The Presbyterian Church and Calvinism

Brian G. Armstrong assesses the state of the Presbyterian Church and its commitment to theological tradition, arguing that the post-war embrace of existentialism has produced a largely a-historical mindset in church and academy, and proposes practical steps for recovering Reformed heritage.

Published
Source
Calvin Studies III
Pages
89–93

The Presbyterian Church and Calvinism

PDF, 5 pages, 201 KB

Download PDF

Full text

Corrections are welcome. This text was produced automatically from a scanned copy (OCR) and may contain errors. For the authoritative version, please refer to the PDF.

Remarks on the state of the Presbyterian Church and its Commitment to Theological Tradition by Brian G. Armstrong My brief remarks wi11 center around two points: (1) The cur- rent situation in the church as I understand it, both with regard to Reformed theology. It wt11 quickly become apparent that I find very suggest that there is’any serious 1nterest either in the Reformed heritage. Indeed, it pains me to say that I find in our church whether of the Reformed variety or not.

(2) Because I find it of no parttcular value just to decry the lack of interest in the churchts tradition and theological heritage, I wiil make some sug- gestions about pract.ical steps which we can take to help remedy the sttuat lon.

forced to seek ways to deal with) the consequence of the widespread The Inordinate emphasis on a personal istic world-and-life vtew has immediate ‘meaning for me,” nothing which is not “relevant,” has church and society a mindset which ts aimost totaliy a-historical. Everything is evaluated, and valued, on the basis of its relevance arises: what value can the events ‘of the past possibly have for my problems of the moment? As an historian, 1t is a constant struggle worthwhile even if there is no easy or apparent application to a while it is extremely difficult, it is possibie when a student is open to learn.

If anything, ‘the a-historical mood which results from the -acceptance of exstentialist philosophy is a much greater problem place, because existential ism has been widely (one can almost say thoroughly) accepted among Protestant. theologians, the a-htstorical worid vtew has become part and parcel of church thinking and teach- this country who Is not profoundiy infiuenced by existentialism. church history Instructors, Presbyterlan teaching and preaching are constantiy passing on this perspective. This is not an entirely negative development in the church, for much nineteenth century theology was so thoroughiy theoretical that there was often no appl ication to the problems of daily ltfe.

But the result of the 68

90 wholesale adoption of the existentialist program among our theolo- gians and teachers is finally much more tragic than the theoretical emphasis of earlier theology, for it has resulted in complete dis- interest in the traditions of the church, and is presentiy resuiting In almost total disinterest in theology itseif.

The double disinterest in tradition and theology is excused, even promoted, under the smokescreen that the twentieth century church must marshal alt fts forces to meet the crying needs of the hour——— social injustice, the evtls of the capitalistic economic sys- tem, the scandal of the disunity among Christians, and the 1ike. Anyone who raises a voice to pramote the cause of our noble tradi——— tion is treated with disdain, and whatever is offered in defense of that tradition is brushed aside as useless and therefore urworthy of serious consideration. One gets the feel ing that a massive, collec- tive guiit feeling exists in the church which governs ali its think- ing. One further gathers that this masstve feeling of guilt can only be expiated by support ing and promoting causes which distance taken part and which it has at times defended. rhe result is a tragic forsaking of the traditions for which the church stands. Generally the arguments to support this subversion of the Presbyterian system are related to the cause of church union where it is supposed that a repudiation of denominational distinctives this case, the rejection of the system Is deliberate. Ecumenicity ls a more nobie cause, and if it requires the severing of ourselves fram the past, so be it. The thinking of these modern-day prophets of ecumenicity seems never to rise above the betief that by pushing aside our traditions we dtssociate ourselves from the ievilstt which Is thelr faith in this program that they never seem to stop and deal with the issue that some form of church goverrment, and some theo- logical traditton, must be establlshed, and that whatever polity and theology is adopted, it, too, has been besmirched by involvement in the social, economic, and disunion evils of the present. day. And church is more and more toward a hierarchical structure, a structure other.

In spite of the amazement I continue to feel over the move- ment toward the episcopal system, what I find as a historian to be these ‘prophetstt to think that it is possible to dissociate oneself from history itself: so powerfui is the a-historical mindset that it blindly accepts the ldea that the way for the church to move ahead, to build a better history, is to deny its present history. Beyond that, when they are presented with the idea that by denying the ians, they shrug and respond, so what?ii I have a serlous problem

91 with the integrity of those who wish to continue calling themseives Presbyterian while rejecting Presbyterian traditions, and I have an of. If we think we can bulld a future by denying our past, then we are most sadly deceived indeed.

There appears also to be a ttpopulistit mental ity which governs much of the decisions and direction of the church today. while this does not preclude a movement toward episcopacy in the area of pol——— idea of a majestic God, a God who inhabits eternity and governs the affalrs of earth, is rejected out of hand. It seems that the egali- dealing with the basic issues of existence. In short, any idea which transcends the immediate becomes irrelevant as we seek meaning in the here and row.

Finally, it doesn’t need to be said that the basic direction of the church is to be fashionable in all that for which it stands, whether in desexing the Bibie and the worship documents of the remaining stlent about the vicious tmperialistic action of Russia in Afghanistan, or the Marxist program of mass starvation in Eritrea!), tne modern mind. It has become a church which seems to be more in- terested in proving it is t’rnodernt than a church which takes seri——— denomination an egotistical presumpt ion that we moderns are far wiser than our predecessors, a presumpt ion which Is both an evidence of a’ lack of respect for the past and an overweening pride in the position of modern man. It is an attitude which wiil not only de- stroy the tradition, but will also ruin the future. But while we can catalog the ills of the present church in the fashion that they have dealt with the historical church, if we take our traditton seriously we have an obligatton to do more than decry the present folly. Hence I want to add a few suggestions of positive action which we might take to preserve the tradition while at the same time finding ways to apply the message of that tradition in the twentieth century.

As a first step, we need to give priority to the matter of 1eges.

It is a grand tradition; it lles at the root of the whoie democratic tradition of America. we need constant iy to promote and present its history and contribution in a sympathetic way. But. in doing this, we need to take seriousiy the problems.which exlsted to cause the wholesale repudiation of a noble past. we must recognize in theology that too often we have taught the disciptine as if it were another branch of philosophy. Theology is not, nor can it be,

92 tual1y comprehended and defended. we must enthusiast ically embrace the truth that faith is the fundamentum of theology, that edifica- tion of the saints is its purpose, and that shorn of its spiritual dimension theology becomes lifeless. And as we teach our tradition we must begin with its founders, appreciating the tradition they sought to preserve through its reformation, and grasping the funda- mentals of the teaching of Zwingii, Caivin, Knox, and their contem- porarles. Only when this foundation has been laid should we go on to introduce them to Brunner and Barth, Bavinck and Berkouwer, or Kung and King.

A second step we should take is to offer for our church leaders refresher courses tn theology and the history of the in pastoral counsel ing, Refomed traditton, rather than courses social awareness, and the ltke.

we must restore to our tradition the idea that the main function of the minister is the proclamation of tne word of God; that his or her time should not be frittered work should be returned to the 1ay leadership of the church where it belongs. There should be regular refresher courses at centers 1ike Davidson, Presbyterian, Erskine, Union, King, Montreat, etc., and these shouid tle into the continuing education plans of our minis- ters and youth leaders.

A third step we should take is to begin producing church school materials which feature the history of the Reformed tradi- t.

terest of the people and effectively communicate that they are part of a noble tradition. One of these ways could be brief biographical vignettes of the great figures of the church, always tying in what they stood for as well as who they were.

Too frequently we have left the writing of these materials to the appointees of the bureau- are the folk who are least suited to be making that. kind of deci- slon. They wit1 aiways be more concerned about correcting the sins of the fathers, producing activists, finding ways to accommodate the civi1 rights lobby, or the women’s rights lobby, or whatever happens to be the tiin thing’t of the moment, than they wtii be concerned about the spiritual growth of the people and the promotion of a sober recognition of the grand tradition of the Reformed. A fourth step we should continue to take is the use of con- ferences 1ike this one to teach, to challenge, and to promote the values of the Reformed tradtt ion. The encouragement which is forth- coming from the coming together of the scholars of the tradition and the teaders of the local churches is of inestimable value for both groups. And, from the practical’ side, the corrective value for the schotars to hear from those on the front line,t and vice versa, is also of inestimable value. we should make conferences like this one a highiight of the church year, encourage sessions to put in the budget funds to send their ministers and youth leaders to such con- ferences, and do more to advertise such meetings.

93 Finally, I am convinced that a fifth step which wouid do much to support and proamote our theology and traditions would be the pro- duction of inexpensive editions of theological treatises, sermons, commentaries, and other writings of the great figures of the church. with the widespread use of the word processor which characterizes our 1ives, the production of such materials could be both easiiy done and Inexpensively provided. Again we should not be bashful enterprise, for the return in lay interest would easily offset a for church school classes, retreats, even conferences 1 ike this one. The sermons and ccmmentaries of Caivin, for example, are much more readable and spiritually challenging than almost any sermons or comnentarfes of the modern church. Reading them wouid naturaliy bring a new awareness and appreciation of his work, and serve to strengthen our tradit ion.

In conciusion, we have much to be concerned about as we vlew the programs, 1iterature, and directlon of our church. But our response should not be one of creating a cult of professional gossip mongers, nor of cutting and running, but we should rather energeti- cally move’ to establish prograns, 1iterature, and impulses which will shore up, and ultImately preserve, the noble heritage which we

Cite this resource

Armstrong, Brian G. “The Presbyterian Church and Calvinism.” Calvin Studies III, 1986. PDF. John Calvin Studies, Foundation for Reformed Theology. https://foundationrt.org/resource/the-presbyterian-church-and-calvinism/.

More from John Calvin Studies

All 95 Calvin studies

Stay in touch.

Receive seminar announcements, new bibliographies, and quiet word from the Foundation a few times each year.

See the work you support.

Small groups of around six to eight pastors read in advance and gather for a week, with a significant portion of their room, board and travel reimbursed.