Sensitive, concerned people outside and inside the church wanted to define themselves over against the chaos, the confusion, the undisciplined life that was all about them. Little groups of the elite began to appear, each striving to rise above their neighbors.

An imperial edict about this time would very significantly condemn some of these groups for wanting to be better than everybody else. As the edict puts it, they consider that it is a sure sign of being low born and commonplace think the same as everybody else and a token of exceptional expertise to undermine what is unanimously agreed so Peter Brown Augustine’s biographer concludes behind the councils of perfection of a Pelagius we can sense the high demands of a sense of nobility especially the responsibility that that nobility breeds, a sense of the high demand of the undisciplined of a patrician household. Well, Pelagius was a very impressive person, and his message was challenging, even inspiring, in a decaying society.

The Message of Pelagius

There are three important elements in that message for us. first of all the Christian life as Pelagius understood it was relatively simple there are good people and there are bad people the good people know the will of God and they do it the bad people sin out of perversity out of contempt for God they sin out of set purpose and out of willfulness Pelagius knew the power of habit the power of example and yet habit did not reach deeply into one’s life and its power could be broken by discipline, by will. Pelagius also knew the need for grace, the grace of forgiveness, the grace of the law, the grace of creation. But with it all, life was very simple. There are the good people and there are the bad people. Americans, it has been said, are born Pelagians.

This is true of morally sensitive people in and out of the church, especially those we generally call Christians. The good life, even the Christian life, is simple. The options are clear and simple choices between good and evil. Grace is available in certain aids, especially the knowledge of what is good in the law. The human person and the human will may have been damaged by parents, may have been damaged by society, but the wounds are not very deep. There are the good people and the bad people, and the difference is in human choice and in the social context of life. And secondly, Pelagius wanted a church without spot or wrinkle. as peter brown has put it pelagius thought of the church as a small elite group in a pagan and decaying world the church was an elite community which had achieved a clear understanding of what it was in contrast to the mediocrity of society in general the church was composed of superior people who stood in judgment upon society pelagius wanted not only the perfect individual but also the perfect group, and he imposed perfection not only upon individuals but also upon the church.

And thirdly, Pelagius wanted to reform society. He and his followers were outspoken critics of Roman society. Under his influence, apparently a very great influence, rich young nobility gave up their wealth and renounced their self-seeking. the Pelagians for example were committed to the redistribution of wealth they could not have chosen a more critical issue perhaps nowhere is the heart of Pelagianism and the optimism of Pelagianism more clearly revealed than in the conviction of some of the Pelagian groups that accumulated wealth was just another bad habit that could be shrugged off by Christians on baptism now this vision of the christian life and of a society transformed by the human will by human discipline is very compelling here is the triumph of the human spirit over passion weakness temptation over every obstacle here is the superiority of the human person over the heritage of the past over fate over the corruptions of the social order.

The Pelagians were determined to triumph over the disordered and undisciplined society of which they were a part. They would maintain a different life from the conventional mediocre lives of their neighbors. Now there’s something very Christian in Pelagius’s concern, and certainly every Calvinist should know this. Like Calvin, Pelagius wanted every Christian to be a monk. The counsels of perfection rest upon us all. Unlike Calvin, he believed a sinless life was a simple possibility. He exulted in the grace of God in creation and in the power of the human will. And whenever this vision of the possibilities of human existence is lost, and whenever this zeal to be perfect as our Father in heaven is perfect dies, the Christian community will be the loser. But Pelagius challenged Augustine’s fundamental understanding of the nature of the Christian faith, and especially of the church and the Christian life.

Augustine’s Case for Grace

Pelagius, Augustine thought, obscured the difference between the church and a community of pagans, of good pagans. augustine thought of the church as an end for convalescence not as an aristocratic elite and certainly not as an elite core for social reform surely augustine knew as well as any theologian in the history of the church the significance of the human will the human person organized and directed indeed he defined a person chiefly in terms of the will a person is not what he or she eats not even what he or she thinks a person is as a person loves the two cities were founded by two loves and yet Augustine also knew that there are many things in life beyond the power of the human will and therefore he rejoiced in making a case for grace and the church has rightly recognized the case that he made in calling him the doctor of grace.

As Augustine put it, no subject gives me greater pleasure. For what ought to be more attractive to us sick men than grace, grace by which we are healed? For us lazy men than grace, grace by which we are stirred up? for us men longing to act than grace by which we are helped. Now, Augustine’s case for grace is very difficult to make. It was very difficult for Augustine to make it, and it’s very difficult for us in our time to make it. The ordinary Christian saw in Pelagius only a sincere believer who wanted Christians to take their faith very seriously. If you do not believe this, I ask you to try an experiment. Preach three types of sermons and evaluate both the difficulty in writing those sermons and the responses to those sermons. Most congregations respond enthusiastically to a sermon that exalts to moral activity. especially if the activity does not touch sensitive concerns.

They also respond enthusiastically to sermons that deal with religious aspects of life, prayer, trust in God, the mystery of existence. they respond least well and certainly sermons are most difficult when we attempt to preach the gospel when we attempt to preach the grace of God when we attempt to put together in a way that as many The simple fact is that Pelagius in his day and the Pelagians in our day have popular Christianity on their side. And moreover, Pelagius could and did appeal to the great theological traditions of the East, and it also exalted in human freedom and in the capacity for communion with God.

Original Sin and the Complexity of Sin

In a very real sense, it was Augustine and the Provincial Church of North Africa against the world and against the sophisticated theological and cultural world. now Augustine based his case on the complexity of the human situation which he believed that Pelagius had grossly oversimplified Augustine was always respectful of Pelagius he believed that Pelagius had a zeal for righteousness but as he went on to say not according to knowledge not according to the knowledge of the human situation of Augustine of an Augustine who is the greatest of all Christian psychologists Augustine’s case included original sin indeed original sin was an important factor in Augustine’s case Augustine knew that no baby is ever born now into a situation of innocency the sin of Adam and all of Adam’s descendants infects the life of a newborn child at birth now original sin has always been an offensive idea and in his last days Reinhold Niebuhr confessed that he had probably made a strategic mistake in trying to fling the concept of original sin in the face of modern people and surely Augustine sometimes clumsily related it too much to sex, to conception, and treated it as though it were an infection in the bloodstream or a defect in the genes.

But surely few articles of Christian faith are so empirically verifiable as original sin. The sin which predates our being a sinner, the sin which informs the very structure and fabric of social existence the sin that penetrates our lives in those mysterious ways in which one person penetrates another person’s life before our first conscious act Augustine knew that our situation is not simply that we are sinners but that we are born into a situation where sin is already present. And he knew also that the corruption of human existence is not superficial. It is not a recent habit that can be easily extended. It reaches into the depths of the human person even beyond conscious awareness. he also knew that the corruption was so pervasive in society that the only options open on public issues involve one in evil as when one loyalty has to be denied for the sake of another loyalty Augustine knew and this is the point that I wish to make now Augustine knew that sin is not simply a matter of perversity of contempt for God in a very remarkable sentence one of the most remarkable sentences in all theology in the essay on nature and grace Augustine puts the human situation remarkably well many sins he said are committed through pride but not all happen proudly they happen so often by ignorance by human weakness many are committed by men weeping and grounding in their distress and he He knew that we frequently conquer one sin only to fall victim to another.

He once wrote a rich widow, I have, he says, have often observed this fact of human behavior, that certain people, when sexuality is repressed, avarice seems to grow in its place. Now, Peter Brown, Augustine’s biographer, comments that the Pelagians, in all their shrill denunciations of the ways of the world, never said anything as shrewd as that. In sum, Augustine knew that the Christian life is never simple. The good are never as good as they think they are, and the bad are never as bad as they’re are thought to be. The good is not a simple possibility. Augustine liked to think of sin as concupiscence, but he meant by it not sensuality but self-centeredness, and he knew that it infects our best deeds as well as our worst. As Reinhold Niebuhr put it for contemporary Pelagians.

Our causes are never as righteous and our participation in them never is devoid of self-interest as we think they are. T.S. Eliot has some very remarkable lines that come to mean something to you when you get in your 50s. It goes like from four quartets and it goes like this, let me disclose the gifts reserved for age to set a crown upon your lifetime’s effort first the cold friction of expiring sense without enchantment offering no promise but bitter tastelessness of shallow fruit as body and soul begin to fall asunder second the conscious impotence of rage at human folly and the laceration of laughter at what ceases to amuse. And last, and this is the point of this quotation, and last, the rending pain of reenactment of all that you have done and been, the shame of motives late revealed and the awareness of things ill done and done to others’ harm which once you took for exercise of virtue.

The Church as Hospital for Convalescence

No one ever put it better than that I think and yet how profoundly analytical and true that is in the perspective of age that which once we took for exercise of virtue is is seen as flawed and done to others’ harm. Augustine knew this, and Pelagius did not. Augustine knew that the Pelagian controversy had to do with the nature of the church. For Pelagius, the church is an aristocratic elite, a community of moral heroes. the church was a disciplined army of the Lord in conquest of the world, the flesh and the devil Augustine preferred to think of the church as an end for convalescence he acknowledged, as I have said that the Pelagians had a zeal for God but not according to knowledge the Pelagians thought human beings needed illumination and help augustine thought they needed healing the sinner needs a true confession of weakness not a false sense of capacity the sinner is not healed quickly but must look forward to prolonged precarious convalescence in the end of the church in the end of the church as augustine put it in his track on nature and grace, our present inquiry is about where he was able to descend there from, who moreover is still in the process of cure.

In the process of being healed, even though he is already in the end. God does not, therefore, enjoin impossibilities, but in his injunctions he counsels you both to do what you can for yourself and to ask his aid in what you cannot do. Now, Augustine had faced this same question in his controversy with the Donatists. They, too, wanted a church without spot or wrinkle. though they concentrated their demand upon the priesthood it’s interesting how the early church dealt with this problem holiness they said the church had to be holy and if it wasn’t holy it wasn’t the church and they first tried to say the church is holiness and therefore its existence depended upon the holiness of its members and they wanted to limit forgiveness finally had to put forgiveness in the Apostles’ Creed as an article of faith that was being denied.

They wanted to limit forgiveness after baptism, and that’s the reason people began to postpone baptism, so they could take care of all their sins. If you could time it just right, that was a very convenient thing to do. And they wanted to say there are certain sins that can’t be forgiven at all. Murder and adultery and apostasy. But they finally had to give up on that. You can’t really have a church if it’s going to depend on human holiness, and then they wanted to limit it to the ministers. Well, that also was a precarious read. And finally, it was Augustine, you know, who came to say that the holiness of the church is not primarily the holiness of its members, not primarily the holiness of its priesthood. The holiness of the church is the activity of God that heals, that makes people holy.

The Pelagians and the Donatists were attempting to maintain holiness, but to maintain holiness at the expense of the Catholicity of the Church. And Augustine was attempting to hold together the Catholicity of the Church and the holiness of the Church. the pelagians defined this holiness too much in moralistic terms the donatist in sacramental as well as moralistic terms but augustine who had a concern for morals and for sacraments knew that the holiness of the church in his not in the holiness of its members nor in the holiness of its priest but in the holiness of god in the action of god through his word in spirit by which sinners are healed and made whole again. Well, Augustine has been called rightly the doctor of grace, who celebrated grace.

And by grace, he did not mean simply a good creation, not simply the law, not simply forgiveness, but the forgiving and healing action of God. As Albert Outlaw has put it, grace is God’s freedom to act without any external necessity whatsoever, to act in love beyond human understanding or control, to act in creation, judgment, and redemption, to give his Son freely as mediator and redeemer, to endure the church with the indwelling power and guidance of the Holy Spirit, to shape the destinies of all creation and the end of the two human societies. Grace is God’s unmerited love and favor, prevenient and occurrent. It touches man’s inmost heart and will. It guides and impels the pilgrimage of those called to be faithful. It draws and raises the soul to repentance, praise, and faith. It transforms the human will so that it is capable of doing good. It relieves man’s religious anxiety by forgiveness and the gift of hope. It established the ground of Christian humility by abolishing the ground of human pride.

Choosing Augustine over Pelagius

God’s grace became incarnate in Jesus Christ and it remains eminent in the Holy Spirit in the church God’s grace God’s personal impingement upon impact upon our lives in those myriad ways in which he encounters us in and outside the church it has never been easy to hold together the holiness and the catholicity of the church neither has it been easy to hold together god’s grace as mercy which forgives our sin with god’s grace as power that renews and sanctifies us we have always found it difficult to really believe that god is gracious a stanza that our hymn books omit from faber’s hymn there is a wideness in god’s mercy puts it very well But we make his love too narrow by false limits of our own, and we magnify his strictures with a zeal he will not own.

Well, Pelagius was, by the standards of American church life, a wonderful Christian man. even if some of his critics said he was overweight and too prideful he was a challenging figure dealing with the relevant critical issues of Roman society and Augustine in comparison was really not with it he was a stodgy churchman of a provincial North African province and his battle with Pelagius was in a real sense Augustine against the world a provincial churchman against the sophisticated leadership of the church he believed in such things as original sin and the necessity of infant baptism and his hopes for this life were relatively modest he wrote a very great book some would say the greatest of all Christian books The City of God to say that the meaning of life is to be found in no human achievement however great and that the security of life is to be found in no human achievement however remarkable but only in God Now, the temptation for us is always to choose Pelagius over Augustine, but if you’re looking for a pastor, no matter how Pelagian you may be, you better choose an Augustine who knew how complex human existence is. and there is a radical difference between the kind of teaching that is done in the church by the Pelagians and that is done in the church by the Augustinians in the long term common sense wisdom of the church Pelagius has been accounted as a heretic and Augustine as the doctor of grace. And we ought to learn from that in the teaching and life of the church today.

Columbia Forum Alumni Lectures

  1. 1The Reformed PerspectiveLecture 1 of 3 · 1978This lecture
  2. 2The Freedom of the Word and the SpiritLecture 2 of 3 · 1978
  3. 3The Teaching of Theology in the Local CongregationLecture 3 of 3 · 1978

Cite this recording

Leith, John H. “The Reformed Perspective.” 1978. Audio recording, MP3. Sermons & Lectures, Foundation for Reformed Theology. https://foundationrt.org/resource/the-reformed-perspective/.

More from Sermons & Lectures

All 41 sermons and lectures

The Reformed Perspective

0:00 of 52:58

Back to top of lecture

Stay in touch.

Receive seminar announcements, new bibliographies, and quiet word from the Foundation a few times each year.

See the work you support.

Small groups of around six to eight pastors read in advance and gather for a week, with a significant portion of their room, board and travel reimbursed.