Foundation for Reformed Theology
Calvin’s Church Polity
https://foundationrt.org/resource/calvins-church-polity/
Calvin’s Church Polity
DeBevoise compares Calvin’s polity with Karl Barth’s practical theology of the church, arguing that for both Reformers the church’s order expresses its obedience and that polity is inseparable from the visible form of faith.
- Author
- John DeBevoise
- Published
- Source
- Calvin Studies II
- Pages
- 1–5
Calvin’s Church Polity
PDF, 5 pages, 186 KB
Full text
Corrections are welcome. This text was produced automatically from a scanned copy (OCR) and may contain errors. For the authoritative version, please refer to the PDF.
Calvin’s Polity and the Practical Theology of Karl Barth by John T. DeBevoise The church is an ordered institution. It must be. Like any other institution involving mixed groups of people. it requires order. Qr, as Barth is fond of pointing out, it takes an order, assumes a form, to Barth and Calvin because the church’s order is refiective of the church’s form in which it expresses itself. It is not a hat or garments for the body but: rather, the shape of the body, what we can see of the body. I think those sections of the Institutes where Calvin presents his polity are structured differently than Barth’s consideration of the church’s order in his theology. I don’t intend for that to be confusing. Both Calvin and Barth are very concerned with the order of the church. Calvin, of course, talks about the order of the church in Book Iv of the Institutes——— and Barth talks about the order of the community between the two is that Barth is ambiguous about the form of the church while Calvin is not.
But Barth’s ambiguity is deliberate ambiguity. What he is doing seems one step removed from what Calvin does. Calvin presents the arder of the community. Barth presents the principles from which the community’s order can rise. Barth deliberately avoids the specifics of a particular polity, and instead writes about the theological presuppositions which underlie church order. He sees many of these theological presuppositions underlying Calvin’s polity but these are implicit——— Calvin’s task is different, Barth believes——— from his task. Barth says: We can only indicate the general presuppositions which are theologically binding on all churches and their Iaw. We cannot develop the Iaw itself. This is a matter for different churches in different places and times and situa- skill in addition to the necessary theologlcal insight). (p. 690. IV. 2 C.D.)
There is no such thing as universal church order. True church order. says Barth, as long as it arises from the general presuppositions, can develop in many different directions.
this end, it is interesting to note where they Iocate the church. Calvin. of course, says: “wherever we see the Word of God purely preached and heard, and the sacraments administered according to Christ’s institu- XXI: P. 1023.)
But Barth avoids an identification like this. He of the Church.
addresses this in Iv l in a section entitled “The Being of the Community,
and his chief emphasis is on the verb is. To describe the church’s being. he abandons the usual distinctions between being and act: here its act is its being. The Church is a work of the Holy Spirit which takes place among man in the form of a human activity. Barth says: The Church is only as it is gathered, and Iets itself be gathered and gathers itself by the living Jesus Christ through the Holy Spirit. The Church is when it takes place that God Iets certain men live as his servants. his’ friends. his children, the witnesses of the reconciliation of the world with Himself as it has taken won in Him over sin and suffering and death: the heralds of his future revelation in which the glory of the Creator will be revealed to all creation as that of his love and faithfulness and mercy. The Church is when it happens to these men in comnon…they receive the awakening power of the Holy Spirit, they are gathered and ailow themselves to be gathered… (c.D. rv 1, p. 65l.) Barth (who often drops “the church'” and instead uses “the community”) believes the community is not the being of a state or institution, but the being of.an event in which the Christian community is awakened. gathered, and at work. One of Barth’s presuppositions is that the church is. an event created by the Holy Spirit. And Calvin’s Marks, in part, frame where this event is taking place.
Is the chief difference in the polity of Caivin and the practical different tasks? Calvin is about the task of re-forming the Church, his new church waits for a specific order, and Barth is about the task of dogmatics, which seeks not a specific order, but the theological presuppo- sitions for order. Barth says the church has the freedom, and exercises today (and then he likes to add iToday——— until Tomorrow; until it takes further order.”) (C.D. IV 2, p- 714.)
Calvin, relying on Paul’s admonition to do things decently and in order: embraces order for the church: We see that some form of organization is necessary in all human society to foster the common peace and maintain concord. We see further that in human transactions, some procedure is always in effect which is to be respected in the interests of public decency. and even of humanity itself. This ought to be especially observed in churches, which are best sustained when all things are under a well-ordered constitution, and which, without concord, become no churches at all. (LCC, XxI, p. 1205.)
Of course, the conscience Is not bound.
usage, then that false opinion of obligation and necessity, which struck consciences with great terror when traditions were thought necessary to salvation, is overthrown. For here nothing is required except that Iove be fostered among us by common effort. (LCC, XXI* P. 1206.)
For the order that is necessary, Calvin goes to scripture and, especially, to the witness of the New Testament church In scripture. But here is the difference. Barth will not do this. It is not just a difference in their tasks. Barth cannot go to the New Testament for specific order; he does not believe it is authoritative here. He says: How. authoritative is this controlling picture of the Church in the Christ community is the great miracle of history,” says Brunner. enterprise undertaken at the turn of the l7th century. But did these first Christians of Brunner’s ecclesia… ever exist in such a way that they can be conceived of as the source and norm of all subsequent reflection on the problem of the church? Does it genuine portrayal? To put it bluntly, did this great miracle really happen? Even according to what we find in the witness of the New Testament, not to speak of the first centuries? Does not this picture belong to the sphere of that which never was on Iand or sea, to the world of ideas and ideals? But even supposing that a kind of pneumatic community did actualiy exist in a recognizable form, the decisive question still remains how this community acquires the authority ascribed to it. When we say, “I believe in the Church,” does this mean that I believe In a model picture of Christian community which I have.discovered or addressed, or which has presented itself to me, and which I describe as a great miracle? Basically, is not the attempt to discuss the problem of the Church in terms of this criterion a romantic undertaking which makes no serious attempt at theological deliberation? (C.D., Iv 2, P. 685.) who relies heavily on the New Testament model.) His question is what is the authority for the criterion of the New Testauent church for church order. It’s not that he doesn’t believe the New Testament and the early chureh are witnesses to a form of the body of Christ, but that they are witnesses to a Particular form of the body of Christ. A particular form.
This is not necessarily to be the law of the activity of the Christian community.
Barth says: No church order is perfect, for none has fallen directly from Heaven and none is identical with the basic law of the Christian Community. Even the orders of the primitive New Testament community (whatever form they took) were not perfect, nor are those of the Western Papacy, the Eastern Patriarchate, the Synodal Presbyterian- fsm which derives from Calvin’s system, Anglican: Methodist. Neo-Lutheran and other forms of Episcopacy, or congregationalism with its sovereignty of the individual community. Nor are the orders of all different systems which are derivative variations of these basic types. There is no reason to look proudly and distaste- fully from one to the others. At one time they may all have been
living law sought and in a certain exaggeration found in obedience: and therefore legitimate forms of the Episcopacy, or congregational- ism with its sovereignty of the individual community. Nor are the orders of all different systems which are derivative variations of fully from one to the others. At one time they may all have been living Iaw sought and in a certain exaggeration found in obedience. and therefore legitimate forms of the body of Jesus Christ. Indeed, they may be this still. (C.D., IV 2. P. 718.) For Barth, the New Testament does not attest a model of Christian Fellowship, but “The Life of the Lord in the community.” The life of the Lord in the community.
This is Barth’s basic presuppositlon which Is normative for the order in the church will always be an inquiry concerning Christ’s ordering and commanding and controiling and the corresponding obedience. All order in the form of the church, to be true order, to be the church: must develop in obedience to Jesus Christ. It is this principle which is the basic Iaw of church order for Barth. All church polity This is why it is no surprise that in his whole section on “The Order of the Community” in Iv 2, Barth quotes——— refers even, to Calvin once. Calvin was fundanentally right, says Barth, when he stated, “As for the true church, we believe that it must be governed according to the true policy that our Lord Jesus Christ has established.” (This quote is from Article 29 of the Gallican Confession of l559.) The point of the quote is that Barth belleved Calvin was right in his form of but because it developed out of the centrality of Jesus Christ. Any government that did this was right. The basic order of the church is Christological.
Calvin’s polity confesses that the church is founded upon God’s Word. Or, in his words, tf. the Church is Christ’s kingdom and he reigns by his word alone:.
(LCC, XxI, p. l046). He cites Cyprian the source of concord of the entire church is drawn from Christ’s (LCC, II, P. l047.) But;-while he might follow episcopate alone..
Barth in his radical Christocentrality which says, “Apart from Jesus Christ there is no other principle or telos to constitute and organize and guarantee this body” (C.D., IV l, P. 663). Wouldn’t Calvin’s reliance on the New Testament church make him hesitate when Barth says even the Kerygma, the preached Word, cannot organize the Church, even baptism, and the Lord’s Supper cannot constitute the Church… the faith and ove and hope of Christians: the work and word of the apostle. cannot constitute or organize the Church (C.D., Iv 1, p. 663)? Calvin’s polity and Barth’s theology of the order of the community both recognize that the Church must have order, and all orders are not relative. Their tasks are different. but that alone does not account for Barth’s deliberate ambiguity on the particular order of the Church.
They don’t hold the same view of the authority of the New Testament church as a model for church order. Both Calvin and Barth believe the form of the Church must find its initiative in the lordship of Jesus Christ. But Barth finds under this lordship a spectrum of particular orders.
Cite this resource
DeBevoise, John. “Calvin’s Church Polity.” Calvin Studies II, 1984. PDF. John Calvin Studies, Foundation for Reformed Theology. https://foundationrt.org/resource/calvins-church-polity/.
More from John Calvin Studies
Stay in touch.
Receive seminar announcements, new bibliographies, and quiet word from the Foundation a few times each year.
See the work you support.
Small groups of around six to eight pastors read in advance and gather for a week, with a significant portion of their room, board and travel reimbursed.
