Foundation for Reformed Theology
Calvin’s Sermon on the Mount
https://foundationrt.org/resource/calvins-sermon-on-the-mount/
Calvin’s Sermon on the Mount
Z. N. Holler examines Calvin’s exegesis of the Sermon on the Mount, noting Calvin’s disciplined brevity and clarity, his sparing use of patristic citation, and his recurring refutation of the papists in expounding the teaching of Jesus.
- Author
- Linda A. Holler
- Published
- Source
- Calvin Studies III
- Pages
- 5–20
Calvin’s Sermon on the Mount
PDF, 16 pages, 596 KB
Full text
Corrections are welcome. This text was produced automatically from a scanned copy (OCR) and may contain errors. For the authoritative version, please refer to the PDF.
Caivin’s Exegesis of the Sermon on the Mount by Z. N. Holler Introductory Observat ions In the Dedication of his Commentary on the Psalms, Calvin wrote: I have kept throughout to a simple method of teachingi and to avoid all ostentatlon, I have refrained for the most part frcm refutation of others, whigh readily provides much opportunity for plausible showing off.
Of such showing off there is ittie in Calvin’s exegesis of the Sermon terpreters, he scarcely refers to them at all. He does cite Augustine’s And views on three occasions, chrisostom’s twice, and Erasmus’ once. he regularly refutes the papists, though never individuaiiy, by name. On the whole his disciplined comitment to clarity, brevity, simplicity, restraint in controversy, and edification of the church——— i.e., the com- mitment that he described in his welj-known letter to simon Grynaeus in 1539——— controls his exegetical style.
Even his notes on the meaning of Greek and Aramaic words are few, brief, and stated In non-technica! terms. It Is evident that Caivin wanted to be read and understood by the struggling congregatlons of God’s people who looked to him for leadership.
Aiso evident throughout this exposition 1s his broad competency as a biblical scholar. His skll in literary criticism gives’ rse to quite t’modern’t criticai Judgments, such as the conclusion that in these chapters Matthew gives us not. a “sermontt proper but a surmary of esus! or his opinlon that Matthew incorporates tn his collection a number of foi lows them.
Calvin in fact speaks frequently and freely in such terms as the design”t gf the Evangelists, what’ they have “omitted’t or collected and He even ‘speculates at ione point as to how Luke happened to the 1ike.
write an obvious non sequitur.
On the other hand, he can express forthrightiy his conviction that it is the Holy Spirit who speaks through the Evangelists.
And he demonstrates throughout his confidence monizing apparent disagreements between part icular sayings of Jesus, be- tween divergent wordings of the Evangelists, and between Jesust words So his confidence in the Bible as God’s word and the old Testament.
critical scholar.
Intent always on discovering the natural, historical sense of Christ’s words, Calvjn generally dismisses allegorizing or spiritualiz- Ing interpretations.
He rejects out of hand the notions of the stoics that would deny the reality of human anguish and harden their followers
It is this fundamental sense of what against the pain of real life.
is real, combined with his confidence in the unity of the scriptures, that seems to underlie his freguent recourse to synecdoche and hyper- bole, as well as to the principle of “accommodation,” in order to ex- plain and broaden the meaning of vivld sayings of Jesus that, If taken Bible.
Surprisingly, in interpreting this portion of scripture which was of such great importance to the Anabaptists in developing their distinc- contexts: the section on persecution iifor righteousnesst sakelt and the section on oaths. Surely he must have been thinking of them throughout his exposition of Jesust relation to the law, yet he neyer identifies as Anabapt ist’t the views against which he contends there. Caivin’s chief adversaries in his exposition of the sermon on the Mount are without doubt the papists. Their theory of the relation be——— tween divine reward and human merlt, thelr doctrines of venial sin and indulgences, of purgatory and suffrages, of Christ’s ‘tadvicestt as op- posed to commands, and of the freedom of the will——— alt are refuted in 13 Also rejected are their practices: their the course of his exegesis* tyranny over souls, theii.lengthy prayers and chantings, and above all, their efforts t the Reformers.
Behind ail these strictures against the papists there ers and the true gospel as the scribes and Pharisees were to Jesus and 15 his teaching.
But be that as it may, it is clear that the Sermon on tive, is “carnal reason: the polluted, “general opinion’t of humankind, which. Calvin knows weil. One cannot but be impressed with the great reformerts constant, clear-sighted awareness of the sort of world this is agd of the struggles to which all, believers included, are subject in it.
1b.But perhaps the key word for Calvin’s exposition is moderation. Again and again he discovers In Jesust precepts a concern for modera- tion. Some examples: The hunger and thirst for righteousness, of which Those who would be reformers shouid, 1ike Christ in his interpretation of the law, exer- cise moderatlon.
In urging us to agrgement with our adversary out of court, Christ is enjoining moderat ton.
The intent of the Instructlon The sort of anxiety on fasting Is.
over food and ciqthing, which Chrlst opposes in Matt. 6:25-34 is an, is a call to And the prohibition itJudge not *.
moderat io22 not an invitation to abolish all distinctions between good and evil.
This almost obsessive concern with’moderation tn interpreting a body of teaching that does not on the surface appear to be alt that
moderate is related to another pervasive theme of Calvin’s interpreta- tion: the christian 1ife as struggle and as cross-bearing. Calvin was always conscious of the sufferings of the Reformed faithful in his own homeland and across western Europe.
so he missed no opportunity to offer these tempted and persecuted saints such wisdom and succor from Christ’s words as would mitigate their troubles and sustain,them in 23 As he their struggies against the world, the flesh, and the devil. reflects on the Jewish opposition to Jesus and Jesus’ manner of deal ing with it, he discerns paraliels instructive for his own people. As Jesus rejected the way of revolutionary extremism and walked in the way of fidelity and the.cross, so must they. If they are to be persecuted——— and whether this con- exampie, and not orn account of their own rashness. cern caused Calvin to moderate overmuch the sharp edges of the Lord’s lively teaching is debatable, but that his exposition was motivated in part by a passionate concern for the edification of his suffering friends is hardiy to be doubted.
But he was also motivated by common sense. Though primarily, and these texts to be a man of practical reason, contending for the realism of the gospel in an age shot through with prideful enthusiasm and fan- aticism. He ctearly knew Christ as an’eminentiy sensible Lord. He be- 1ieved, for example, that christ, in teliing those who were fasting to tanoint their heads and wash their faces, had no intention of moving So he interprets this rather playful instruction of a happy face.
Uesus as hyperbole intended to move his disciples toward moderation, not toward inverted excess. Or again, it is simpiy not reasonabie to sup- pose that Jesus wanted his followers literally to pluck out lustful eyes and, chop off offending hands. And Calvin would not interpret him so. All.of which ls to say that Calvin was too honest and reasonable a man either to fail to take Jesust salty words seriousiy or to swallow them all ltteraily, as though Jesus had been as deadly serious as the fan- atics of Calvints own day.
It. is truly remarkable how little Calvin the theologian allows his own doctrtnal concerns, or even doctrinal outlooks from other New Testament writings, to intrude in his exegesis of these Gospel texts. of the later faith in Christ coior his discussion. Both of these times he introduces the requlrement of faith in christ as the Mediator into a 26 He does in discussing once import the doctrine of justtficatlon gratuitousix And he intro- duces doctrinal distinctions foreign to the context in order to inter- pret the ttwilitt and the ‘kingdomt of God in his exegesis of the Lord’s But such instances as these are really the exceptions that Prayer.
prove the rule. Calvin -is engaged here in discipiined critical and his- he apparently considers it enough to 1et the texts that he is dealing with deliver their own message, unless, of course, they seem to con- tradict one another or other porttons of scripture. In those cases, as
has already been pointed out, he does do his best to harmonize the differences.
So much for my comments. Now I want to summarize Caivin’s own lucid conmentary. It is hard to condense his work. It ts all wheat and sweep and quality of this particular work, I wiil try to gather up the main points of his exegesls in such a way as to let him speak for him- se1f.s shall be kept at a minimum.
A Condensation of Calvin’s Exegesis of Matthew 7-g Introduction (Matt. 5:1-2) This teacning was probably delivered after the choosing of the twelve, but as the spirit of God did not see fit to clarify this matter, Pious and modest readers ought to be satlsfied with having a brlef summary of the doctrine of christ… collected out of many and varlous discourses, the first of whtch was that in True Happiness (Matt. 5:3——— 12) The teaching of the beatitudes addresses the general opinion!t that happiness consists In the achievement of onets desires in a ‘tjoyous and happy lifet (25g). In contrast, Christ’s intention is to equip his and wi11 soon be fol1owed by a happy resulttt (260). Now concerning the individual beatitudes: ttPoor in spirittt means really poor, as Luke’s wording makes plain; but since deprivation can produce pride and cruelty, Matthew’s addition, ttin spirit,’t is appropriate. For oniy those poor’t… who happytt (261).
the meekt are those who endure, rather than retaliating against evil. If it seems foolish to prcmise such people the earth, when fero- cious folk are busy taking it for themselves, one need only remember how restless and insecure the ferocious are: they reaily possess nothing, whereas the meek are happy In the knowledge of God’s protection now and in the promise of inheriting ttthe worldtt (262). those who hunger and thirst after righteousness’t Is a figure for people in poverty and want who have been defrauded of their right and seek only simple justice. (This surprising Interpretation is ‘a result of harnonizing Luke’s iyou who hunger nowlt with Matthew’s wording.)
the pure in heartt! are the sincere, in contrast to the deceit- Christ comforts them with the consideration tt.
ful.
.. that, if they have not the sagacity to deceive in this worid, they wiil enjoy the sight of God in heaventt (264). (This, you notice, is a social, not’ a theological definition of tpure in heart.)
personal and social peacemaking in a world that clamors for advocates, not peacemakers. They therefore suffer the reproaches of men, but ttthe God of peacett accounts them his chi1dren (265).
“those who suffer on account of righteousness——— i.e., because they oppose bad causes and defend good ones.
.tt——— are simpiy experi- encing it.
the majority of men: for the flesh cannot endure the doctrine of the Gospel; none can endure to have their vices reproved’t (265). Conse- quentiy those believers who are not presently suffering persecution shouid meditate on this doctrine In order to be prepared when their time comes.
In commenting on this ftnal beatitude, Caivin sets his views over against the stoics, who scorn hope of future reward and secure their present happiness through mental games; also against the papists, who imagine that the reward promised by Christ can somehow be merited; and against the Anabaptists who court persecution, and thus suffer for their own fault. Calvin knows that for those who are faithful to the gospel, persecutton wi11 come. Theirs wi11′ not be a happy 1ifet according to the ‘standards of “carnal reason.” Yet the happiness that they enjoy now,.by raising thelr minds to heaven and beholding there tvast grounds for.joy,t is real and important for the world; and the future happiness that. they are promised is as certain and as free as the promises of God. (In ali of this the Kingdom, for Calvin, is a future reality of God which powerfully affects society now, through the awareness and the faithful behavior of bel ievers. Hence his consistentiy this-worldly and social, rather than other-worldly and spiritualized interpretation of the beatttudes.)
The Task of Christis.Discip1es (Matt. 5:13-16) It is not the disciples themselves but the ‘theavenly doctrinet cormitted to them that ts the salt of the earth. To ‘salittt the earth is thelr taski and to fail in it is to be iiable to dreadful judgment. For tt… it’is an incurable disease, when ministers and teachers of the word corrupt and render themselves tasteless..
Stt1l, Christts warning is not ‘for ministers only but for the whole church (27of.). The ttiighttt metaphor also appiles to the preaching of the gospel and to those to whom it ls committed. The exhortation, ttLet your light shine,” etc., does not contradict the instruction In chapter 6 to per- those whose light tshines’t according to Christ’s Instruction are truly good, in that they reveal God as their Author and bring God glory.
10 The Relation of Chrlst.to the Law (Matt. 5:17-20) In saying that he came to t’fulfiitt the law, Christ is deciaring his doctrtne to be in perfect agreement with the law and the prophets. Thus he intended to keep enthusiasts among his hearers from giving his new method of teaching a shaltow, revolutionary interpretation which would needlessly have offended the genuinely devout. Also he wanted to refute the slander that he did intend to abolish the law and the proph- ets. so Christ teaches moderation here——— a lesson that applies directly to the reformers of Caivin’s day: In responding to simiiar attacks of.the papists, they should eschew “novelty and discourage “trasht re- sponses to their message, and do nothing to discourage the faith of the So Christ affirms the law as tt… the eternal rule of a devout and holy life… unchangeable as the justice of God, which it em- braced, is unchangeable” (277). True, there is some appearance of a change in the authority of the law concerning certain ceremonies, but it was only the use of these that was abolished, while their meaning was I’more fully confirmed’ by Christ.
Thus the law and the gospel, which fulfils it,.. with. one consent, declare God to be their Authortt tt (278).
The teaching concerning those who break or uphold certain icom- mandments,lt and teach others to do the same, has reference to the Ten Commandments, which are obiigatory for “al1 the chlldren of God.it 1 when the eva’uattons of men.
And Calvin sees a danger in this idea of tleast; for tt.
we are not at liberty to think anything smal1 on comand!!
(279).
The True Meaning of the Law (Matt. 5:20-48) The insufficient righteousness ( (Matt. 5:20): The reason that the lrighteousness of the scribes and phariseest is inadequate for entry trained their disciples, 11ke apes, to hypocrisyit (281). Accordingly, It is only these outward, literal interpretations that Christ is setting aside in the antitheses, tYou have heard that it was said… but I say to you tt For nothing was farther from Christ’s purpose than to alter.or innovate any thing in the comandments of the Ing a perfect love of God and of one’s neighbor. In this 1ight the words, “But I say to you. -.”t simply establish Christ’s authority over against the anttquity of the scribal traditions. And far from abolish- ing the law, they point to its true meaning.
Murder (Matt. 5:21-26): In the case of the sixth commandment the true meaning ts: tthose’ who shall only be angry with their brethren or treat them with haughty disdain, or injure them by any reproach, are murdererstt (285). The example of’ leaving one’s gift at the altar to. go
11 this, tt… that whatever we offer to God is polluted, unless, at least as much as lieth in us (Rom. xii.l8), we are at peace with our brethren! (287). The further injunct ion, to settle with one’s adversary out of court, addresses the human tendency toward obstinate defense of one’s Own rights and enjoins Christ’s people, ‘t..
.. to cujtivate moderation and justice, and to make some abatement from the highest rigour..,”i for the sake of peace and frtendship (288).
Incidentally, Calvin considers it ridiculous that the papists should use a tortured allegorical interpretation of tnis passage to versaryt tn this saying to be the devil, he wryly observes that.. Christ enjoins those who believe ln him to be agreed with thine adversary.
Therefore in order that the Papists may find their purgatory here, they must first become the friends and brethren of devt1s (289).
Adultery. (Matt. 5:27-32): In this second antithesis Christ’s in- tent is to condemn tithe lust of the flesh” by teaching “… that not only those who form a deliberate purpose of fornication, but those who admit any polluted thoughts, are reckoned adulterers before God’t (2go). This, in contrast to the papists who teach that tt… lust Is not a sin untii it gain the full consent of the heart 29of.). Calvin para- phrases the accompanying instruction about plucking out the offending the commandments of Godt (29l). Yet christ does not intend that we I it- erally muttlate ourseives.
He uses this’ exaggerated “language to get our attention, knowing that “.
men allow themselves too much 1ib-..t in these matters (291).
erty..
Moving to the teaching on divorce, Calvin explains Christ’s ap- divorce law as a civil matter: part of the ‘nationat law’t of Moses, “accommodatedt to the ways of men, but not “t… on that account, law- ful In the sight of Godt (292).
PerJury and. oaths (Matt. 5:33-37): Thts antithesis, 1ike the It exposes an error current among the Jews, that the third commandment applied oniy to perjurers and not to those who called on the name of God for trivlal reasons. Christ intends that.
.. al1 promises and engagements which have been sanctloned by the use of the name God:.. be honored (294). The words, 1swear not at all,t do not, as the Anabaptists and others imagine, mean 1iterally to swear never. For earth), the particle, at all, relates not to the’ substance but to the form of the oath and therefore means ‘neither directly nor Indirectlylt (2g4). Further, since the law not only allows but enjoins oath-taking.. all oaths are unlawful, which 1n any way abuse and profane the sacred name of God…t (295). st111, the remedy for the dishonesty that gives rise to such swearing Is the sincerity represented by a
12 simple iYest or tiNo”; for it is in the wickedness of men that swearing originates.
An aiternative to retaliation (Matt. 5:38-4l): Recognizing the lex talionis as a statute to be enforced by the magistrates rather than an authortzation for private revenge, Christ requires that his disciples not “repel violence with violencett but bear personal injuries patiently (2g8). Paul is the best interpreter of the Lord’s Intent when he en- joins Christians to ‘tovercome evil with goodtt (Rom. 12:21). So Christ’s purpose here is not to overturn public laws but to train beltevers in “moderation and justicett and to teach themn pat ience through suffering. But, when any one has it in his power to protect himself and his property from injury, without exercising revenge, the words of Chrtst do not prevent him fram turning aside gently and inoffen——— sively to avotd the threatened attack (2gg).
For surely Christ did not intend for his people to whet the mal ice of those whose cruelty would only be encouraged by their victim’s turning the other cheek.
(Here Calvin rejects iiteralism for a situational ethic.)
: similarily, the saying about responding to one who wouid lsue you to wrench from them a part. of their property, they ought to be prepared to lose the wholet (3oo). This is not to say, however, that both coat and cloak should be surrendered without ever going to court, or that Christlans are.
entirely prohibited from engaging in law-suits, tion would be to encourage robbery and extortlon. The meaning of the difficuit saying, tgive to him who asks,’t etc. (Matt. 5:42), is found by comparison with Luke 6:35 (ttLend, expecting nothing in return…).
It requires being “t,.. generously disposed not tfoolish prodigal ity.”t to all who need our assistance, and who cannot return the favour (301f.)
Loving one’s.neighbor (matt. 5:43-48): By itneighbortt christ un- derstands the law to include t’the whole human race.it To 1 Imit the word, as the scribes did, to benevolent personstt is a great absurdity.tt For clearly,i what a man has deserved, but extends itself to the unworthy, the wicked, and the ungrateful (3o4). Thus the requirement, “Love your enemies, includes the whole of the precedtng teaching on love. To render good for evii Is admittedly very difficult. But our vices and weakness ought not to be pleaded as an apol- ogy. we ought simply to tnguire, what Is demanded by the law of charity: for, if we rely on the heavenly power of the Spirit, we shall encounter successfuliy all that ts opposed to it in our feelings (305).
13 punish the wicked and titake vengeance on the reprobate,’t for example) but we are to emulate… first, that free and pure kindness, whjch Is not induced by the expectat ion of gain;——— and, secondiy that. remark- (308).
Aiternatives to Religious Ostentaton (Matt. 6:1-18) sincerity in giving (Matt. 6:1-4): In the teaching on alms, prayer, and fasting, christ is attacking the general problem of ambi- tion, that so easily corrupts virtuous work. Using synecdoche, he here lets one charitable work (alms) stand for the general category of those: do good, not fram a desire to do what is right, nor on ac——— who tt.
reputation for holiness’t (3io). The secrecy which Christ requires here stands opposed to insincerity and ostentation, not to public charity as such, or to a zeal ‘.
.. to edify the brethren by good examples (310). He intends oniy that his people. reckon it enough that their duties are approved by God alone”t (311).
sincerity..in.praying (Matt. 6:5-15): Christ’s strictures against ostentatious prayer paraiiei those on alms. Enter into thy closettt is neither to be allegorized as referring to the ttinward recesses of the heart’t nor taken 1iterally as contravening the many bibl ical passages that call God’s people to public, corporate worship. It is intended only to correct the desire for public adulation and means that ‘t. whether a man prays alone, or Ir the presence of others, he ought to have the same feelings, as if he were shut up ln his closet, and had no other witness but Godit (313). The caution against ttvain repetit.ions’f addresses the erroneous notion that God’s favor Is obtained by quantity of words or wearlsome chanting.
All such superstition is overcome by the simple word, ttyour Father knows tt But if God knows what things we have need of, before we ask. him, where lles the advantage of prayer?it (314). Calvin’s answer: Believers pray nelther to inform God nor to urge God to his duty but to exercise their confldence that it.. from him alone they hope and expect, both for themseives and for others, all good thingstt (314). since God has freely promised and will surely grant such good gifts, it is paradoxically true tt… that He freely anticipates our wishes, and yet that we obtain by prayer what we askit (314).
The form of prayer which desus taught his disciples (i.e., the Lord’s Prayer) is not to be followed slavishly, by rote, but is intended to ‘guide and restraint our desires within the iimits of its petitions. Thustt.
* we infer, that the rule which [christ] has given us for praying aright relates not to the words, but to the things themselvestt (3l6). The first three of tts six petitions appropriately relate to God’s glory, ‘t… without any regard to ourseives; and the remaining three relate to those things that are necessary for our salvatlon’t (316).
14 toward us, and the clause, who art in heaven,t pointing to God’s power over al1 things. since it would be presumption to cal1 God our Father except on the grounds of our union with the body of Christ, t.. there is no other way of praying aright but by approaching God with reliance on the Mediatortt (317f.).
The sanctification of God’s name to which the first petition re- fers is that which is necessary because of the profaning that the name suffers at human hands; thus the substance of the petitlon is. that the glory of God may shine in the world, and may be duly acknowl- edged by menti (318).
The second petition, thy kingdom come,it refers in part to God’s rule, when men.
.. voluntarily devote and submit themselves to be governed by him,.
renouncing their desirestt (31g). This, God ac- complishes through his word and Spirit. A second aspect of the Kingdom, the subjection of all his enemies, Is accomplished through nis power. To the extent that evii persists tn the world, God’s kingdom, which.. is continually growing and advancing to the end of the world, almost 1ike nineteenth-century 1 iberal ism!) The will of God, which is the subject of the third petition, is of God.which Is done. continual ly.
tt.. however obstinately men may strive:to oppose him..
..”; and second,’ God’s will “… that ali creatures may obey him, without opposition, and without reluctance’t (32i). It is for God’s wiil tn the latter sense that we are to pray. God’s evangelical will, you might call it. with the petition for daily bread Christ moves to the things we ought to ask for ourselves. He begins with mundane bread, in order to insttii confidence that if God cares for our bodies, surely he is even more careful for our souls.
“t,.. who have But why, asks Calvin,’ should the godiy rich, thetr yeariy produce laid up in store.. pray in this way?
The reply is easy. Unless our plenty is ‘.
. watered by the secret bless-,”t it wili suddenly vanish, or lose its power to sup- ing of God..
port us, and t!.
. we shal1 famish tn the midst of plentytt (324f.). If the question be asked, why ls bread that we ask to be given to us called set it apart for our use. Thus Christ teaches us… that what we That the petition, “Forgive us our debts,t follows the prayer for bread does not indicate Christ’s evaiuation of tts importance. On the contrary, we ought always… to begin with the forgiveness of sins,tt heard. ‘In fact “… every one who thinks that he has no need of such a remedy, ls struck out of the number of the disciplestt (326). ‘ This
15 forgiveness has nothing to do with tt.
.. satisfaction, by which the world endeavors to purchase its own det iverancet (326). It is simply forgiveness, full and free. Therefore the addition, as we forgive our debtors,lt does not state the condition upon which God forgives us. By these additional words Christ intencs tt.
.. only to remind us of the feel ings which we ought to cherish towards brethren, when we desire to be reconclled to Godi (327).
The final petition carries not two thoughts but one: that we may not be led into temptatlon, deliver us from evl1tt (327). Temptationlt is to be understood here not as outward trials, which are inevitable, but rather as it.:. all wicked emotions, which excite us to sin.. tt valid, for according to many passages of scripture God does ti. in a way peculiar to himself…ti lead people into temptation (328f.). Yet we are not to infer from thls that God is therefore the author of evil, for God is just..
sincerity.in fasting (Matt. 6:l6-18): This teaching is intended head and wash your face,” is hyperbole, not a 1iteral command that would. withdraw us from one kind of hypocrisy and lead us into anothertt C331). Instead, Christ Intends.that our fasting t…’ should make no change ln our accustomed way of I ivingt (33l). The promise of the Father’s reward in this case.
.. is not strictly accurate.’t For fasting, in contrast to alms and prayers, is ta doubtful operationt sires, strengthen our prayer life, and testify to our repentance (331). Faith and Treasure’ In the place of the universal and deadiy “plague’t of amassing wealth, ‘ which is llable to putrefaction, or robbery, or a thou——— sand other accidents.
t christ invites us to lay up ‘imperishable riches.
This laying up of ittreasure in heaven’t consists of meditating (332). Our 1ives are in fact confined. wherever we imagine the greatest happiness to be. If for us that were heaven, “.. it would be easy for us to trample upon the worid, to despise earthly biessings… and to rise towards heaventt (334).
sentences,t They depict the proper role of the mind, represented by the eye, in directing our affect ions, which are otherwise bl ind. The God-or-Mammon saying, with which this particular section ends, returns to the theme of covetousness and means that, though it Is not ‘impossible for the rlch to serve God, those who give themseives up as slaves to ‘riches lt.
.. must abandon the service of God: for covet- This either/or does. not, ousness makes us the slaves of the devil.n however, apply directly to bel ievers, who groan under the bondage of ang u.. an unwiliing and reluctant service to the flesh. whose’..”.. desires and exertions are approved by the Lord, as tf they
16 rendered to him a perfect obediencelt (338). (This is one of those rare examples of the triumpn of doctrine over Calvtn’s exegesis.) Excessive Anxiety. (Matt. 6:25-34) In this section Christ is reproving only undue anxiety; for some “caret is inherent in our human condition, as a “t… punishment,in order to humble us” (330). what Christ condemns is “immoderate care”t reliance.
The way of a proper care is that of faithful labor in one’s wili see to the lesser gifts that sustain it. So this is not a teaching.tt or to re-.. to encourage us to indolence and sluggishness. lieve us of all anxiety, but to guard us from anxiety that arises from distrust in God and neglect of the iife of the kingdom and pride In our Own abl1ities (344).
Judging (Matt. 7:1-5) Christ’s words, ttjudge not,’t are not “.
.. an absolute probition from judging,…” but are designed “.
.. to guard us against indulg- ty,: in judging our neighborst (346). Moderation is Christts intent, not the setting aside of ‘tt.
all distinction between good and eviitt (346f.). On the contrary, it is God’s wil1 t!… that we should pro- claim the sentence which he pronounces ‘on the actions of men: only we must preserve such modesty toward each other, as to make manifest that he is the only Lawgiver.and Judge.
..(347).
That is, we must judge according to the word and law of God and the rule of charity, which means we begin by subject ing ourselves to examinatlon. Recognizing that the children of God are often the recipients of unjust judgments of men, Calvin suggests that the Lord permits this in order to “humble them’t but also notes that sometimes it is “… partly deserved: for there is no man who is so kind and indulgent as he ought to be towards his brethrentt (348).
withholding the Gospel (Matt. 7:6) unrelated to the previous teaching. And it ls not intended to 1Imit the presentation of the gospel to the. docile and wel1-prepared. itthe remedy of salvation must be refused to none, till they have rejected it so basely when offered to them, as to make it evident that they are.. self-condemned.:.. (35o). Yet such seif-condemned scoffers, who would swinishiy turn the gospel into an excuse for self-indulgence or, 1ike dogs, rend its doctrine and its ministers, “t… must not be permitted to approach itit (350).
The Necessity and promise of Prayer (Matt. 7:7-l1) The tnstruction to ask, seek, and knock is a three-foid exhorta- tion to prayer, along with promises that our prayers wiii not be fruitless.
Those In need who do not ask God’s help “… are justly pun- ished for their siothfulnesstt (352). Yet God does not wait for our prayers before taking thought for our welfare. Out of his own gracious- ness, not because of our praying, God gives us faith, which precedes all our praying, and with it, all good things.
Detached Sayings on Justice and the Narrow way (Matt. 7:l2-14) The Golden Rule (matt. 7:l2) is to be read iby itseifit as an ex- hortation to simple justice, whose requirements we understand gulte well when we demand it for ourselves.
more opposed to the flesh than the doctrine of Christ.. But though Lit] confines and hems us in, reduces our 1ife to a narrow road, separates us ought not to prevent us from striving to obtain 1ifett (357). This needs saying because those being “… ruined in the midst of a vast crowd… do not bel ieve that they are ruined’t (357). A warning Against False Prophets (Matt. 7:15-20) Christ’s warning is necessary both because we are Ingenious at deceiving ourselves and because itit is the will of the Lord… that his church sha!l be engaged in uninterrupted warfare in this worid’t (362). Besides, It gives us confidence that, t… provided we are not.tt we shatl be able to avoid led astray through our own sluggishness.
all 1ife’s snares.
The test, tBy their fruits you shall know them,tt stands opposed to the practice of the papists who quote Christ’s words, tbeware of false prophets,’t in order to frighten ignorant peoplet into avoiding the reformers and their teaching it.
.. without knowing whyui (364). The iisanctityli but a manner of teaching that seeks God’s, rather than one’s own glory. For bel ievers who are uncertain of their competence to make such judgments there is the promise of the help of the Spirit,. provided they distrust themselves, renounce their Own?
judgment, and give themselves up wholly to his direction. Let us remember, however, that all doctrlnes must be brought to the Word of God as the standard, and that, in judging of false prophets, the rule of faith hoids the chief place (365). in Calvin’s value system.)
warnings agalnst Empty Profession (Matt. 7:21-27) The sayings about professing ‘tlord, Lordtt apply the tnstruction about false teachers to ti.
+. all hypocrites, whatever may be their rank or station..
devote himself, sincerely and honestly, to the exerctses of a new life’t (367). And this, Calvin reminds us, includes believing in Christ.
18 The final parable carrles forward this teaching by showing that true piety is not fuliy distinguished from its counterfeit, till it which has its. roots deep In the heart, and rests on an earnest and steady affection as its foundat lon, that it may not give way to temptations’t (370).
Conclusion (Matt. 7:28-29) These final words of the chapter point to the involuntary reac- Indescribab1le, and unwonted majesty drew to him the minds of mentt (371). tion of these words of Jesus is radical; yet also reasonable, rather than poetic or rhetorical tn the prophetic tradition. On the one hand, he holds to the radical wisdom of the gospel over against the encrusted traditions of the Roman religious establishment. On the other hand, he holds to the radical wisdom and good sense of desust startling words over against the 1iteralistic interpretations of sectartan enthusiasts the real worid, in which, as Calvin sees It, this theavenly doctrine——— though painful and chailenging——— makes the best. sense of all. Notes John Calvin, Calvin: Commentaries (edited and translated by The. Library.. of Christian Classics: Ichthus Edition; Phi ladelphia: The westminster Press, 1958; cited as Calvin:commentaries), p. 57. Matthew, Mark, and Luke: Vol. I'(translated by wiiiiam Pringle for the Calvin Transiation Society, Edinburgh, Scotland; and reprinted in Grand 269, 298f.2 327, 329, 347, 322. Ibid., pp. 73-77.
Harmony, pp. 258f., 335, 345, 349. 1bid., pp. 258, 315, 355, 357. 7Ibid.,,p. 259. Incidentally, this is the only such reference that I found in the exegesis of Matthew 5-7. Ibid., pp. 258f., 274, 295, 308, 310, 312, 331, 354.
19 Ibid., pp. 259, 288f., 312; but see the careful1y worded alle- goricat, or at least, metaphorical interpretation of the saying about the eye as the 1ight of the body, p. 335. 11 Ibid.: pp. 290, 307, 309 (synecdoche); 29l, 331 (hyperbole); 279, 284, 287, 292 (accommodation). 12.
In wi1lem Balke’s study, Calvin and.the _Anabaptist Radicals (translated by william Heynen: Grand Rapids, Michigan: william B. Eerdmans Pub1iching Company, 1981), pp. 313-20, the author sets Calvin’s interpretation of the Sermon on the Mount as a whole over against that of the Anabaptists. And surely the views of the atter are refuted in the course of Caivin’s discussion. This only makes it the more surpris- cited (see Harmony, pp. 267, 294f.), whereas the papists are constant1y refuted by name.
the papists in pointing out this anaiogy. This inclusion is a mistake, I think. It is the Roman estabiishment that corresponds to the Jewish establishment of uesust time in Calvin’s thinking. 17.
Ibid., p. 263.
18 Ibid., p. 276.
19.
Ibid., p. 228.
moving discussion in Calvin: Commentarles, pp. 37-50. 24 claring his agreement with the Law: Harmony, pp. 275-7. 25 Ibid., p. 331.
26 Ibid., pp. 317f., 367f.
27 Ibid., p. 338.
20 28 In this condensation the quotations from the Harmony wi1i not ordinartly be footnoted but referenced simply by noting in parentheses at the end of the quotation the page of the Harmony from which it is taken.
Cite this resource
Holler, Linda A. “Calvin’s Sermon on the Mount.” Calvin Studies III, 1986. PDF. John Calvin Studies, Foundation for Reformed Theology. https://foundationrt.org/resource/calvins-sermon-on-the-mount/.
More from John Calvin Studies
Stay in touch.
Receive seminar announcements, new bibliographies, and quiet word from the Foundation a few times each year.
See the work you support.
Small groups of around six to eight pastors read in advance and gather for a week, with a significant portion of their room, board and travel reimbursed.
