Foundation for Reformed Theology
Piety and the Confession of Sin
https://foundationrt.org/resource/piety-and-the-confession-of-sin/
Piety and the Confession of Sin
Carlos M. N. Eire argues that Reformation scholarship has under-attended the Reformed attack on idolatry, contending that Calvin’s polemic against Catholic worship was no transitional concern but a central animating issue shaping the formation of Protestant theology and piety.
- Author
- Carlos M. N. Eire
- Published
- Source
- Calvin Studies IV
- Pages
- 105–133
Piety and the Confession of Sin
PDF, 29 pages, 851 KB
Full text
Corrections are welcome. This text was produced automatically from a scanned copy (OCR) and may contain errors. For the authoritative version, please refer to the PDF.
“TRUE PIETY BEGETS TRUE CONFESSION”: JOHN CALVIN’S ATTACK ON IDOLATRY by Carlos M. N. Eire Introduction To some extent, Reformation scholarship sti’1 1abors under the burden of trying to explain the religious upheaval of the created by the Reformation. since certain theological questions became the focus of intense debate after the initial period of the Reformation, it has long been assumed by many scholars that these were the central questions raised by the Reformers them- selves, and that these issues alone gave shape to the Reforma- cially in regard to theology——— by those problems which came to be considered crucial by the heirs of the Reformers. Lutherans. for instance, still devote much attention to the issue of justifica- tion. Calvinists, whether they like it or not, are drawn into discussions about predestination.
This tendency helps explain, at least in part, why the Reformed polemic against Cathoiic worship has received relatively 1ittle attention since the seventeenth century. Wherever the in- pastors and theologians usually desisted from focusing directly on the subject of idolatry. When the “idols* were no’longer an immediate threat the question of idolatry quietiy slipped into oblivion, and remained rather obscure to succeeding generations. down to our own day. Hence, it is not surprising to find schol- one aspect of the Reformed movement, and a transitional and nega- no independent significance: but was rather subordinate to the “real” issue of the, Reformation as defined by Luther, that of works——— righteousness.
the Reformation, is that there may be a vast difference between what has been traditionally perceived as the “canon” of central.Reformation issues and those problems that actually occupied the attention of the Reformers.
‘Furthermore, I would like to argue that some of the so-called “transitional and negative” aspects theology than has heretofore been assumed. More specifically I on its own terms: as it was perceived by contemporaries, one must The issue of idolatry was not an adjunct, “negative” or subordi- nate question for the Reformed, but rather a central, positive organizing theme of much of their theology and piety. 105
106 Some scholars have also averted their gaze from this sub- ject for a different reason, because they consider it as an em- of whose whose primary concern is the promotion of Christian uni- ty rather than the writing of history. the subject of idolatry is far too disconcerting. Consequently. the problem is hidden in the cellar, along with other troublesome topics such as witch- craft and demon possession. (Interestingly enough, historians and anthropologists have developed a great appreciation for the extent. then the agenda for Reformation research is set by the churchly concerns of the present day. since some scholars are genuinely interested in casting off the burden of divisiveness created by the Reformation, they strain to highiight similari- ties, rather than differences: between medieval Catholicism and sixteenth-century Protestantism. Thus are we driven further from understanding the Reformation on its own terms. Though some of these well-intentioned ecumenists would rather gloss over the repugnance Calvin felt towards Catholic worship, preferring instead to relegate this problem to the ash heap of “sectarian’ history: the fact remains that Calvin devoted a tremendous amount of attention to idolatry. To Calvin and many of nis contemporaries, the Reformation was not just a strug- gle for right theology, but also for right worship. Over against Gospels stood the abominable “idolatry” of ‘the Roman Catholic Church. If this language sounds oddiy old-fashioned, tenden tious, or abusive, it is precisely because it is the language used by Calvin. This was not the dispassionate language of present-day ecumenists), but rather of reforming zeal. By focusing on the controversy over idolatry in the six- teenth century: one may not be paying attention to something.de- fined as “important by post-Reformation theologians: or to what tainly come closer to understanding what was crucial for Calvin. One question this study does not seek to answer is whether question for theologians and ecclesiastics, not for historians. Still, if Christians, Catholic as well as Protestant, are to con- tinue the progress already made towards mutual respect and a greater sense of confraternity it is imperative that’they gain a fuller appreciation of their own history. It is not only ahis- torical: but counterproductive to strive for unity by pretending that serious disagreements never existed.
107 Calvin’s Theology of Worship Knowledge of God and worship of God According to Calvin, the purpose of human existence is to know God and to glorify him by worship and obedience.3 Here may be seen the foundation of Calvin’s theology of worship and of his attack on idolatry. Knowledge of God and worship of’God are in- separable: One cannot come to know God without yielding some wor- ship to him.
Various attempts have been made to provide a neat descrip- tive phrase for Calvin’s principal concern in worship, but the glory) and finitum non est capax infiniti (the finite cannot con- tain the infinite). Although Calvinnever explicitly used the phrase “finitum non est capax infiniti,” and would never have de- strictly), it is fair to say that he agreed in principle with its meaning in everyday 1ife. These two interdependent principles are the basic components of Calvin’s argument against idolatry. Calvin’s primary concern in his struggle against Catholic piety was to defend the glory of the God who’is “entireiy other,” and whose reality is inaccessible.
Calvin forcefully asserted mary dignity among human beings.’ God’s radical transcendence through the principle finitum non est capaxinfiniti and his omnipotence through soliDeo gloria.”To make others aware of this dual realization, Calvin systematically juxtaposed the divine and the human contrasted the spiritual and the material and placed the transcendent and omnipotent solus of God ahove the contingent multiple of humanity and the created world.
demnation of the improper mixing of spiritual and material in worship-an affirmation of the principie finitum non est capax It is also an indictment of the”human attempt to infiniti.
domesticate God and to rob him of his glory——— an affirmation of the principle soli Deo gloria.
Calvin speaks about the nature of worship and about the seriousness of the sin of idolatry in his 1543 treatise, On the Necessity of Reforming the Church, where he concentrates on the significanceofworshipforthe Christian religion. Calvin’s argument, as indicated by the title of the treatise. is that the church had reached such a corrupt state that its reform could wait no longer. The most significant aspect of corruption sing- led out by Calvin is the perversion of worship, and it is in explaining this issue that he set forth the basis for his attack on idolatry.
108 Calvin begins by studying the place that worship hoids in the Christian faith. and he concludes that it is one of the two elements that define Christianity: If it be asked, then, by what things chiefiy the Chris- tian religion has a standing existence amongst us, and maintains its truth, it will’be found that the following two not only occupy the principal place, but comprehend under them all the other parts, and consequently the whole substance of Christianity. viz.: a knowledge first. of”theright waytoworshipGod; and secondly of the Christians. our profession is empty and vain. Calvin thus asserts that one cannot be a Christian without a proper knowledge of worship: and even places worship before sal——— vation in order of cognitive importance. Correct worship not only precedes righteousness, it precedes the true knowledge of salvation.
In any discussion of the relationship between reli- God.
It’ is because he believes worship to be the foundation of theology that Calvin can answer one of the more frequent charges of little significance, needlessly causing a schism. Calvin re- sponds by saying, on the contrary, that disputes over points of ligion.
Commenting further on the dispute over worship that divided Christendom, Calvin asserts tnat it is not an insignifi- cant struggle at all. but rather a 1ife-and-death combat over what is most essential to the Christian life: “For it is not true that we dispute about a worthless shadow. The whole. substance of Calvin uses equally strong 1anguage when he exhorts all Christians to assume their primary duty, that is, to struggle for the maintenance of pure worship: There is nothing to which all men should pay more atten- tion, nothing in which God wishes us to exhibit a more intense eagerness than in endeavoring that the glory of his name may remain undiminished, his kingdom be’ ad- yanced, and ‘the pure doctrine,, which alonergcan guide us to true worship, flourish in full strength. Calvin ridicules Catholics for saying that Protestants are only concerned with trifles. when the pagan idolaters spoke of fighting for their altars and sacred hearths, says Calvin. they
109 supported what they believed to be the noblest of all causes. Catholics, though also idolaters. are so confused about the na- ture of their worship that they regard as almost superfluous a tion of men..
Calvin thus points to the contradiction in Catholic polemics: The Catholics cling tenaciously to their forms of worship, yet also try to minimize the effect of the protestant to question. The seriousness of their corruption, Calvin adds. is evident in theirgfailure to see that worship is the soul of 18 the Christaan life.
Idolatry, then, is the’ very antithesis of religion.
The imperative for spiritual worship Calvin maintains”thattheonlycorrectform of worship means two things: worship devoid of trust in material props or by God.
Concerning the nature of spiritual worship, Calvin says that it must begin with an attitude of complete dependence on Godzas the source and endpoint of all human acts and aspira- 215 tions.
The true foundation of proper worship, according to Calvin. is to acknowledge God to be, as He is. the only source of all virtue, justice, holiness, wisdom, truth. power. goodness. mercy, life and salvation; in accordance with this, and to ascribe and render to Him the giory of all that is good, to seek all thinas in Him alone: and to The principal lesson to be learned from this knowledge is that, since God is spiritual, one should never try to form an earthly or carnal conception of him. Human beings can only meet God on God’s terms and at God’s level, and it is the role of wor- ship to raise men’s hearts above the world. Aithough the human race searchessfor God in the material world, this search is al- The sum of the matter, says Calvin, is that the ways futile.
worship of God must be spiritual, in order that it may correspond with his nature.
It is necessary to remember what God is, he cautions, “lest, we specting Him.25 The superiority of the spiritual dimension over the mat- erial is at the center of Calvin’s teaching. Calvin insists that that “whatever holds down and confines the senses ta the earth is through the improper mingling of spiritual and material in wor-
110 ship, since God’s honor is corrupted-“by an impious falsehood” whenever any form is attached to him.
Calvin’s second dictum concern’ng spiritual worship states that God is to be honored only according to -his commands in scripture. It is at this point that Calvin uses his hermeneutic of transcendence to attach Cathoiic worship. Calvin assails the estabiished piety as something thathad no sanction from the Word 28 Not once does Calvin waver of God and was thoroughly corrupt.
by in regard to his interpretation of what scripture means “spiritual worship.” The Word of God is clear, he says, and as a and true worship. it has a universal and univocal application.
God’s commands stand inscribed in the pages of the Bible as an unchanging rule that 30 it such legitimate worship as is prescribed in the law. What Calvin says in the first few chapters of the Insti- tutes is tightly woven around this series of facts: Scripture settles all questions and describes the truth in detail. what is this truth? That nature can lead to God, but only scripture re- veals him; that this revelation gives knowledge of God, and that worship is the result of knowledge. As Calvin says, scripture first invites to fearsathen to God, and finally, “by this, we can There is no escaping this hermeneutical circle in Calvin. In fact, he asserts that even the Bible itself is incapable of imiting discussion of God to a purely analytic level. ‘All considerations of God, even the simpiest mention of his name, require a response, and even more important, the right kind of response: “As often as Scripture asserts that thereis one God, it is not contending over the bare name, but also pre- scribingathat nothing belonging to his divinity be transferred to another.
Calvin’s interpretation of the history of idolatry The ultimate object of Caivin’s theology may be knowledge only be concerned with this as it pertains to human beings. For Calvin. God is never an abstraction that has to be related to an abstractiy conceived humanity; he is always the God of human beings, the God who reveals himseif. Correspondingly. the human ealing God.
human beings, as a resuit of the Fail, cannot come to know God God’ by a cognitive,gulf that can only be bridged by grace and
111 ways: Its natural gifts have been corrupted and its spiritual gifts have been completely taken away.
The imperfection of human soul are extingu’ished in them.
Human beings;, says Calvin, have been placed,in a_hopeless situation as a result of the Falt.
There is still implanted in numan nature a desire to search for the truth, but this desire can never be fulfilled. The human mind, dulled in its intellec- capabilities, can only grope in the dark for the truth. In this state of confusion human beings can only move in the direc- They are perpetually headed in a tion of falsehood and evil.
downward direction, towards death, ignorance, and spiritual destruction: with respect to the kingdom of God, and al1 that relates to the spiritual 1ife, the 1ight of human reason differs ittle from darkness: for, before it has pointed out the road, it is extinguished; and its power of perception is littie else than blindgess, for before it has reached its fruition, it is gone.
Just as human beings retain an insatiable desire for the truth they once knew before the Fall, so do they retain a 1onging for the relationship they once enjoyed with God. This innate de the semen.religionis (seed ofreTigion).
Calvin feels that nation on earth that does not have some form of religion. Idolatry and superstition are themselves an additional proof of this natural inclination in humanity. Calvin argues that the human being.
Ironicaily, this seed of religion does not br’ing human beings closer to God, but further alienates them. Stressing the spiritual ineptitude of human beings to the point where he seems inconsistent, Calvin asserts that this seed seldom takes.root. and that when it does, it only brings forth deformed and poison- ous fruit. Scarcely one person in a hundred, he says. follows fulfiils this desire in a perverted manner. Because of their sinful condition, then, human beings can only respond to this in- stinct erroneously, either by suppressing its effect or by dis- torting its intended purpose.
The “seed of religion” causes human beings to disparage the honor of God and to separate them in fact is the fountainhead of superstition and idolatry among human beings:
112 All have naturally something of religion born with them, weakness of our minds. that our apprehension of God is all superstitions, not in its own nature. but through the darkness which has settled down upon the minds of men. and which preventsathem from distinguishing between idols and the true God.
Calvin’s interpretation of human corruption plays an im- portant role in his assessment of the problem of idolatry. In and vagrants.
Although they can know God correctly in the divine.
These false conceptions lead to the development of.idolatrous practices. and this process separates them from God even further. Calvin proposes a twofold corruption of worship. saying that there are two tendencies in fallen humanity that dis- please God immensely. The first is that human beings, though they can come to know the truth, choose to follow their own base instincts and create their own religion. (This choice, howevers is limited by the perversion of nature, which will only allow human beings to fall into deception.) The only worship that can please God, says Calvin, is that which He has decreed as accept ignore the prescriptions of God.
God is further displeased, adds Calvin, by the manner in which his commands are corrupted. This is the second step in human audacity: God demands to be worshiped spiritually, but human beings can only devise material forms of worship. The re- bellion of the human race in regard to worship displeases God tremendously, not only because of the act of disobedience, but because of the form of worship it creates. It is insult added to injury.
Calvin asserts that human beings, in the state of sin, are continually drawn to the earthly and material. They have become creatures “of the flesh-a selfish and self-centered that all their thoughts are dominated by material conceptions. Fallen humanity has become engulfed in material existence; it has completely forsaken the spiritual dimension, and has there- fore removed itself from the realm of God. Calvin comments on this situation by stating that in order to approach God cor- rectly, human beings must transcend their own materiality and egocentricity.
For as long as our views are bounded by the earth. per- fectly content with our own righteousness. wisdom and strength, we fondly flatter ourselves and fancy we are Tittle Tess than demigods.
But if we once elevate our
113 thoughts to God, and consider his nature. and the con- summate perfection of His righteousness. wisdom, and strength, to which we ought to be conformed-what before charmed us in ourselves under the false pretext of right- eousness, wil1 soon be loathed as the greatest iniquity; what strangely deceived us under the title of wisdom. will be despised as extreme folly; and what wore the ap- pearance of strength, wiil be proved to be most wretched seems in us the highest perfection.
In this passage, Calvin makes it clear that the root of idolatry 1ies not in the material world per se. but in human beings themselves, who are impudent enough”to seek divinity on their own terms instead of the Creator’s. Human beings reverse the order of divine reality expecting to find the Creator in the created. As long as they remain enmeshed in the material level of their own existence: and are satisfied with their own corrupt being, human beings are immersed in the darkest error. Human that correspond to their own disposition; hence, they delude At this point Calvin further refines the theology of idol- atry that had already been developed by Zwingli. Though Calvin’s this problem in isolation from the doctrine of the Fall. Calvin man’s mind is 1ike a iabyrinth.”5 Calvin is no dualist.
The created, material world is viewed as good in itself. The material worid is neutral, it seems, or indifferent. when compared to God and the spiritual realm, it is impossible to deny that ontological superiority belongs to the Creator. But what matters’ for Calvin is the fact that idolatry does not result from any insufficiency in matter itself, due to its contingency and ontological inferiority. but rather from a defect in human beings. It is the human mind, or “fiesh,” that tries to reverse the natural order. Since they are incapable of properly perceiving the superior, spiritual oneness of God, human beings continually atomize the divine by trying to create a pantheon of fictitious material deities: “surely, just as waters boil up from a vast, full spring so does an immense crowd of gods fiow forth from the human mind, while each one, in wandering about with tog, much iicense, wrongly invents this or I The end result of this process is that: the objective reality of God is denied by human beings. Instead of understanding the true metaphysics. the human race creates an
114 infinite number of false, subjective opinions, so that religion says Calvin, each person is to blame for creating falsehoods:… after we rashly grasp a conception of some sort of divinity, straightaway we fall back into the ravings or evii imaginings of our flesh, and corrupt by our vanity the pure truth of God. In one respect we are indeed un- alike, because each one of us privately forges his own particular error; yet we are very much alike in that. trifles.
When one considers that Calvin regarded knowledge of God and of oneself to be the proper end of ail human beings, it is easy to see why the idolatrous impulse seemed so heinous: It produced a complete reversal of the true, natural order, and perverted the cognitio that alone could make life good. Calvin emphasizes the relative worthlessness of human material existence (in comparison with God) and argues that the true goal of humanity is to transcend the created world. If human beings are ever ‘to attain truth and eternal life, they must then regard the world as worthless.
-Calvin speaks of the flesh 55 as an obstacle that must be overcome, but not in a spiritual- istic or dualistic sense. what Calvin opposes is the egocentric- ity of human beings, that is, their attempt to worship God ac- cording to their own whims. The fault 1ies not in the material world, but in human beinas, who obstinatety refuse to accept the spiritual truth of God.”
Commenting on the corruption of wor- and rashness: who while “precariously drawing a fleeting breath from moment to momentt dare to devise their own form of wor- 57 ship.
The sin of corrupt worship is augmented by the fact that “crass imaginations” and materialistic conceptions, of human be- essence, or to draw Him down fro.heaven, and to place Him be- Human beings try to reverse the proper order of creation. Instead of adapting themselves to God adapt to the created world. Calvin warns that this is a 1ates to the worship of God, ought to be sufficient for restrain- and nauseating.
Since the Fall has made human beings slaves to error, says Calvin, “every one of usais, even from his mother’s womb, a mas- When the semen religionis is awakened
115 in human beings. it necessarily leads to error, because the fall- en mind can only conceive of God in material terms. It is no surprise therefore, that Calvin refers to.the semen religionis as “the beginning and source of idolatry. 62 Human beings per- cept God on his own terms.
Calvin finds the origin of idolatry in the human effort to domesticate God and tailor religion to human desires: For this is the origin of jdolatry. that when the genuine simplicity of God’s worship is known, people begin to be dissatisfied with it, and curiously to inquire whether there is anything worthy of belief in the figments of men; for men’s minds are soon attracted by the snares of novelty, so as to pollute, with various kinds of leaven, 64 what has been delivered in God’s word.
The argument against miracles Al1 of this would stilt remain rather academic and subject to dispute, though, if Calvin were not also to deny the meta- Catholic piety was defended through the example of the numerous miracles: ancient and contemporary, that had been performed through the aggcy of material objects of worship, especially through relics.
Catholics argued that protestant worship could be proven false through its lack of miracles. Calvin answers this charge olic claims.
What they adduce as the strongest physical evi- dence of the truth of their worship, says Calvin, is but its subtlest and most heinous deception.
Calvin asserts that the messengers, not to alter the fabric of material reality. This is especially evident in the cases of Moses and the apostles of Christ. In regard to the message of the New Testament, miracles must be regarded as “seals of the Gospel, that is, as the signa- apostles.
Calvin argues that it is wrong for Catholics to de——— mand miracles from the Protestants for this very reason, because that, very. Gospel whose truth aii ‘the miracles that Jesus Christ and his disciples ever wrought serve to confirm.”? This is the principal point of Calvin’s response to the Catholic argument, and it is a significant point. He asserts that miracles ceased at the end of the Apostolic Age. But. then, what becomes of the ready answer, taken from scripture: They are not really miracles. but humanly devised’ deceptions that give the impression of being more than they really are.
116 which, though they are deceitful tricks rather than true powers, are such a sort as to mislead the simple-minded and untutored [II Thes. 2:9-10]…. Idolatry has been nourished by wonderful miracles. yet these are not suffi- of idolaters.
Calvin, then, will grant miracles neither to God nor to the devil.
Like Bucer before him, Calvin realized that the miracles claimed, by. the Catholics were one of the mainstays of their nFor whence,”he asked, “come so many,superstitioys piety.
Since the numerous New Testament examples of miracles performed with a scriptural argument, Calv’in had to develop a different interpretation of the nature and function of miracles. One example often cited by Catholic polemicists was the story of the miracles performed by Peter’s shadow as it fell upon the sick (Acts 5:15). Calvin comments on this particular case: The papists abuse this text, not only to the end they may commend feigned miracles, which they.say are done at the graves of martyrs: but also that they may try to sell us their relics.” why, say they, shali not the grave. or garment, or the touching of’the bonesaof Peter have as much power to heal, as his shadow had??
Calvin refutes the Catholic argument by saying it is wrong to think that Peter’s healing power is a universal and everlasting characteristic of sainthood. The gift of miracles in the church was restricted to a specific time,’he says: and its only purpose was, to spread the truth of the Gospei among the heathen of antiquity.
The same issue surfaces again in connection with the story (Acts 12:2). ‘These miracles: says Calvin. are temporary testi- monies of the power of God, not a permanent condition of Chris- that his doctrine would have greater authority. and that he was the minister of this power, not its source. All miracles are performed to increase knowledge of the glory of God, he con- tinues, not to further the glory of the saint performing them or. formed.
The miracles claimed by Rome for its relics are ut- terly false, he concludes, because they accomplish thez9pposite the miracle stories of the New Testament, and therefore skirts
117 having to consider the possibi’ity of miracles being wrought through the agency of material objects. He does not deny that agate the gospel but hergargues that the time has passed when such things would occur.
In reference to the miraculous ef——— fects obtained by the apostles through chrism and unction, for instance, Calvin advised that it was no longer possible to expect these material objects to be of any use. Now that the gift of employed, and such things should be banished from the church. The historical argument’ for the usefulness of miracles. there- fore, removes from Calvin the responsibility of having to admit idolatry. Calvin bypasses the potentially troublesome subject of a scriptural warrant for the existence of miraculous cures, and this place unto their relics; as if Paul sent his handkerchiefs Papistry they worship Francis’ shoes and mantle, Rose’s girdle. Calvin points to the will of God as the source of-mir- acles. Nothing, after all, is impossible for the Almighty. but he restricts their employment to dramatic revelational events. The momentous changes brought about in the knowledge of God through the work of Moses. Jesus. and the aposties completely overshadow the relatively small service rendered by the miracles that accompanied the revelation. At the heart of Calvin’s argu- deep distrust of the religious value that men come to place on material objects. He has to accept the possibility of having miracles occur tnrough material mediation, but he does so reluc- tantly, removing this possibility to remote and specific in- stances, and keep’ing them as divinely chosen instruments that aid the revelation of the spiritual reality of God. Calvin’s denial of miracles in the material sphere is the capstone of his metaphysical assumptions. Uneasy with any inter- mingling of spiritual and materiai, he takes the miraculous out of the ordinary and moves it into the realm of revelation. Only when God decides to break into this world to communicate with human beings does he appoint specific instances where the nat- ural. material order is changed. Aside from such extraordinary events, which God intends as proof of his revelation, and not as ends in themselves, there is no intrusion of the divine, spir- itual sphere into the material. This world operates on its own divinely appointed principles. Religion, then, does not seek to change the way the materia’ world operates. but rather to under- stand it as it.is: eternally subject to God’s will and as always incapable -of transmitting any spiritual power in and of itself. To believe otherwise. says Calvin. is to transfer God’s glory to his creation. and this is the trap of idolatry.
118 Polution and punishment: the dangers of misdirected worship Because Calvin sees human nature as inherently prone to idolatry. he constantly warns that it is dangerous to accept even the most insignificant form of material worship in the church. for “men’s foliy” cannot restrain itself from falling headlong into super- stitious rites. The acceptance of materiality in worship pre- sents a threat to the purity of religion. and Calvin cautions so feigned god there should quickly be begotten a hwndred; that a Calv’in be- Iieves that idolatry progresses graduaily, but warns that once He attributes this to’ the great speed with which the seed of how fertile is the field of falsehood in the human mind, and that the smallest of arains, when sown there, will grow to yield an Taking these factors into consideration, Calvin warns that it is necessary to keep the seed from ever coming into contact with the soil; in other words, that every effort must be made to ensure that worship remains “spiritual.”?
The image of idolatry such as images into worship, they are playing with fire: So innate in us is superstition. that the least occasion will infect us with contagion. Dry wood will not so easily burn when coals are put under ‘it, as idolatry wil1 seize and occupy the minds of men, when the opportunity presents itself’to them. And who does not see’that im- ages are sparks? What! sparks do I say? nay, rather fire.
smailest distortion of spiritual worship. Calvin maintains that from worshiping it.
Calvin’s argument is that there is no such thing as an #innocent” religious image. Their acceptance alone, is an act of idolatry, so that as soon as images appear, retigion is cor- rupted and adulterated. Calvin also asserts that the prohibition distinct injunctions. The first prohibits the erection of any graven, image, or any such likeness: the second forbids theepay- By
119 divine law therefore all believers are prohibited from taking the first step toward idolatry.
The same argument is used by Calvin in regard to relics. One cannot keep these material reminders of someone else’s holi- without eventually beiieving that God’s power can be harnessed through the relic. Calvin argues that no distinction can be made between the preservation of relics and the worship of relics, be- cause other erated by the church.
cause they make men cleave to things “vain and perishing. also being polluted by some degree of superstition. The ultimate resu’t of all punishment it can bring from God.
misdirected worship is to bring additional calamities upon the human race: unreasonableness, famine, pestilence, and war. This, Calvin insists. is another reason why idolatry needs to be re- moved from every town and nation. Even though Calvin regarded all idols as false and powerless in any real, divine sense, he still believed that they wereaan objective danger, a source of pollution for body and’ soul.
Calvin does not say that al idolatrous paraphernalia are dangerous in themselves, as if they objectively exude a contagious pollution to all who come in con at a statue, he says than there is in looking at a stone. Yet. he adds, one must be cautious. Danger increases when the faith——— incited to participate in false worship.
The best policy to He alone keeps himself free, who does not even allow him- self any faked imitation of idolaters. but is abstinent to such an extent that he contracts no guilt or stain either by look. access, or nearness; approving his con- stancy to the Lord al’ the more because while surrounded conquered.
A final consideration Calvin takes into account is that all impure worship not only displeases God, but goes to Satan as well. Those who become embroiled in idolatry, he points out, are handing themselves over to the devil. because the ultimate result of false worship is abandonment by God: As long as we keep this rule (that one conform to the pure doctrine of God), we know that God will approve the
120 worship that is rendered by us: but if we add any of our fantasies or borrow anything from men, everything will be placed in charge of everything we do.
The practical implications of Calvin’s warnings about the dangers of idolatry are significant. since idolatry is a fertile danger, the true Christian must maintain a strict separation from all’ kinds of misdirected worship. Catholic piety, therefore, separating the Protestants: who worship spiritually. and the Catholics, who worship wrongly——— a gulf that can never be bridged without endangering the purity of spiritual religion. This atti- the 1540s onward, through the wars of Religion. Conclusion In many ways. it is fitting that Calvin’s most popular tracts. but rather the Inventory of Relics. (1543), a sarcastic expose of the “falsehood of Roman Catholic piety written in an Erasmian vein.
The Inventory is primarily what the title implies: a cata- log of variousreTics held and venerated throughout Europe. In this work. Calvin lists numerous items, one after the other in to show his readers that their falsehood can be easily proven It tgg absurd even to amuse children, or even “madness” (folie) In fact. he says that the purpose of the Inventory is not really to show why the cult of relics is wrong, but rather to point out that it is’foolish and fraudulent. Caivin says he hopes to re- obvious deceptions of the Catholic church.
If men cannot be then at least they might be able to see that its actual practice is insulting to human reason.
This remarkable expose, one of the few places in all of his work where Calvin allows some humor to surface. is a good theology of idolatry. In the first place. it is significant that the piece is so obviously a part of the Erasmian heritage to The very clearly. At times, in fact, Calvin even borrows freely from Erasmus. almost word for word, as in this joke about the relic of the true cross: “In brief, if all the pieces which could be found
121 The Inyentory, which went, through numerous, editions and translations is not only a fitting homage to Erasmus by one of his intellectual grandchildren (even if the humanist would have objected to its “vehemence”), but also a convincing testi- mony to the enduring power of the Erasmian critique and its in- fluence on the Reformed. No matter how much the conclusions to piety remained similar: as did their style, and more impor- tantly: their intention. Erasmus had wanted to turn piety from the outer to the inner. from the visible to the invisible. He cal, or grossly stupid. Seven years after Erasmus’s death, Calvin was trying to do the same thing, only with a more urgent sense of purpose.
This brings us to another point: Unlike Erasmus, who seems the Inventory is not graced with an ironic smirk. but rather with the frozen ‘smile of victory, of triumph over an opponent. Cal- vin’s Inventory is a good complement to the first few chapters of the 1559Institutes. ‘If one keeps in mind what Calvin says about cognitio in hisTater work. then it is easy to see that’the In- ventory is a manifesto of the very same human powers that are fuifitled by this knowledge. True cognitio of God and self does not allow for nonsense.
The unreasonableness of relics, and of all misdirected worship as well, plays an important role in Calvin’s polemic against Catholicism. ‘By arguing that idolatry is not only wrong but wrongheaded, Calvin can compare idolaters to unreasoning beasts. Those who do not direct every thought and action to the goal of worshiping God as he commands degenerate from the law of their creation, which is to come to know and worship God correct- beasts when they fail to worship properly.
He warnshis readers to take stock of their position as rational beings and not let themselves be deprived of their humanity: “let everyone. then, be on nis guard, and not allow himself to be led along ‘ike any way or path by which he might be guided safely. In other words, Calvin is here arguing about reality and the way it is to be perceived, just as he does in the Institutes. correctiy. In doing this, one also knows oneself and is ful- filled.’ There is but one reality to perceive:.God’s reality. Yet, this involves knowing that there is a fundamental division
122 between material and spiritual and that one cannot approach the spiritual through the material.
Which means, of course, that once one knows that the divine-human relationship can only be transacted in spiritual terms, the material world assumes its proper place. It, too, is definitely real but only in a contingent, finite way. But the as determined and directly controlled by God. ‘It functions as it is supposed to function, as created, as material, as finite. Material reality cannot be usurped by spiritual reality: In fact, it is incapable of being altered by its superior. Miracles can occur only’ because God, at rare moments, in his infinite power. decides to use them as proof of his revelation. But they are not the apostles, and would not occur again. E Even then, when they human perception or reason: but depended primarily on faith.
Calvin says over and over in the Inventory that what one sees, or observes as real. is real in this material sphere. If something is contrary to experience. or reason, then it must be considered false. This is why he lashed out with such comic fury consistencies, and sharp measured descriptions to demolish absurd claims. What fish ever lasted over 1,5o0 years, he asks. How. then. is it possible that the fish distributed by Jesus.can stiil be around? ‘This is not the way the worid works. What object the appearance of something new? How. then, is it that st. that the wine jars from Cana are all in different styles, shapes. ingly contemporary in appearance?
The point Calvin wants to make is that if anyone claims that these objects are real (as the Catholic church did in many cases), then it naturally follows: by reason and common sense that the one making such claims should not be heeded.
This is the application of the new Renaissance metaphysics as adopted in the Reformed tradition. Aithough Calvin’s argument in the Inventory is based on a scriptural foundation, his her- meneuticis shaped by metaphysical considerations about the fab- ric of reality. The intended audience of the treatise is a new phenomenon, too. The Inventory aims to convince the educated, those who take pride in their thinking abilities, the cultured, reasonable” is a product of the humanist tradition, and it in dicates that the Reformation succeeded in part because of its affinity with certain aspects of the intellectual climate of the sixteenth century.
123 The metaphysical assumptions of this most Erasmian of Cal- principles are concerned, he adds nothing new. He is very faith- ful in maintaining a tradition, defending the principles of finitum non est capax infiniti and soli Deo gloria. His contri- bution Tiesprincipally in the clarification, expansion, and application of these principles.
theology of transcendence.
Firsts he refines a point that Zwingli, Bullinger, and others had not fuily developed. Calvin, beings, not in the material world.
This anthropological per- central to this theology, turning it into an essential component of his doctrine of the’ Fall. whereas Zwingli had concentrated ically, on the human condition itself.
The problem on which Calvin focuses is the endemic corruption of human nature and the fact that the material world itself is not evii. Men are evil. Religion is a human phenomenon, a human response to the reality of God, but since men are corrupt, religion, too, shares in this corruption. Because they try to reverse the order of creation by attempting to bring God down to their level, men are inherently idolatrous. By stressing this point as a universal rule, Calvin makes ‘dolatry an ever-present danger, a contagious disease of sorts, and he closes the door on compromise with any kind of re- the objective reality of God with the infinite number of subjec- tive opinions that fallen human beings create about him, Calvin makes it a doctrine that men are metaphysically deranged, nat- urally inclined to reverse the order of things. Idolatry, then. is a permanent condition of the human race, something against which human beings must always struggle.
In connection with this anthropological and metaphysical toward the development of a theology of idolatry. Calvin defines the place of worship as none of his predecessors had done before. Though they had struggled against idolatry, their theology was somewhat fundamentalistic and more inclined towards action than systematic exposition. Calvin clears whatever doubt anyone could gle. for, “pure worship.”* Calvin states plainly that the war against idolatry is not merely blind obedience to scripture: but also something reasonable. Worship, he says, is the central con——— It is not some peripheral matter, but “the of the Christian faith. It is the reason for human existence, the fundamental principle that alone can bring true cognitio to human beings. and therefore true fulfillment. since”the’ proper end of human existence is knowledge of God and
124 of ourselves. By making worship a necessary existential com- ponent of knowledge. Calvin turns it into the nexus between tion. It.is a very practical sort of theology that Calvin devel ops as a result of this. Religion is not merely a set of doc- “True piety begets true confession.”
This is enormously sig- nificant.
One may even argue that it becomes the fundamental defining characteristic of Calvinism.
The Reformation for which Calvin struggled was not so much one of doctrine, but rather one of piety, which involved profound nity would not only have to change its theology but also its outward expression of faith, not to mention its attitude toward the material world. Though this was already part of the Reformed tradition long before Calvin entered into the fight, it was Cal- vin, more than anyone else, who turned this into an explicit guiding principle and devoted his energies to making it under- stood. This, too, would have serious consequences when it came to considering any compromise on religion.
second, and this is his analysis of reverential acts. In connec- tion with his theology of worship, Calvin develops a univocal in- terpretation of reverential acts that, on the one hand. is an affirmation of his metaphysical assumptions, and on the other, is a practical application of these principles. By carefully defin- ing what goes on in worship. how human actions relate to the spiritual reality of God, regardless of man’s intentions, as some sort of spiritual commerce, Calvin finally drives the Reformed forceful manner. It is this point, because of its practical na- ture, that will allow Calvin’to wage a new kind of war against idolatry. Unlike his predecessors, Calvin faced the task of “idolatrous” societies in which they 1ived. Instead of fighting effective way of undermining the system that supported their ex- istence. It was to prove a long, hard battle, but without this understanding of reverential acts or of the place of worship in human life, or of the dangers of idolatry. it is doubtful that the war against the idols could have become as serious a chal- his ideas were taken seriously.
125 Notes *This paper is a condensed version of chapter six of my I am grateful”to the publisher for permission to use this material.
IMark Edwards. review of war Against the.Idols, American Historical Review 92.5 (1987): 1194. william Bouwsma. review of war Against the Idols: Catho- 1ic Historica1 Review 73.4 (1987): 588-9. Genevan Catechism (1545), questions 1. 2, and 6: CR 6.9-10.
Inst. I.5.9.
Subsequent references to the Institutes will be to the 1559 edition, unless specified otherwise. AlT Battles, J. T. McNeill, ed. (Philadelphia: 1960). est cum’carne dissidium quam igni cum aqua.” rist (Princeton, 1967), 163.
vocation Reformatrice (Wiesbaden,1966),202. daa (o).snastus snlosn (q).-.etdolb oa tlos.. (e):kboloat bum Dei.”
Each of these principles defends the complete other- does add, however. that “on peut affirmer sans hesiter que le plus fondamental” (Le Jeune Calvin 202). Francois Wendel makes a similar observation:””Fromthe beginning of his work, Calvin places all his theology under the sign of what was one of the essential principles of the Reform: the absolute transcendence of. That is the idea that dominates the whole of Calvin’s theological exposi- tion and underlies the majority of his controversies.” Calvin: The Origins. and Development of His Religious Thought, trans.”p. with more caution, stating that Calvin’s transcendental premises were at the root of the majority of his theological controver- sies, though not necessarily at the root of all his work (McDonne11, Calvin-, 165).
126 Ernst Saxer, Aberglaube, Heuchelei und Frommigkeit. Eine 6g.Saxer thinks that Calvin based his opposition to Rome on the two Lutheran concepts of “sola fides” and “sola scriptura,” and that he thus formuiated his concept of “true religion” on an op- position to unscriptural beliefs and works-righteousness. I be- iieve Saxer overlooks an important part of Calvin’s theology by ignoring the principles of “soli Deo gloria” and #finitum non est capax infiniti.” ‘Similarly, Margarete Stirm overlooks the sig- nificance of worship in Calvin’s theological opposition to image worship. Though she provides a good summary of Calvin’s own the biblical Law as ‘the source of these arguments. See: Die Bilderfrage in der Reformation (Gutersloh, 1977): 161-222. 10.
De necessitate reformandae Ecclesiae (1543): CR 6:459. Inst.z II.8.11.
(New York, 1952), 28. Also: E. Doumergue,”Deux Grandes Doc——— Vie (1909). 638-42.
De necessitate: CR 6:502.
Sadoleto: “l have also no difficulty in conceding to you that there is nothing more dangerous to our salvation than a twisted and perverse worship of ‘God.”
Rep1y to Sadoleto (1539), CR 5:392.
171bid., CR 6:502.
Inst., II.8.11.
19.
CR 7:673. Calvin speaks of idols in Vera Christianae pacificationis et. Ecclesiae reformandae ratio as follows:”ldolam enim erigitur,”non”quod externam sacrarii speciem deformets sed quod total ecclesiae sanctitatem inquinet ac pervertat: quod labefactet totum Dei cultum, nihil in religione nostra impollutum relinquat.”
Dei cultum. se in externis vel caeremoniis, vel aliis quibuslibet operibus reponatur: deinde non esse legitumum nisi ad eius cui praestatur voluntatem sit compositus, ‘tanquam ad suam regulam. Utramque solus quam necessarium est.”
127 21 This conception of reality is only one of many platonic influences evident in the thought of Calvin. For a detailed study of Calvin’s Platonism consult: Gerd Babelotzky Platonische Bilder und Gedankengange in Calvins Lehre vom Menschen (wies- baden, 1977): J. BoissetSagesseet Saintetedansa”pensee de Calvin (Paris, 1g59). especially “Les Themes Platoniciens dans 22 De necessitate. CR 6:440. In the Institutes Calvin expands on this point, indicating that what man owes to God may (3) invocation; and (4) thanksgiving (1I.8.16). 23.
“Volunt enim Commentary on Isaiah (1551), CR 37:20.
homines praesantem habere Deum: atque hoc initium et fons idola triae est: quia Deus per simulachrum nobis non adest, sed per verbum suum et spiritus virtutem. Quamvis autem et gratine suae et bonorum spiritualium imaginem nobis obiiciat in sacramentis. non alio tamen spectat, quam ut sursum ad se nos invitet.” 24:403. certum enim est,”Deusnunquamvoluisse co1i nisi,pro Unde sequitur verum eius cultum semper fuisse ens natura.
spiritualem. ideoque minine’ situm in externis pompis.” Also Inst.,Il.8.17: “God who11y calTs us back and withdraws us from petty carnal observances, which our stupid minds, crassly conceiving God, are wont to devise. And he makes us conform to his lawful worship, that is, a spiritual worship established by himself.”
27 Inst., I.11.2.
28 necessitate. CR 6.463-4. Also: Peter Auski “sim- De plicity and siience: The Influence of Scripture on the Aesthetic Thought of the Major Reformers,” Journai of Reiigious History 10 (1979):343-64.
29.
Calvin’s doctrine of scripture is best summarized in Inst. I.6-lo. For further reference: J. K. S. Reid, The Author- ity of Scripture (London: 1957). 29-55. Reid provides a good summary of’Caivin*s doctrine of scripture and supplies thorough notes in reference to the most significant scholarly debates about this subject. J. T. McNeill also provides a brief and helpful study in “The Significance of the Word of God for Cal- vin, Church History, 28″(1959): 140-5. 0ther studies include the following: T. H. L. Parker, The Doctrine of the Knowledge of God (Edinburgh, 1952), 41-7; E.Dowey,Knowledge, 86-146;W. Niesel: The Theology of Calvin (Philade1phia, 1956), 22-38; F.
128 wendel: Ca1vin, 156-60: and more recently, H. J. Forstman, word and Spirit:”Calvin’s Doctrine of Biblical Authority (Stanford, schrift fur Kirchengeschichte, 79 (1968): 329-41. Also: W. H. Neuser, “Theologie des Worts——— Schrift, Verheissung und Evangelium bei Caivin,” in Calvinus. Theologus: Die Referate des Europaischen fur Ca7vinforschung16-19sept. 1974, W. H. Neuser, Kongress ed.(Neukirchen/V1uyn,1976), 17-38; and in the same volume, A. zur Hermeneutik Calvins,” 39-70. 301 Inst.,1.2.2.
31.
Inst., I.10.2.
32 Inst.,I.12.1.
33- Inst., I.l.1: “… nearly all the wisdom we possess, that is to say, true and sound wisdom, consists of two parts: the knowledge of God and of ourselves. * This statement stands at the beginning of every edition of the Institutes. each time in a slightly different form. J. T. McNeiTl indicates that Calvin may andrja. Augustine, and Thomas Aquinas (Inst., I.1.36, n. 3). Roy Renaissance platonism,” Journal of the History of Ideas, g (1948):447-71.
Charles Trinkaus, attempting to prove that Calvin was a “modern” thinker, argues that one may see in Cal- vin’s epistemological concerns a “healthy skepticism” derived from nominalismthe same sort of skepticism, he adds, that pro- duced modern science. 1 #Renaissance Problems in Calvin’s Theol- ogy,” Studies in the Renaissance, 1 (1954): 59-80. 34.
insists that it is not merely a formal principle, but a reality that must be faced in treating any religious or moral category of Calvin’s thought: “every theological statement has an anthropo- logical correlate, and every anthropological statement a theo- logical correlate: (Knowledge: 20). 37 Hans Engelland does not think the labyrinth is ali that rationalism of the humanists and the revelation theology of Christianity. This theory, however, exaggerates Calvin’s indeci——— sion, since it is clear that Calvin accepts a dominant pessimism in regard to man’s spiritual capabilities. Gott und Mensch bei Calvin (Munich, 1943), 7-32, 46-59. Also:w.Ko1fhaus, Vom
129 Christilichen Leben nach Johannes Calvin (Neukirchen, 1949), 23-68; and G. Bockwoldt, “DasMenschebild Cal1vins,#’N Neue Zeit- (1968):171-173; andRichard”Stauffer. Dieu, la Creation et 1a Providence dans la Predication de Calvin (Bern, 1978). 39 Commentary on Ephesians: 4.17: cR 51:204. 40 Inst.s I.3.1: “There is within the human mind, and in- deed by natural instinct, an awareness of divinity Lsensus divin- itatisl Aiso: I.4.1, “God has sown a seed of religion Lsemen religionisl in all men.” Edward Dowey maintains that outside the Institutes, Calvin uses the term semen religionis most often. Dowey, Knowledge, 52 n. 13. See also: H.”C. Hoeksema, “Calvin’s Theologyofthe Semen Religionis. Protestant Reformed Theolog- ica1 Journal. 8 (1975): 25-37. Natura Deorum, I.16.43.) 42.
Inst.. I.3.1.
43 Inst., I.4.1.
44 Commentary on Psaims, 97.7: CR 32.44. J. Ries, Die Naturliche Gotteserkentnisin der… Theologie..der…Krisis..im. Zuzammenhang mit demImagobegr’ff bei Ca1vin(Bonn.1939)34-5. 46.
At times Calvin attributes man’s perversion to the di. rect temptatior of the devil, not to man’s corruption. Calvin to estrange man from God. Petit Traicte, CR 5:457: Commentary on Samue1, CR 29:473. 47 Inst.: I.11.4; Commentary on Ezekie1, 6.4: CR 40:l40. 48 Inst.3 I.1l.1.
49 Commentary on John’s Gospel. CR 47:90. 50.
Inst.: I.5.12.
51 Ibid.
52 Inst.? I.5.12.
53 Inst.- I.5.l1.
130 54 Inst.. II.9.1-2.
55 fugiendis, CR 5:243.
“Iam istud quoque aeque ac saeculorum omnium vitium est, tam vafras esse, amabiles capti. osas, speciosisque praetextas nominibus, ad illudendum unumquem- que, carnis suae illecebras: ut illam arcere a concilis nostris, abiqereque, primus sit sapiendi gradus.” 56m De necessitate, CR 6:461. “Scio quam difficulter hoc persuadeaturmundo, improbari Deo cultus omnes praeter verbum suum institutos. Quim potius haeret haec persuasio, et quasi in ossibus omnium defixa est, ac nedullis, quidquid agant, in eo se satis iustam approbationem habere. si modo qualemunque honoris Dei zelum obtendat.
. mendacium esse. quidquid verbo suo additur, praesertim in haec parte: ethelothreseia meram esse Vanitatem.”
57 Inst., I.11.4.
58 Commentary on the Last Four Books of Moses. CR 24:392. 59 Commentary on the Acts of the Apostles, CR 48:562. Jean Delumeau stresses the point that Calvin, and the Reformers as a whole, were among the first armchair ethnologists of the western Actes du colloque sur 1*Admiral de Co1igny (Paris. 1974), 471. 61.
Commentary on the Last Four Books of Moses, CR 24:423. quia Deus per simulacrum nobis not adest, sed per verbum suum et spiritus virtutem.”
… quod mens humana.
ut nihil nisicrassum et terrenum de Deo concipit, ita ad eandem crassiteam transfert omnia divinae preasentiae symbola… nos autem, qu’ terrae sumus affixi illum similiter volumus in terra habere,” Calvin also says elsewhere: “Le source d’idola- trie est que nous sommes charnelz et apprehendons Dieu selon nostre fantasie.”
64.
John H. Leith has remarkedthat “the history ofreligions becomes Honor of wi1liam Childs Robinson, J. M. Richards,ed. (Richmond, VA1968). 114.
included in the McNeil1 edition of Institutes. p. 16… In the Commentary on Acts, Calvin mentions that “the papists do object unto us miracles again and again.”
131 66 For a detailed analysis of Calvin’s view of miracles consult: H. Schutzeichel: Die. Glaubenstheologie. Calvins (Munich, i972),, 258-65; E. Saxer, Aberglaube,44-5; and Bernard Vogler. “La Réforme et le Miracle,’ Revue d’Histoire de la Spirituaiite, 48 (1972): 145-149.
Commentary on Matthew, 10:1; Commentary on John’s Gospel, 2:11. Commentary on Matthew. 10:1. In the Commentary on John’s Gospel. ve1 ad fidem nos praefarent, vel in fide confirment” (cR 47:270). In connection with this point, Calvin adds that miracles do not produce faith in and of themselves, and that in order to benefit from miracles, men must have their hearts purified. Otherwise, how would it have been possible far the Jews to be angered by the (the greatest miracle imaginable for Calvin). this would do Miracles. then, cause no objective change in those who behold them (CR 47.271).
of Augustine, who attacked the “miracles” of the Donatists in the same manner (Augustine, Commentary on John’s Gospel, 13:17). omy: 4:5: CR 28:208.
74.
Commentary on Acts, CR 48.104.
751bid.
Commentary on Acts. CR 48.l04: “Hic enim finis est, ut mundus a Christo abductus ad sanctos transfugiat.” 78.
Martin Luther had also at times argued that although physical miracles could not occur in the post-Apostolic age: the A Sermon on Word of God continued to work spiritual miracles. Keeping the Chi1dren in Scho01″ (1530), wA 30/2:534ff. A1so: Vogler.. “La Reforme et”le Miracle,”146-7; H.” Berger, Calvins Geschichtsauffassung (Zurich: 1955) 108-110.
132 79.
Inst., IV.29.4-13; IV.19.18-21. A1though Calvin and the ing, they never abandoned hope in the power of God to cure ill- pretation of the miraculous. the Reformation separated medicine and religion. He feels this is distinctly “modern”,and in keep- ing with the spirit of the Renaissance (“La Réforme et ie Mirac1e,” 148-9).
80.
Commentary on Acts, 19.11-12. cR 48:445. 81 For a discussion of Calvin’s use of the nominalist con- cepts of the “potentia Dei absoluta” and “potentia Dei ordinata. see F. wendel, Calvin: 127ff. The same issue is also analyzed by Karl Reuter, Das Grundverstandnis der Theologie Calvins. unter Hinbeziehung Ihrer Geschichtlichen Abhangigkeiten(Neukirchen/ Vluyn,1963),”143-52;and K. McDonne11, ca1vin,”8-12. For a general discussion of the concept of God’s authority in Calvin’s theology consult Bohatec, Bude und Calvin, 325-45. CR 48:155.
Also: Inst.$ I.11.3.
83 etters, CR 13:85.
84 Commentary on I John. CR 55:376. 85.
De fugiendis, CR 5:253-4. Zwing1i had warned against this danger in De vera et falsareligione: “since sure danger churches, and imminent risk of their adoration and worship, they ought to be abolished in the churches and wherever risk of’ their worship threatens” (Latin works, 3:336). 86 Commentary on the Last Four Books of Moses: cR 24:377: “spectra Tlla, vet”fallaces pompas.” Also, Inst.,11.8.17.
87 Inventory of Relics, CR 6:410. 90 Ibid., CR 6:410.
scribed by Calvin in the Institutes, II.18-2l. Also: De necessi- tate, CR 6:502: “Scimus quam execrabilis Deo sit idolatria: et quam horrendis poenis eam ultus sit tum in populo israelitico. tum in aliis gentibus, passim narrant historiae.’
133 Even when one’s life is threatened by idolaters. says This Re- would be Calvin’s main argument against the Nicodemites. sponse a un Ho1andois, CR 9:604. 94 De fugiendis, CR 5:265. 95.
Sermons..on..Deuteronomy, CR 28:715: Petit Traicte. CR 6:548.
Ibid.: CR 6:416. 102g Between 1543 and 1622, the Inventory of Re1ics appeared in at least twenty different editions.inciuding seven French. one Latin. six German: two English: and four Dutch. CR 59:461- 96.
“Catalogis operum Calvini chronologicus,H 103.
Inst.: I.3.3. 104 Inventory of Re1ics: CR 6:452. 105 Commentary on John’s Gospel: CR 47:271. Calvin remarks on the incompatibility of faith and absurdity: “Ie m’en rapporte aux plus povres idiotz qu’on pourra trouver, si on dont adiouster foy a des choses tant absurdes (cR 6:445). Arts (New Haven: 1966), 161-6. 109 De necessitate, CR 6.459.
Cite this resource
Eire, Carlos M. N. “Piety and the Confession of Sin.” Calvin Studies IV, 1988. PDF. John Calvin Studies, Foundation for Reformed Theology. https://foundationrt.org/resource/piety-and-the-confession-of-sin/.
More from John Calvin Studies
Stay in touch.
Receive seminar announcements, new bibliographies, and quiet word from the Foundation a few times each year.
See the work you support.
Small groups of around six to eight pastors read in advance and gather for a week, with a significant portion of their room, board and travel reimbursed.
