The Freedom of the Word and the Spirit

Dr. Leith reflects on the relationship between Scripture and the Holy Spirit in the Reformed tradition, exploring how the Word comes alive through the Spirit’s work in the community of faith.

Recorded
Length
Series
Columbia Forum Alumni Lectures, 2 of 3
Skip to the transcript

The Freedom of the Word and the SpiritDr. John H. Leith, 1978

0:00 of 51:59

Download MP3

Keyboard shortcuts
Space or K
Play or pause
Left arrow or J
Back 15 seconds
Right arrow or L
Forward 15 seconds
Home
Back to the start
M
Mute or unmute

The letters and arrows work anywhere on this page except in a text field or on another link or button. Space and Home act on the recording only while the player has focus, so they still scroll the page as usual.

Transcript

Transcribed from the 1978 recording. Corrections are welcome. The text was produced automatically from the audio and may contain errors; section headings were added only as reading aids. The attached audio recording is the authoritative source.

In this lecture

I’ve sometimes said that when you move from a congregation to educational institution you discover that students are not as grateful for what you do as congregations, but I’m grateful for Charlie Couser. I do think a teacher should require or should teach in such a way that students have to say yes or no to what the teacher has to say and I’m sure if you look long enough you could get some who would not say yes but who would say no. In any case it’s a very happy privilege for me to be back and it’s a very happy privilege and has always been since to the life of the church to come in contact with those who were members of those classes in 55, 56. Yesterday we talked about the perspective of holiness, the context in which teaching can take place, and then we talked about the Catholicity of the church.

The Freedom of God

This morning let us come a step further and look at a third perspective that informs the experience of a congregation where real teaching of theology can take place. And this is an awareness and a sensitivity to the freedom of God. Now, no theologian has understood and exalted in the freedom of God over the order, the procedures, the structures of the church more than Karl Barth. And he rejoiced in this freedom without repudiating polity or the orders of worship or the procedures for carrying out the business of the church. One of the great achievements of Karl Barth’s dogmatics is his incorporation, not only of ecclesiology, but of a great deal of practical theology in his dogmatics, especially in volume four on reconciliation. Barth’s point of departure is very close to what I was saying yesterday, his point of departure for the understanding of the church was his conviction that the church has its existence first of all by virtue of the divine activity.

The Christian community, the true church, arises and is only as the Holy Spirit works, the quickening power of the living Lord Jesus. And it continues and is only he sanctifies men and their human work, building up them and their work into the true church. It is a greatness of Barth that he knew that the church is not a religious society, not a pious society, as so great a theologian as Schleiermacher had said. He certainly knew that it was not a therapy group or a community for social change, or a study group. Of course, the church is all of these things, and it can be studied as such by sociologists. When it is perceived in this way, that which makes the church the church and that which distinguishes it from every other organization is missing.

If the church is a pious society, and if the church is a study group, then the Bible can be studied and taught as literature and theology can be studied as another philosophy. It is a notorious fact that most mainline churches today are far more comfortable studying the Bible than they are in using the Bible devotionally, that they’re far more comfortable analyzing social issues than they are seriously assimilating, studying theology. As a matter of fact, most ministers, as well as laypeople, find it far easier to discuss, in quotes, the Christian position on the Panama Canal than the doctrine of God you can try that and I would wager that overwhelmingly in the church You will find more ministers who can talk intelligently about the Panama Canal Treaty than they can about the intricacies of the doctrine of God, about the problem of transcendence, for example.

And that, surely, is a commentary upon the life of the church today. Hence, the awareness of the church as the creation of God is the precondition for teaching theology as a matter of life and death, as a matter of the most fateful decisions of life. Now the mystery of the church, the spiritual reality, the third dimension as Barth calls it, cannot be scientifically observed and measured. It can only be believed, as the creed puts it, I believe the holy catholic church. That is to say, I believe that in the mixed company that that can be studied as just another human organization, there exists the people of God. In the old theological formula, the church is in a sense invisible, in that we cannot penetrate its mystery. But the visible church attests the invisible glory and reality.

The visible lives wholly by the invisible. The church lives by the awakening power of the Holy Spirit, not by its own action. The church is not God, but it is responsible to God. The awakening power of the Holy Spirit is the important thing. This means that the church must not take itself too seriously, that it must not live too confidently on the phenomenal level, that the church as a human work does not have the last word. on the one hand Karl Barth takes the church with incredible seriousness as the work of God and on the other hand he can take the church as a human work simply for what it is a human work in response to the divine work to come at it from another angle, the unity of the church is its unity in Jesus Christ. And because of the unity of the church in Jesus Christ, Karl Barth can accept the historical character of the church without being unduly disturbed.

Each community has its own locality, its own environment, tradition and language unity cannot be secured by wiping out individual differences and certainly Barth says it cannot be imposed by any form of church government by any hierarchy by any bureaucracy the reality of the church is the activity of God by his word and spirit which brings the church into being and which sanctifies it. And in this work and in this activity is its unity. Everything else is a human work. Now human work is not therefore unimportant.

Worship as Human Work

Faith and love and their diverse expressions are the appropriate response to the activity of God. Worship, a very human work, is at the heart of the church’s life. As Barth puts it, assembly for worship is self-evidently the center and the presupposition of the whole Christian life, the atmosphere in which it is lived. It is not only in worship that the community is edified and edifies itself, but it is here first that this continually takes place. And if it does not take place here, it does not take place anywhere. Worship is a human work but it is a work by which the church lives on the human level and it is therefore important. Worship, Barth insisted, must be governed by biblical theological rubrics rather than by aesthetic, psychological, cultural, or personal considerations.

Yet Barth knew that worship was a human work subject to the freedom of God. In discussing the place of prayer and worship, for example, Barth illustrated the human freedom that comes from knowing that worship is a human work, not a divine work. For example, Barth illustrates the freedom one should have concerning the orders of worship in this way. In detail, it has to be considered whether the prayers before and after preaching are not to be brought into much closer connection even with it externally, not being separated by congregational singing, organ music, but forming a threefold complex opened and closed by singing. Again, it ought to be considered whether these prayers should not always be worked out afresh so that instead of recurring and stereotyped fashion from a printed book or sheet, they are newly fashioned and therefore prepared with a sermon for each Sunday in honor of the living Lord of the living community. again it must be considered whether the antithesis of the confession of sin and the promise of grace naturally in the reverse order would not be better placed in the context of preaching rather than in the opening prayer or rather the questionable little drama which serves as a commencement of divine worship in many places the opening prayer being reserved for thanksgiving for the call of God which gathers the community and intercession for the presence and activity of the Holy Ghost.

Again, it has to be considered whether the Lord’s Prayer, best repeated by the whole congregation, would not better come at the end or even at the beginning of the opening prayer rather than at the conclusion of the final prayer. Finally, it must be asked whether this final prayer should not for the most part and decisively instead of occasionally or not at all follow the example of the Liturgy of Chrysostom and consist in intercession for the whole state of Christ’s Church, for all the semi-Christian and non-Christian world, for all the men who are, sin, or suffer in so many ways, especially for those who hold positions of responsibility, so that at the climax of the service and in transition to the administration of the Lord’s Supper, there is the necessary opening of the doors and windows to the outside world, and this in the best possible form, namely of calling upon God, I’ve read that at length to demonstrate the kind of freedom that Barth had in dealing with the worship of the church, which he understood as a human work in response to the divine work that constituted the church.

Church Order and Polity

Now, moving from worship to church order, Church Order, Barth insisted, is critically important for the life of the church. He knew that the church is a fellowship, a community, but it is a fellowship ordered by law, the law of Christ. Some German historians who contributed to Barth’s early theological education had insisted that church law is only for those who are weak in faith, and that the true church, the true fellowship, can exist without order and without law. Brunner too, in his early emphasis on the church as a personal community in response to the divine word, came very close to saying the same thing. Barth insists that the reality of the church is not church law, not church polity, but that church law is not therefore unimportant.

Instead of rejecting church law or polity, Barth argued, is it not wiser to argue that the juridification and the bureaucratization, that is the reduction of church life to a matter of forms and techniques, are symptoms of disorder which we can counter not by a rejection of the problem of law or dissolution of order, but only by a recognition and assertion of the true order of the community, that they constitute a lawlessness of the church in face of which we have to maintain the form of law which corresponds to the substance of the matter and therefore a true church law. But this true church law is that which derives from the basic law valid in the church, that is from the Christological ecclesiological concept of the community. For all of the problematical nature of his concrete answer, Calvin was fundamentally right when he said.

That the church, the true church, ought to be governed by the policy, the polity, that our Lord Jesus has established. But note that Calvin says, we believe. This is a statement of faith. It is thus a statement which has Jesus Christ as its theme and content. And because it has Jesus Christ, it also has the order established by him, and therefore the consequent obligation to rule the church in correspondence with this order. In face of this, the arguments of the church historians and of Brunner are caught in a vicious circle. Because they ignore the basic Christological, ecclesiastical law of the church, they are forced to seek a definition of the church, which will make the question of church law impossible.

Education as Human Work

And because they eliminate the question of church law, they are betrayed into this definition of the church and unnecessarily blind to its basic Christological ecclesiastical character. What Barth is saying here is that the church is not polity, but that polity is not therefore unimportant, but it must be a polity that’s consonant with the nature of the church’s reality. Here again is illustration of a human freedom, corresponds to the divine freedom of not only the orders of worship, but also over the polity of the church. And now for a third illustration, education, like worship in church order, is a human work. it must be valued for what it is but only for what it is as Barth has so aptly said the Christian community is more than a school and you cannot reduce the church to a school but it is also a school to quote Barth the overestimation of this element of its action in the days of protestant orthodoxy with its teaching sermons catechetical drill was no doubt mistaken but so too is the underestimation which has become customary and popular in more recent times in the form of the well-known but rather trivial antithesis between doctrine, which supposedly appeals only to the understanding or even the memory, and life, which it is thought can be immediately accessible apart from these.

In both cases, the basic error is a confusion of that which God alone can do and does with that which it is the business and the task of the community to do. The real knowledge which wins and claims the whole man and therefore his understanding and disposition, will and heart, can only be the work of God. It belongs, however, to the witness of the community which serves this work of God that in a limited but definite way it should contain instruction which in the first instance is addressed to the understanding and memory concerning that which might arise as living knowledge as its theme and its fulfillment. Barth is here attempting to state theoretically and theologically what is very difficult to maintain in practice namely a balance between the orders, structures and procedures of the church and the essential reality of the church as a people of God. The structures, orders, procedures are all human works. And therefore, Barth finds it easy to modify them or even to dispense with them, but never in an arbitrary or callous way.

From Christendom to Voluntary Church

They are human works that respond to the activity of God, but they are not God only human works of a mixed character now let us set over against what Barth has said the reality of the church in our time the most decisive fact about the church today as a human work is its existence in a new kind of society. We have made the journey from the church of the people of God in a parish situation in Christendom to the church as a voluntary community in a free, pluralistic, mobile, urban, industrial, mass media-dominated society. Let me say that again because I think it is fundamental to understand if one is to deal with the reality of the church. We are now at the end of the journey from the parish church in Christendom, which was the model of the medieval church, of the Reformation church, to the voluntary church in a free, pluralistic, secular, mobile, urban, industrial, mass media-dominated society.

Or as Martin Marty has put it, the church from a society in which all the sanctions support the church in what is perceived to be the Christian way of life to the church and the society in which few if any of the sanctions support the church and the Christian way of life. John Calvin accepted the idea of Christendom. He knew that Christendom was a pretense. Rather than rejecting Christendom, he sought to make it a reality, at least in Geneva. And wherever the Calvinists went, they carried with them this vision of the Holy Community. And to a remarkable degree, they transformed Scotland and built the new Jerusalem in England’s green and pleasant land, at least the Puritans attempted to, and sought to illustrate in Massachusetts the possibility of a Christian society.

Calvin did not reject Christendom. He sought to make it a reality, and neither did he reject the parish church. He believed that the parish system in which the congregation is defined geographically is the best way of ordering the church’s life. Even members of the Westminster Assembly believed that the parish church was the best way of ordering the church’s life, and they had great resentment against those who invaded parishes and set up competing preaching points. All of this, the parish church in Christendom, came apart. with the advance of a secular society in which the official commitments of society were no longer Christian. In Christendom, not everyone was Christian, but in Christendom, the society was officially committed to what was perceived to be a Christian understanding of the nature of reality.

This all began to come apart in the 13th century, and today we have seen the fulfillment of the secular trends of the past centuries in our own time. In the 17th and 18th centuries we had the invention of the denominational pattern of church life. John Calvin could not have imagined a denomination and if he could have imagined a denomination he would not have accepted it as a valid way of ordering the church’s life. The denominational pattern was an invention of Calvinists in large measure, of Puritans. Denomination is by definition the conviction that this community is the church, but it is not the full manifestation of the church. When the American frontier was settled, you already had the movement toward the secularization of society. You had the advent of denominations as a pattern for ordering the church’s life, and the frontier was free and open.

There were no parishes on the frontier, and those churches that attempted to establish parishes in America failed. The frontier was open. So in America we began with a society increasingly secular and with a pluralism of Protestant denominations in the same community. But if Christendom was dead, Protestantism, at least for many of us in the South, had taken its place. Let me say parenthetically here, the community in which I grew The public schools grew up in South Carolina in the 1930s. It was no longer Christendom, but it was Protestantdom. The public schools were Protestant schools. All the sanctions of the community supported and undergirded what was perceived to be a Christian understanding of reality and a Christian way of life. Moreover, transportation was limited, it was virtually impossible for young people to get out of the sight of older people who would recognize them, who knew their parents and who shared their parents’ worldview and perspective.

It’s impossible to be anonymous in this kind of society. was the extension of the family, uncles and aunts, grandparents, and the public school was a Protestant school that enforced all the sanctions of the community. This is no longer true. It is no longer true even in the South. We are now a highly pluralistic society, not simply a pluralism of Protestant denominations, not simply a pluralism of Christian denominations or Hebraic Christian denominations, but a pluralism of almost all conceivable ways of understanding reality and human behavior. In Richmond, Virginia today, certainly every style of life is acceptable so long as significant damage is not done to another human being or to property. in this kind of society the church is a very free voluntary institution in america today we have greater freedom to be or not to be the church and people in the western world at least some places in the western world have enjoyed in almost 1500 years this is an incredible sort of freedom a highly voluntary society.

Of course, legally, the church in America has always been voluntary, almost always voluntary, but there was a psychological compulsion. But today, there is no great psychological compulsion to be the church. People are free to be the church or not to be the church as they wish. They’re free to change traditions. A few people in the history of the human race on this planet have been free to change their traditions. And more than this, this is a mass media-dominated society. The mass media penetrates our bedrooms, our living rooms, our dining rooms, and there proclaims alien views of life. If you do not believe this, take off one day and listen to one or two or three soap operas and record on a sheet of paper the worldview, the principles of human behavior that are embodied in those soap operas.

And if one does not believe that the impact of the worldview, the style of life as embodied in soap operas will not affect human conduct in the long run, then I think one is being very naive. A familiarity does not always breed contempt. It may encourage us to adopt these styles of life. In the community in which I came up, the church, the leaders in the church, pretty well controlled what came into the community, as well as what went out. Now, it was radio, but radio had not been developed as radio has been developed in our time. A few years ago, I asked a professor at Catholic University if the changes that had occurred at the Vatican Council were for good. It appeared that the Pope was opposed to these changes, and his reply was, yes, they were for good, because there was no way to keep Catholic seminarians from reading Time magazine or looking at the television set.

And because it was impossible to keep Time magazine out of their hands, to keep them from looking at the television set, the changes were for good. The church would have to live with the modifications that had already begun in its life. This is the kind of society, the kind of world in which we live. And it is further aggravated by the fact that we are highly mobile and frequently anonymous Human behavior and past has been frequently determined and set by the fact that we were recognized that we were not People live anonymous lives in the city. Very interested in 1965, Harvey Cox published The Secular City in which rural areas were bad and the city was close to heaven. He exalted in the freedom that the anonymity of the city brings to people, it gives to people to be who they are.

It is not strange that college students were greatly excited by The Secular City because college students, by and large, have good IQs and physical stamina, effective personalities. They have the world, as it were, in their control, in their pockets, and they exulted in this freedom to do their thing. Cox never raised the question about whether or not doing one’s thing was really good. In many cases, it was not pleasant to behold. But on the other hand, one can also argue that this great new freedom that anonymity brings to people in the city was the occasion for the destruction of more people than it was for the building up in the enhancement of human personality. And it is significant, I think, that almost at the same time that Harvey Cox published The Secular City, a secular urbanologist at MIT and Harvard, Edward Banfield, should have published The Unheavenly City, in which he suggested that there was really no solution to the problem of the city.

In any case, we live today in a radically new kind of society that has called in question all the structures, all the procedures of the church. In the older society, if the church did not educate its people, the community would educate them in the ways of God. I think I can illustrate that truth by Abraham Lincoln. One can argue that Abraham Lincoln, who was not a member of the organized church, was the best theologian that America produced in the 19th century. Certainly, it did not produce any greater theological writing than Lincoln’s Second Inaugural. In our century, an Abraham Lincoln is simply not a possibility. In a secular society, there are not likely to be people who grow up being informed by the words of the Bible and by the content of Christian faith that Abraham Lincoln was in 19th century society. Now, this crisis of the church in our time is very similar, it seems to me, to the crisis that was created by the 19th century and the Enlightenment.

The Crisis of the Enlightenment

This is a crisis of social structure. In the 19th century, we had a crisis of theology. The development of Protestant theology, the development of Reformed theology, I think can best be understood in terms of the following periodization. First of all, you have classic Reformed theology, from Martin Luther’s Theses in 1517 to the death of Calvin, say, in 1564. Here was a vibrant, vigorous formulation of Protestant understanding of Christian faith, largely by preachers. It was followed by a period of Protestant scholasticism when this preacher’s theology was refined and put in writing of careful textbooks by the great Protestant scholastic theologians. All of this theology is theology of very high technical qualities. You get it in the Westminster Assembly and in the writings of people like Turretin.

This was followed, it seems to me, by a third period that one can call the crisis of the Enlightenment in the 19th century, roughly from 1776 to 1918, when the church experienced the crisis created by the intellectual and cultural changes of the time. During this period, the impact of the scientific revolution, which has changed the way people think about the world and relate themselves to the world more radically than anything else that has happened in our history. And alongside the scientific revolution that came to its climax, emotional climax, theologically in Darwin, you had Karl Marx who challenged the church in decisive ways suggested that theology was epiphenomenal to the economic process that the way we turn make our living Determines what we think theologically and ethically.

Challenged by Freud. Challenged by the new methods of critical historical study. Challenged by the new awareness of living religions. And challenged by the industrialization of society. now the church responded to this kind of challenge in three clear-cut ways one of these was fundamentalism some fundamentalists were simply pietistic they went on reading their bibles and saying their prayers as though nothing had happened most of us know pietistic fundamentalists who went on as though the enlightenment the 19th century had not occurred and then there were the fighting fundamentalists who defied the 19th century and said it’s just not so and if it and if it is we’re not going to have it and then there were those fundamentalists who went a step further and became the Lord’s FBI agents to kind of ferret out the heretics which many of us have had some experience with and then there were the Liberals the Liberals instead of ignoring or defying these changes sought to assimilate these changes into a Christian understanding of life.

They were determined to be modern people and therefore to assimilate the new knowledge into Christian understanding. This was a great theological experiment and endeavor. In some situations it succeeded and in others, the liberals simply became modern men rather than Christians who live in the modern era. And then in Karl Barth, we get beyond the liberal fundamentalist controversy. On the one hand, Barth was neither a fundamentalist nor a liberal. Over against the fundamentalists, he at least in theory accepted the critical study of the Bible, accepted modern science, he accepted the social revolution. But over against the liberals he affirmed the discontinuity between Christian faith and other religions, the discontinuity between God and man, the discontinuity between the church and the world, and so forth.

Now theology goes beyond the fundamentalist liberal controversy and resolved in a new way. Now, the Barthian, Niebuhrian, Tillichian resolution of these problems was somewhat premature as became apparent in the late 50s and the attempt in very diverse ways to reopen some of the questions believed to be prematurely answered by these great theologians of the 20s, 30s, and 40s. And then there was the social gospel. All the liberals were social gospelers, but not all social gospelers were liberals, so you cannot identify the social gospel with liberalism. But the social gospel was the attempt to ask, how do Christians live in this new kind of society ethically? A question that still is before us. And in many cases, the social gospel has answered this question too simply.

But it was an attempt to adjust Christian faith to a new social situation, industrialized society. What does it mean? The church had known what it was to be honest in an agricultural rural society, but what does it mean to be honest if you happen to be president of General Motors or president of the United Automobile Workers? This was the question that the social gospel attempted to answer. now it seems to me that the kind of theological crisis which was precipitated in the 19th century and it continued into the 20th century is now being precipitated in the social ordering of the church by the crisis in our society the church confronts the same kind of challenge in the transition from the parish church in Christendom to the voluntary church in a free, pluralistic, mobile, urban, industrial, mass media society that it faced theologically in the 19th century.

A New Fundamentalism of Structure

And I would like to suggest, and I do this somewhat tentatively, it became very clear to me several days ago when I was reviewing what I was saying today, that the church is reacting to this crisis in very much the same way. Why? That it reacted to the theological crisis. There is some evidence that just as you had a theological fundamentalism, we are now in danger of a fundamentalism of the book of church order. We are now in danger of a fundamentalism, not of theology, but of the church’s structures, procedures, and techniques. Over against this confused situation, there is a tendency to say that every jot and tittle of the book of church order has to be obeyed. Now that’s the new doctrine in the church. Actually, in American Presbyterianism, we got along without a book of church order for the first hundred years.

And always theology has taken precedence over order. Church polity has always been subordinate to the gospel in our tradition and in the Lutheran tradition. One of the characteristics of the early Protestant Reformation in both its Lutheran and Calvinist form was a radical subordination of polity to the gospel. And yet it was suggested several years ago in Presbyterian life that the book of church order had to be strictly interpreted and strictly imposed upon the church. But you could have a loose interpretation of the confession of faith. I would suggest that this is a kind of fundamentalism of polity that is comparable to the theological fundamentalism that emerged in the 19th century. And fundamentalism, whether it’s a fundamentalism of theology or whether it’s a fundamentalism of polity is equally damaging to the life of the church.

Or in any case, they’re both damaging. We see also this trend in worship. The church has always celebrated a certain freedom in worship. At least for most of our history, we have celebrated a certain freedom. It is interesting that in this time of social change, there are the attempts to say that this is the canonical form of worship. Now it suggests that this is a fundamentalism in the field of worship that again is comparable to the attempt to impose on the church a fundamentalism in theology. Fundamentalism, whether it’s a fundamentalism of theology or polity or worship or education is always, it seems to me, damaging. So I submit for what it’s worth that there is a parallel between this crisis involving the orders and structures and procedures of the church and the crisis for theology that was created by the Enlightenment and the 19th century.

And it seems to me that in dealing with this new crisis, we ought to be able to learn something from the mistakes and tragedies of the fundamentalist liberal controversy in the church in the late 19th century and the first three or four decades of this century. In education, we are troubled by the theological crisis and by the social crisis. Theological time is not the same as chronological time.

Words of Caution

And in the education and teaching ministry of the church, we are troubled today by the residual impact of the fundamentalist, liberal controversy. We are also troubled by the social crisis, and in this troubled and confused situation it seems to me certain words of caution ought to be enunciated. We ought not to become too enamored with change. Change is not necessarily good. It is important to note that we are talking together now in 1978, and we ought not to to read the situation either in our society or in the church as if it were 1940. Perhaps in 1940, someone needed to challenge the rigid orthodoxy that was dominant in southern Presbyterianism. The good of the church, for example, could be served in 1940 when someone refused to assert an apodictic belief in the virgin birth. for the sake of the theological freedom of the church.

But surely that is no longer the case. Perhaps our church curriculums were too simplistically biblical in 1940, but that is surely not the case today. Let me say here, parenthetically, that in 1940 people grew up knowing the Bible. The culture taught them the Bible, even if the church didn’t. Today that is certainly no longer the case. The change has been very recent. I suspect my, I imagine my daughter learned more Bible when she was in the second grade or maybe it was the third grade in Gunnar Park schools in Richmond from a good Baptist teacher who told her a Bible story every day. I remember at that time we had on campus at Union Seminary a minister from the Christian Reformed Church who came to my office once to talk about these Christian public schools.

A phenomenon, he said, he didn’t know existed. And I asked him what he meant. He said, well, your public schools are Christian schools. You have prayer before lunch. You have teachers who tell Bible stories. But that no longer happens in the schools in Richmond. Perhaps our curriculums in 1940 were too simplistically biblical. But surely that’s not the case today. Perhaps we talk too much in 1940 about God, too little about our obligation to all the children of God. but surely that is no longer our situation the word of caution therefore needs to be expressed against too great an impatience with all the theologies with all the forms of church life in 1940 perhaps we were frozen in our traditions but today we are too alive, it seems to me, to all the Pied Pipers of our society, to all the pressure groups, to all the enticements of a rapidly changing social order.

The Inertia of History

In a very interesting book, The History of Future, to Heilbroner speaks of the inertia of history as one of the great molding forces of history that we ought to appreciate. He says this humble characteristic of historical inertia is responsible for more history than all the campaigns, the movements, and the revolutions of our society. Now, as Brunner goes on to say, we ought not to depreciate this historical inertia. This historical inertia is rooted, he suggests, in our very nature as human beings Human beings persist in living their lives in familiar ways This inertia has biological and psychological roots And more than this, it is a protective reflex for the overwhelming majority of men and women who know very little but who know this that life is fragile and this inertia is a protective self reflex against sudden changes that can destroy the fragile gift of life and its achievements it is of great value he goes on to say when a small error can spell disaster it is a simple fact that a decision made in 30 minutes by a A committee in the life of the church can undo the achievement of a century of devoted effort from Christian people.

The inertia, therefore, Heilbroner concludes, of ideologies and of institutions is often lamentable, but it is also a protection against the ever-present Tide Pipers who lead off in unprofitable directions. Well, that seems to me is our situation in education today and teaching ministry in the church. On the one hand, we simply cannot repeat what our forefathers said theologically. As great as is the theology of Augustine and as great as is the theology of Calvin, and we simply cannot repeat it, memorize it, and proclaim it in our time. But on the other hand, we cannot ignore it, reject it, refuse to be taught by it. There is a better solution. We can assimilate it and state it in the idiom and the language of the culture of our time. the extraordinary historical dynamism of the recent past underscores a need for caution in the teaching of the church it underscores the need for accepting and recognizing the freedom of god the freedom of god over the structures and orders and procedures of our society but on the other hand which accepts the orders procedures of our society and the theological heritage of the church as a human work but as a human work which is nonetheless important for the ongoing life of the church

Columbia Forum Alumni Lectures

  1. 1The Reformed PerspectiveLecture 1 of 3 · 1978
  2. 2The Freedom of the Word and the SpiritLecture 2 of 3 · 1978This lecture
  3. 3The Teaching of Theology in the Local CongregationLecture 3 of 3 · 1978

Cite this recording

Leith, John H. “The Freedom of the Word and the Spirit.” 1978. Audio recording, MP3. Sermons & Lectures, Foundation for Reformed Theology. https://foundationrt.org/resource/the-freedom-of-the-word-and-the-spirit/.

More from Sermons & Lectures

All 41 sermons and lectures

The Freedom of the Word and the Spirit

0:00 of 51:59

Back to top of lecture

Stay in touch.

Receive seminar announcements, new bibliographies, and quiet word from the Foundation a few times each year.

See the work you support.

Small groups of around six to eight pastors read in advance and gather for a week, with a significant portion of their room, board and travel reimbursed.