Remembering the Reformation

Dr. Leith reflects on the significance of the Protestant Reformation: its theological recovery of the gospel and its enduring importance for the church today.

Recorded
Length
Skip to the transcript

Remembering the ReformationDr. John H. Leith, 1990

0:00 of 33:04

Download MP3

Keyboard shortcuts
Space or K
Play or pause
Left arrow or J
Back 15 seconds
Right arrow or L
Forward 15 seconds
Home
Back to the start
M
Mute or unmute

The letters and arrows work anywhere on this page except in a text field or on another link or button. Space and Home act on the recording only while the player has focus, so they still scroll the page as usual.

Transcript

Transcribed from the 1990 recording. Corrections are welcome. The text was produced automatically from the audio and may contain errors; section headings were added only as reading aids. The attached audio recording is the authoritative source.

In this lecture

There’s always a great privilege to share in the life of this particular congregation. Sharing this life because of the role this congregation has played in the Presbyterian and Christian community in America. And because your ministers are my friends. Let us pray. Follow, O God, the preaching of thy word with the blessing of thy Spirit Grant that insofar as it is true, it shall be undergirded by thy power Insofar as it is false, it may be quickly forgotten and do no harm In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit Amen Last Wednesday was the 473rd anniversary of Martin Luther’s 95 theses, which he nailed to the church door at Wittenberg, or as some prefer to say more politely, mailed them to the Archbishop. but whether he nailed them or mailed them he set in motion the events which we now call the Protestant Reformation and today you and I are different persons different personalities from what we would have been because the Reformation happened and we live in a nation whose ethos, culture, institutions are different from what they would have been if the Reformation had not happened.

Remembering the Reformation

The Reformation, therefore, has to do with our identity as persons, as citizens, and above all, as believers. And hence it is worthwhile to remember, to recall our identity as a way of affirming our deepest convictions. Yet a sermon on the Reformation is something of a contradiction in terms. For all the Reformers, without exception, insisted that sermons should be the simple, plain, unadorned exposition and application of Scripture. Indeed, it was this emphasis upon the sermon as the center of worship and the sermon as the intelligible exposition of Scripture that shaped our communities and that shaped our lives. Yet a sermon on remembering the Reformation is not altogether out of place against the background of the Reformation and also in the context of two factors two movements or events in our time which force us to take the Reformation more seriously and therefore to take scripture more seriously.

There is justification, it seems to me, in using the Reformation, the secular, humanist, pluralistic context of the Christian community’s life today and the emergence of Islam rather than communism as a primary alternative to Christian faith in our world as the context in which we can understand more clearly the significance of the words of our text from Paul’s letter to the Romans. If you confess with your lips that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead you will be saved. For there is no distinction between Jew and Greek the same Lord is Lord of all and bestows his riches upon all who call upon him. For everyone who calls upon the name of the Lord will be saved. But how are men to call upon him in whom they have not believed, and how are they to believe in him of whom they have never heard?

So faith comes from what is heard. And what is heard comes from the preaching of Christ. What do these words mean for us as individuals, as witnesses to the Christian faith, and as a congregation which lives by hearing the word of God in our particular time? Let us begin with the Reformation background. And let us note, first of all, that the Reformation had its origin in the bruised spirits and the aggrieved consciences of human beings.

The Theological Origin of the Reformation

Historians have sought for a long time to find the origins of the Reformation. In large measure, economic forces and nationalist forces and political forces are the social movements of the time. Some have even found it in the difference between the temperament of people in northern Europe from the temperament of people in southern Europe. And one of the more popular explanations of the Reformation, even among Protestants themselves, is that it was a reaction against the breakdown of morals in society, but in particular, the breakdown of morals and the corruption of the church. But it is becoming increasingly clear that the reformations cannot be explained in terms of economic and political and social factors, and nor can it be explained in terms of a reaction to corruptions in the church.

The decisive origin of the Reformation was in the bruised spirits and the aggrieved consciences of human beings in the presence of God amid the chaotic events of history. For Martin Luther, the fundamental human problem is not political. And neither was it economic. And neither was it social. The primary human problem was in the anguish and the guilt of a sinful person in the presence of a righteous God. For Ulrich Zwingli and Zurich and Calvin in Geneva, it was a slightly different emphasis upon the desperate need of lonely individuals in a hostile world, adrift to hear the word of God and to find in that word the purpose and the meaning of their lives. What does it mean to be a human being? And how does a human being stand in the presence of God, the ground and source of one’s existence?

In the presence of God to whom one is unconditionally obligated and responsible. how does one meet the crises and challenges of life with the serenity and the dignity and poise of those who trust in the living God medieval Catholicism had lost its ability to answer these basic questions it suggested that these questions could be answered by pilgrimages by buying indulgences by various human works and if medieval Catholicism had existed today it would have added by joining a cause whereby we certify and prove ourselves righteous before God and guarantee the completion of our lives. Increasingly the church was preoccupied with the concerns of its own existence. The revenues of the church were used in an alarming degree to construct baroque buildings away from the congregation, to enhance a curia, which we today would call a bureaucracy, a church structure that did not mediate the grace of God to wounded human hearts.

Now today, we no longer experience guilt in the same way that Luther did, nor meaninglessness, yet if modern people do not experience guilt as Luther did, they surely experience it in that strange and pervasive awareness of the disparity between what we know God intended us to be and what we know we actually are. the guilt we feel about the unfulfilled possibilities of our life. The possibilities that lie beyond our highest efforts. We may not feel guilty before God, but we feel guilty that we have been poor parents or not successful in our careers or that we do not love. There can be no question, I think, that people in our time experience the same anguish in the presence of historical forces which overwhelm us and threaten our future. We become frantic before the threat of a nuclear holocaust.

We become angry or pathologically guilty in the midst of racial conflicts. Even with the marvels of modern science, we no less than medieval people know that the world is not responsive to our wishes. The Reformation began in the awareness that the basic human problem is not economic, political, or social, but theological. And it moved from that to give a theological answer to that problem. It is true enough that political, economic, and social forces influenced the Reformation, yet with an amazing unanimity. the reformers all refused to identify the gospel with any ambiguous human cause. The Marxists have never forgiven Luther his refusal to allow the gospel to be identified with the cause of the peasants. One of the slogans in our time is the priority of our causes in particular the priority of ministering to human need, to feed the hungry, to visit the sick, and especially to visit those poor lost souls in our jails.

The Priority of the Gospel

All of us ought to do more than that. And one ought not to be put in a situation of having to choose between feeding the hungry and preaching the gospel. And yet, it’s critically important for us to keep our priorities in proper order. If one did have to choose, it is more important to preach the gospel. When we have fed a hungry person and the hungry person is satisfied, all the problems of human existence still remain. Human beings do not live by bread alone, nor do we live by political planning or social engineering. the simple fact is we all die by these things unless there is a word of grace the gospel the fundamental need of every human being to be told about the grace that lies behind every human life the purpose that called every human life into existence the power of God to enter into our human affairs in Jesus Christ and on the cross bear our sins and to forgive sin without destroying the moral structure of the universe and our hope of eternal life.

This is what we need above all else and without this, nothing else really matters very much. Martin Luther put it with a great deal of flair as he did most things he one time said life among us is as bad as it is among the papists we are no better than the papists we do not fight and damn them because they live evil lives I do not consider myself to be pious but when it comes to whether one teaches correctly about the word of God there I take my stand and fight that is my calling to contest doctrine has never happened until now others have fought over life but to take doctrine that is to grab the goose by the neck when the word of God remains pure Even if quality of life fails us, we still have hope. The fundamental issue is Luther knew. It’s not whether we are more moral, not whether we are better fed than other people, or whether we have better social ministries, or whether we have the right understanding of what it is to be a human being.

How Preaching Shapes Human History

This is the basic fact, especially what it means to be a human being in the presence of the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ. The Reformation understood the fundamental human problem as theological, and it sought to give a theological answer to that problem, which it believed was the church’s greatest service and great mission in the world. And now let us come a step further and note that having seen the human problem as theological and having given a theological answer to it, the Protestant Reformation mightily shaped human life on this planet. Herbert Butterfield, one of the most distinguished historians of this century once said that the church has influenced society most not when it has tried to take society by the neck as it were and order it around but it has influenced society most when it has been most responsible in doing what that by which the church lives namely preaching, teaching the word of God, administering the sacraments and exercising pastoral care.

As has already been intimated, I was for a number of years 11 years pastor of the Presbyterian Church in Auburn, Alabama and one of the great theological problems I had to face was how to say that whether or not Auburn, Alabama won the football game was a relatively unimportant event in the ongoing of human history without antagonizing people. Then it suddenly discovered me, it occurred to me, that 70,000 to 80,000 people would gather to see Auburn and Alabama play the last Saturday in November. That’s a very impressive spectacle with all the rituals and religious dimensions that had been incorporated into football games. Very impressive. But, on calculation, it became clear that within 25 miles of the stadium, a radius of 25 miles, more people gathered to hear the word of God preached on Sunday morning.

This is a fact that is designed mightily to shape human history. And to quote Butterfield again, historians have wrongfully minimized the impact of the preaching of the word of God upon congregations which gather Sunday after Sunday. It is through the hearing of the word of God that life in our society is shaped. Mr. Jefferson talked to establish University of Virginia as a very secular institution and it maintains its secular identity but at times it has had devoted Presbyterian elders as president who on Sunday morning heard the word of God and confessed the Apostles’ Creed and the church on the campus of the University of Virginia We have many task forces on disarmament. But how does the church influence disarmament? Well, it influences it through a Presbyterian elder named James Woolsey, a former Rhodes scholar, who reads Reinhold Niebuhr, who’s in church on Sunday, and who has participated in almost every one of the negotiations with the Russians.

That is the way the church transforms society. when the church does its task of preaching the gospel the gospel which if the church does not declare no one else will declare it mightily shapes human history it has done so in the past it does so today in numerous communities across this land now let me come a step further and note that we not only hear this word from Romans that if we confess with our lips that Jesus is Lord and believe in our hearts that God raised him from the dead, we shall be saved. We hear this word not only against the backdrop of the Reformation, which understood the fundamental human practice, It’s a problem to be theological. We hear it also in the context of a secular, pluralistic society, which erodes basic, fundamental Christian commitments.

The Erosion of a Secular Society

One of the unquestioned dogmas of a secular society is simply that there is no such thing as revelation and that there are many roads to God, all of them equally benign or equally harmless, however the case may be. In a secular society, people who are not tolerant politically, socially, and economically regard it beyond the boundaries of politeness and niceness to refer to religious differences. And this secularism in our society is increasingly taking its toll, as I have watched it in the civic club to which I belong in Richmond, Virginia. A few years ago, I was always impressed with the fervency of the prayers in that civic club and the clarity with which some identified their Christian commitments. today we no longer have prayers we have short lectures to the Kiwanis Club not addresses to deity really or at least the persons who give them have not reflected on what it would be to address something to deity if there is a deity and there is no mention of Jesus Christ and even in our church school literature and elsewhere we substitute CE and BCE for BC and AD The erosion of a secular society has penetrated to the very heart of the church’s life, and many of the fundamental doctrines on which the church exists are now at risk.

Doctrines which are at issue in the secular culture are those upon which the church is based. Does the triune God act personally in the created order? Or to put it practically, when we pray, does anyone hear? The conviction that the God who created the world, the word, the mind of God and God’s self-expression became flesh and dwelt among us, full of grace and truth, fully God and fully man. That God in Christ bore our sins and that when evil men sought to do away with him, God raised Jesus Christ from the dead vindicating his life and his words and that when we die there is hope of life with God. Ambassador Kennan, who I understand once worshipped in this congregation once said in the Princeton Chapel that the most dreary thing in all the world was the communist funeral where the meaninglessness of life is expounded by the meaninglessness of death.

And he quoted Ambassador Bolander saying that communism would never really grasp the hearts of people because it did not have an answer to the problem of death. Well, a secular society forces or invades the church and beguiles us into minimizing the clarity with which we affirm our Christian faith, not simply as something that is meaningful to us, but it’s true. when we say that God raised Jesus Christ from the dead we do not mean this is a beautiful symbol we do not mean this is a beautiful assertion we mean that God actually raised Jesus Christ from the dead this is a faith that constitutes a church and this is a faith that is at risk in a secular and pluralistic society very interesting to read a comment written a while back which I would like to quote.

As a consequence of the modern theory of religious freedom, the churches find themselves in an anomalous position. Inwardly to their communicants, they continue to assert they possess the only complete version of truth, but outwardly in their civic relation with other churches and with civil power, They preach and practice tolerance. The separation of church and state involves more than a mere logical difficulty for churchmen. It involves a deep psychological difficulty for members of the congregation.

The Emergence of Islam

Then he goes on to say, The human soul is not so divided in compartments that man can be indifferent in one part of his soul, firmly believing in another. And he continues. That statement was written by Walter Lippmann in 1929. And what he wrote in 1929… 1929 is increasingly clear with clinical accuracy in our society. There are theological bases in which people can respect the rights of other people in the same society without compromising the uniqueness, the identity, the Christian, Protestant, and Reformed identity of the Christian community. And then moving one step further. However, this whole issue is sharply focused for us now by the emergence of Islam as the primary alternative to Christian faith in the world. For the past hundred years, communism has been the primary option other than Christian faith in the world.

And many Christians even found communism very beguiling. the communists were very happy to have Christian allies they used words which had symbolic meaning and which Christians filled with their own meaning justice, equality community, peace of course the fundamental fact is I do not know of anybody who is not for peace and I do not know of anybody who is not for justice The real question is, what is justice? And the real question is, how do you get peace? But the use of these words was very beguiling. And many Christians went off to Prague to the Communist Peace Conference because they thought this was for peace. Today, the Communists claim to be a faith that satisfies basic human needs. The human needs of what it is to be a person, the human needs of what it is to be physically alive in this world, have been exposed to be flawed, inadequate, and ineffective.

And in this place there is emerging Islam, which is an entirely different problem, as was illustrated recently in the Rushdie affair, when Khomeini decreed the execution of the author of the Satanic Verses. The real problem for us is what this crisis revealed about liberal society in Britain and, one would have to say, also in America when the issue is fully raised here. British society was very willing to accept the Islamic community into the liberal society on the same basis it accepted all other people. And it expected the Islamic group to accommodate themselves to the general consensus of this British society. Great Britain, as our society, gave almost sacred status to the right of racial minorities, ethnic minorities, nationalistic minorities, cultural minorities.

And they were very happy to accept the Islamic people on this basis. but the Islamic community said very clearly we do not want to be accepted in British society on the basis of race or ethnic origin or nationality or culture we want to be accepted here as a people of faith who believe and who not only believe but who believe that what we say is fact and who intend to establish in Britain an Islamic society with Islamic values. There was no adequate answer that a liberal, pluralistic, and secular society could give to the Roistia affair. For one thing, two, basic rights guaranteed in so many contemporary documents, The right to free speech, the right to freedom of religion, cancelled each other out. And we’re in a situation where you could not have both at the same time.

The Islamic emergence confronts us with difficult problems, but it forces us to face issues that otherwise we did not have the courage to face and to address in our own particular society. One can think of communism as God’s judgment on the Christian community. for its moral lethargy. But by the same token, it seems to me, one can think of the rise of Islam as an alternative to Christian faith, as God’s judgment upon the spiritual anemia and the vacillating faith commitments and the uncertain identity of Protestant churches. And if history tells us anything, Christian communities, without clarity concerning their identity, cannot survive in an Islamic society. Well, this is the context in which we hear these words. If one confesses with one’s lips that Jesus is Lord, if one believes in one’s heart that God raised him from the dead, there is salvation.

We hear that now in the context of the reformation which we remember and the social pluralistic society in which we live and which continually erodes the distinctiveness of our faith and over against the challenge of the Islamic community. You and I are heirs today of a great heritage.

Our Reformed Heritage

We’re first of all Christian. Christians of the Nicene Creed and the Apostles’ Creed and we are Protestant and we are Reformed and this is a great heritage you and I are different people and the United States of America is certainly a different nation from what it would have been without the Protestant Reformation many of those aspects of our common life today which we regard as most precious are derived from the Protestant Reformation, from Puritanism, and from the Evangelical Awakening. And for that we must be deeply grateful. Those who have gone before have sacrificed and have lived and bequeathed to us a goodly heritage. In the Words of Luther’s hymn, they knew what it was to let goods and kindred go, this mortal life also, the body they may kill. God’s truth abided still. His kingdom is forever. And in response, we can but pray, exclaim, and sing. They climbed the steep ascent of heaven through peril, toil, and pain. O God to us may grace be given to follow in their train Amen

Cite this recording

Leith, John H. “Remembering the Reformation.” 1990. Audio recording, MP3. Sermons & Lectures, Foundation for Reformed Theology. https://foundationrt.org/resource/remembering-the-reformation/.

More from Sermons & Lectures

All 41 sermons and lectures

Remembering the Reformation

0:00 of 33:04

Back to top of lecture

Stay in touch.

Receive seminar announcements, new bibliographies, and quiet word from the Foundation a few times each year.

See the work you support.

Small groups of around six to eight pastors read in advance and gather for a week, with a significant portion of their room, board and travel reimbursed.