Foundation for Reformed Theology
Calvin’s 1536 Institutes
https://foundationrt.org/resource/calvins-1536-institutes/
Calvin’s 1536 Institutes
McKee reflects on the 1536 first edition of Calvin’s Institutes of the Christian Religion at its 450th anniversary, drawing together familiar and less-familiar features to recover the book’s identity as the church’s book of doctrine and piety.
- Author
- Elsie Anne McKee
- Published
- Source
- Calvin Studies III
- Pages
- 33–38
Calvin’s 1536 Institutes
PDF, 6 pages, 217 KB
Full text
Corrections are welcome. This text was produced automatically from a scanned copy (OCR) and may contain errors. For the authoritative version, please refer to the PDF.
Calvin’s l536 Institutes: The Church’s Book by Elsie Mckee ciaily to have the opportunity to say a few words about one of the great theologian-pastors of the Christian church. The remarkableness of the person is evident in the book for which we celebrate the 45oth birthday this year. John Calvin’s Institutes of the Christian Religion has been studied repeatediy, particularly in the edition of”i5sg. On this anni- versary I cannot add anything new to the discussion of the Inst.itutes of 1536, but I should 1ike to bring together.a few of the many things one could say in hopes that the juxtaposition of well-known and less——— known It is often said that Calvin is very consistent, and he is. This does not mean, however, that he,did not learn and mature, did not de- velop new facets of his-thought.
I would ilke to suggest some of the rather distincttve characteristics of the l536 Institutes. Piease note the qualification; in emphasizing discontinuity, the continuity must not be forgotten.
As Is wel1 known, Calvin had two principal purposes,in mind when he wrote and published the first edition of the Institutes. Even as a re- cent convert himself, Caivin had been’ besieged with’pieas for instruc- tion. Thus he had begun the book as a kind of catechism for: the young French church, the new evangelicais who needed a clear statement of: their faith.
when I first set my hand to this work… my purpose was touched with any zeal for religion might be shaped to true godl ness. And I undertook this labor especialiy for our. thirsting for Christ: very few who had been imbued with’ even a slight. knowledge of him. The book itself witnesses that this was my intention, adapted as it Is to a simple and, you may say, elementary form of teaching.
In the tense context of 1535, when Anabaptists at Muenster were giving a bad name to all who broke wtth Rome, Calvin realized that his fellow be- 1ievers needed aiso to be clearly distinguished fram the radicals. Thus the young scholar addressed his work to the French ktng, Francis I, as an apologia for the evangellcal integrity and political.orderliness of persecuted French Protestants.
nothing was farther from my mind, most glorious King, than to write something which might be.
offered to your But I perceived that the fury of certain Majesty..
34 is no place in it for sound doctrlne. Consequently, it seemed made confession before you with the same work. From this you may learn the nature of the doctrine against which those mad- men burn with rage, who today disturb your realm with fire and sword. And indeed I shall not fear to confess that I have here embraced almost the sum of that very doctrine which they and shout must be punished by prison, exile, proscriptton, fire, and be exterminated on land and sea.
Indeed, I know with what horrible reports they have filled your ears and But, mind, to render our cause as hateful as possibie to you. ifäit as fits your clemency, you ought to weigh the fact that is enough merely to make accusations, then no innocence wi11 remain either in words or deeds.
ulius Koestiin has pointed out that in 1536 the first three chapters, on law, creed, and prayer, are the primary catechetical portion of the Institutes and perhaps the more important half of the book. (In fact, In later editions of the Institutes, tne credal emphasis expands until three chapters of the first edition, especially five and six, are more polemical and more clearly apologetic——— not. in the modern sense of a rattonal prolegomenon to belief but as a confident statement of the true faith, distinguishing it from alt perversions. Thus the two purposes, catechetical and apologetic, are also reflected in the shape of the book* In time the audience for the catechesis shifted slightly. The Institutes were stii1 intended to open the scriptures to the people of to outweigh the purpose of educating simple layfoik. This was not per- haps deltberatei Calvin in fact translated later editions into French for the 1iterate laity. However, the enormous growth of the final edi- tion, the one Calvgn himself preferred, suggests that the primary audi——— ence was students.
The.apologetic purpose, too, was never lost; the epistle to Francis I was retained throughout. As it became evident that the French kings would not 1isten, the emphasis on apologla receded. The 1536 Institutes was thus in some ways uniqueiy the book of the church——— the lay church, the new believers. Less “systematic,!t more was the confesslon of.scattered, persecuted handfuls of christians who price, even exile, imprisonment, or death.
On a lighter note, it is amusing to polnt out some forgotten tun- characteristictt facts about the Institutes of 1536. The Calvin legend”t is ever with us; one can. count on people automatlcally associating the One interest ing
35 point, which always surprises such people, is the fact that the word predestination does not appear in the first edition of the Institutes, and there is only a hint of the topic itself in the discussions of the church.
Some (including the speaker) would say that this is perfectly approprlate, since election in Calvin should. be understood as an implj- cate of faith, not a subject of speculatlon.
Another fascinating point, and one which has oniy recentiy been un- covered, is the treatment of women’s roles in the Institutes, especlally In 1536. It appears that those who have bltthely quoted’ Calvin to deny ecclesiasticai office or ordination to women wiil have to find another ence to women’s public roies in 1536 is fn the context of the discussion women to keep silent in church among the indifferent things, the ex- ternal polity of the church which can be changed as ldeas of seeml iness and edificat ion change!9 In later editions Calvin cails women’ts silence a matter of order ratner than decortm as in 1536, but he continues to regard this text as an example of adtaphora. (In fact, Calvin is appar- entiy the oniy mainstream Protestant to classify 1 Cor. 14:34 this way, though his own practtce was very traditional. Evidently decorum and order in the sixteenth-century did not stretch as far as they could in future generat ions.)
A wel1-known but very important characteristtc of the Institutes which is most evident in the earliest editions ls the rhetorical beauty and biting wit of Caivin’s wrtting. One numorous example of the latter supposed to have despised).
:’But… [indifferent things]… are more important than 1s commonly bel ieved. For when consciences have once ensnared themselves, they enter a long and inextricable maze, not easy to get out of. If a man begins to doubt whether he may use 1inen for sheets, shirts, handkerchiefs, and napkins, he wi11 afterward be uncertain also about hemp -and finally, doubt whether he can sup without napkins, or go without handker- chiefs…. If he boggles at sweet wine, he will not with distinctive features, I remembered a curious question which I had never In a passing coment in an article chiefly had time to investigate.
concerned with a comparison of Bucerts and Calvin’s catechisms, acques Courvoisier makes the provocative claim that Calvin came to Strasbourg a Lutherant and, under,the infiuence of Bucer, was transformed into a 1I’ tiReformedt theologian.
Courvoisier bases this yiew on the fact that
36 it. is in strasbourg that Calvin develops his teaching on the church from a focus on the:invisible to the cleariy visible. An apt quotation from the German theologian Hundeshagen makes the point: for Lutherans, the Church is a locus in systematic theology, while,for the Reformed, it Is As further evidence, Courvoisier highlights the oft-noted fact that ln 1536 Calvin follows Luther in ordering his topics. Law comes first, then faith or creed, then prayer, and so forth.: According. to Courvoisier, this order is altered in ‘iater editions of the Institutes; from 1539 on, faith is chisms of Capito and Bucer in the early 1530s.
To recast Courvoisier’s thought, one might ask if this first Instl- tutes, the book of the church, was a!so in fact much less a book’ about Cer- tainly there is development.
However, Courvoisier’s chal lenging assertions seem rather extreme. with regard to the ordertng of the material, it seems iikely that Luther and’ Calvin both were following a much older catechetical tradition. Further, an examination of the contents of the chapter on law suggests that Calvin already he.ld the characteristically Reformedtt insistence on the third use, though’this receives less prominence than in later edi——— tions. More Importantiy, the 1536 organizat ian of the chapter entitled tton the Lawt does not begin abruptly with law*.
but in fact has strong similarit’ies to the later overal1 organization of the Institutes. Calvin ftrst sketches his characteristic schema of.the knowledge of God and of ourselves, then treats briefly the image of God and the fall, Christ, grace, and. justification by faith. Only then does the reformer turn to the decalog and conclude with a comment on the three uses of the law. The shift between the Institutes of 1536 and 1539 does not seem as clear; the 1536,material is greatly expanded but not essentially altered.
The quotation from Hundeshagen points up a fact which many, have noted.
reaction to abuses; positive, practical ecclesiology expands most in 1543, after the strasbourg sojourn. Two points should be noted, though. In 1536 Calvin was not seeking to organize the church but to purify and reform It. He was not concerned so ‘much with ‘polity as with doctrine and correcting abuses. when the Institutes became primarily a textbook for theologian-pastors, more practical discussion of ecclesiology was necessary. Secondiy, despite the lack of practical application in 1536, the beginning.
It remains true, however, that the Institutes of 1536 is the book of lay christlans whose office was.not ecclesiasttcal organ- ization but witness to their faith.
In conciuding one might ask why we are focusing on the Institutes of 1536, if Caivin himself felt this had long been superseded. Most
37 of a child, no matter how much richer and more mature the adult may be. As a historian, I must also say that studying the varlous stages of the developing book has a particular fascination: from the promise of the bud through the full biooming of what is rightly regarded as the single seventeenth centuries came a long period of declining interest In Calvin. Then, some would say ttunexpectedly,tt came the twentieth-century revival of Luther studles and of Calvin studies; with these, the much-neglected exegetical works of the theologian-pastor. It.
is faithful, prickly friend among the saints, Uohn Calvin. Notes An oider but exceilent discussion of the development of the Institutes is Julius Koestlin, ‘calvins Institutio nach Form und Inhait, In ihrer gescnichtlichen Entwickiung,tt Theologische studien und Kritiken, 1868, pp. 6-62, 410-486. See also John T. MeNei11, “Introduction,i Press, 196o), pp. xxix-ixxi. (Hereafter: Institutes.) John Calvin, Institution of the Christian Religion, trans. and annotated by F. L. Battles (At1anta: John Knox Press, 1975), pp. y-iviii. (Here- after: Institution.)
Institution, p. 1.
Institution, p. 1.
Koestlin, op. cit., pp. 21, 23, 27.
Institutes, itJohn Calvin to the Reader,tt p. 4. Calvin ( (Kassel: Oncken, 1937), pp. 61-62.
Jane Dempsey Douglass, women, Freedom, and Calvin (phi ladelphia: Westminster Press, 1985).
decorum be established through the addition of observances that form, as It were, a bond of union. But In these observances one thing must be always guarded against. They are not to be considered necessary for salvation and thus bind consciences by scruples; nor are they to be as- sociated with the worship of God, so that piety is lodged in them… There are examples of [thisl sort ln Paul: that women should not teach
38 in church (I Cor. 14:14-34l, that they should go out with heads covered [I Cor. ll:5ffl. And examples can be seen i’n the everyday habits of 1iving, such as: that we pray with knees bent and head bare:. 10 Institution, p. 245. 11 ttles catechismes de Geneve et de stras- Jacques Courvoisier, t 84 (1935), pp. 107, 120. 12 Courvoisier, op. cit., p. 120, citing Hundeshagen as quoted in D. Ritschl, Dogmengeschichte des Protestantismus, vol. 3, p. 129. 13, Koest1in, oP:.cit., pp. 28-29. 14.
courvoisier, op. cit., p. 1o7, cttes the parallel tables in Opera Calvini, vol. 1, pp.’li-iviii, but these do not fully support him. 16 Alexandre Ganoczy, Le. jeune. Calvin: Genese. et évolution de _sa yocation reformatrice (wiesbaden: Franz steiner, 1966), e.g., pp. 79, 239.
Cite this resource
McKee, Elsie Anne. “Calvin’s 1536 Institutes.” Calvin Studies III, 1986. PDF. John Calvin Studies, Foundation for Reformed Theology. https://foundationrt.org/resource/calvins-1536-institutes/.
More from John Calvin Studies
Stay in touch.
Receive seminar announcements, new bibliographies, and quiet word from the Foundation a few times each year.
See the work you support.
Small groups of around six to eight pastors read in advance and gather for a week, with a significant portion of their room, board and travel reimbursed.
