Calvinism as Theocentric Humanism

William J. Bouwsma reads Calvin as a child of the Renaissance, arguing that theology is a human activity deeply shaped by its historical moment and that Calvin’s thought becomes intelligible only when situated within the cultural circumstances of sixteenth-century Europe.

Published
Source
Calvin Studies II
Pages
21–32

Calvinism as Theocentric Humanism

PDF, 12 pages, 506 KB

Download PDF

Full text

Corrections are welcome. This text was produced automatically from a scanned copy (OCR) and may contain errors. For the authoritative version, please refer to the PDF.

21 Calvinism as Renaissance Artifact by william J. Bouwsma I should like in this paper, through a particular case, to make a general point that seems to me insufficiently appreciated by both historians and theologians, for rather different reasons but with much often remarkably sensitive to its historical context, and which can therefore tell us a good deal about the past; and conversely that theological discourse can often be understood only with some knowledge of the circumstances surrounding its expression.

Calvin is useful to make this point, first of all because he is widely perceived as the source of a movement of great Importance In the formation of modern civilization. Indeed, he has left his mark on the their favorite outdoor cafe, and they introduced me to their favorite waiter, a young man named Carlo, who was always curious about the people he waited on. One of my friends told him that I was an American professor. and he added——— rather mischievously——— that I was working on John Calvin. Carlo looked blank at this fascinating datum, until my friend said, wYou know——— Giovanni Calvino.” Suddeniy Carlo’s face lit up, and he exclaimed, “oh! He was the one who made the’ big mess up there!”r In spite of this remarkable name recognition, Calvin has been little studied by general historians. (Indeed, it might be observed that theologians have rarely been of nuch fnterest to historians, unless they could also be showm to have some extra-theological significance). I am not well informed on such matters, but it is my impression that even Marxist historians have been insufficiently interested in theology to bother to expose it as superstructure. Historians have, on the whole, left Calvin to theologians or to Calvin specialists, who have been little concerned to depict him as a historical figure——— as a child of his age.

The reasons for this historiographical eglect are complex. It intimidated into Ieaving such personages to specfalists. Or perhaps we have assumed that intellectual and artistic distinction is so exceptional that those who possess it are somehow elevated above historical processes altogether. are less representative of their time and less likely to be informative about it than second-raters.

That this is a mistake is suggested by one of the greatest twentieth-century works in cultural history, Lucien Febvre’s remarkable study of Rabelais, with its profound remarks about the sixteenth-century

22 mind.1 from the historical life swirling about them: though I think this a possibility that can easily be exaggerated. But it seems to me more iikely for distinction of mind to be accompanied by unusual sensitivity to its surroundings and unusual ability to comment on their signifi- cance. I also think that some theologians have particular talents along these lines. I am quite sure that this was the case with Calvin. But something else has kept historians away from theology and theologians: a pronounced and often unexamined secularist bias, a tacit assumption that theology has little to do with the real world that concerns historians, but only with another kind of world, “up there, i.e.: unrelatable except in corrupted forms——— to real life. Although this secularist bias is now being challenged by some very good histor- ians, it has meanwhile subtly collaborated, I suspect, with a tendency among some theologlans to think of theology as an,activity that stands apart from other disciplines and above them. In this view tao, theology is concerned with higher truths: eternal truths. absolutely different in kind from the transitory realities of our lower historical world, from whose influence theologians——— at least when they are doing theology——— are also insulated. The result, at any rate, has been the persistence of a kind of two-tiered intellectual universe, a realm of eternal truths above and of contingency below, corresponding to the pre-Copernican separation of spheres has been aided, in the case of Calvin, by the harsh, rigid, inhuman, and unlovable, but also of Calvinism and therefore of Calvin himself as the source of this strange fdeal.for the human personality.

is the support it gives to the depiction of Calvin as a systematic theologian, as the great systematizer of the Protestant Reformation. This representation of Calvin is also usually accompanied by a quite unexamined assumption that system is a Good Thing in itself, and especially a Good Thing in theology. “system” can, of course, mean quite different things. It can mean no more than the temporary ordering of concepts for purposes of instruction. Every good teacher knows how to do this, and as a systematic thinker usually mean something else: that he made intelligible, in a definitive way, the “real” connections and implica- tions of the gospel, more or Iess as God himself intended us to understand them, so that we can reiy absolutely on Calvin’s guidance. It may also be true that Calvin sometimes inadvertently encouraged this lLe Probleme de l’incroyance au xVIe siecle. La religlon de Rabelais (Paris, 1942), recently translated by Beatrice Gottlieb, The Problem of Unbellef in the Sixteenth Century: the Religion of Rabelas (Cambridge, Mass., 1982).

Among them ny Berkeley colleague, Henry F. May.

23 view of his accomplishment, though I doubt that he would have cared to defend it. In any case, much in what he said. would seem to preclude it. And I will argue that, except in the most practical and pedagogical sense, Calvin was not a systematlc theologian; that, however skillful he may have been in ordering theological concepts for pedagogical reasons: he deeply abhorred theological system-butlding as a kind of vlolence those who understand Calvin as a systematizer in this sense can only do so by misreading him, or reading him in oddly selective ways; and finally that a better grasp of sixteenth-century culture would make such an interpretation of Calvin largely Impossible.

I say largely impossible because this view of Calvin is not quite wrong. Like other major thinkers of the sixteenth century, and indeed for some time before: Calvin was complex and eclectic, engaged in an effort to marshal and manage a bundle of contradictory intellectual Some of these, if isolated and fully developed, impulses and resources.

were systematic, though they often pointed in contradictory directions. Stoic or a Neoplatonist because they did not realize that every sixteenth-century intellectual was something of both, as well as of a good deal else. In fact the bits and pieces of different systems in Calvin’s thought make him not more systematic but harder to classify: less coherent. In addition, when Calvin was put on the defensive, as often happened, he sometimes succumbed to the temptation to take refuge in systematic constructions of a kind that he ordinarily distrusted. The systematic Calvin was mostly, however, another historical artifact: the artificial construct of his followers of the ater sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, when human insecurity and the yearning for social and political order received symbolic expression in a great wave of system buiiding of the kind that Calvin sought to avoid. It is characteristic, of course, of the philosophy and natural science of this period, and we can also see it in Roman Catholic theology; but it is more’striking in Lutheranism and Calvinism because they had originally been opposed to this kind of theologizing. In this development the attitudes, the methodology, even the vocabulary of.medieval scholastic theology, long under attack first by Renalssance humanists and then by Protestant Reformers, were everywhere revived. The notion of a systematic Calvin, then, seems to me to have a and self-evident truths that Francois Turretini, one of Calvin’s most century, required in theology.

But even the scholastic method of generating such truths was not enough by itself. It requlred validation itself by an appeal to past practice. The consequence illustrates a curious feature of the history of Protestantism. It had arisen out of a sense of the impossibility of holy men in this life; but by the seventeenth century it was making saints of its own founding fathers. Quoted in John W. Beardslee. ed.: Reformed Dogmatics: J. Wolleblus, G. Voetius F..Turretin (New York, 1965),”i2.

So Calvin, who had sought to demolish systematic theology, had to be remade in the image of his systematizing sons——— who, however: were largely ceasing to read him. They found Turretini more congenial. There is a kind of a priori argunent against the notion of a systematizing Calvin. It is that some cultural situations appear to support efforts to systematize: while others do not: not only in theology but in every kind of activity. Thus the thirteenth century the seventeenth. But the period between, which the sixteenth century brought to a climax, was not only innospltable to systematic thought but attacked it and everywhere undermined the possibility of it. Even the effect was to challenge the marvelous coherence of a traditional. comprehensive: utterly systematic cosmology that had also been survived only in smali, relatively isolated pockets. What characterizes the great figures in the cultural expression of this period is their complexity, their exuberant variety, their resistance.to reductlon to system. We argue about them, we find them continuously fascinating. because they always elude our grasp. This is also to say that they are impossible to embalm: they remain alive——— Erasmus, Thomas More, Machiavelli, in the earlier century; Raphael and Michelangelo; Montaigne. Cervantes, and Shakespeare.

I should Iike to present Calvin to you In’this company. The accomplishments of these figures depended not on their systematic coherence but on their ability, somehow and not without strain, to manage contradictory forces, to triumph over variety without denying It. Stephen Greenblatt’s elegant description of More’s Utopia seems to me playground in which a shifting series of apparently incompatible impulses can find intensesexpression without flying apart or turning Calvin’s Institutes——— and his commentaries and sermons and polemical tracts and Ietters——— may also be seen as a kind of playground. Need I say that this is not to deny their deep seriousness? But a systematic: Calvin, as that term Is usually understood, would be an anomaly and an änachronism. But Calvin himself can help us.to understand his thought as a historical artifact, above all by the convenient manner In which he age. He did so in numerous passages that are often overlooked precisely because, since they attach him quite precisely to particular concerns of Turretin’s Institutio theologicae elencticae. first published in 3 volumes in Geneva,l680-83, remained the basic text in theology (in Latin) for students in the Princeton Seminary until the later nineteenth century, when it at last gave way to Charles Hodge’s Systematic Theology, also in three voiumes (New York. l87l-73). 5.

Renaissance Self-Fashioning: More to Shakespeare (Chicago, 198o). pp. 56-57.

25 time and place, they have seemed to most of his readers “irrelevant” to his supposedly perennial significance. These are passages in which he attacked the Scholastic theologilans, the scolasticl, and thereby identified himself with a particular community of discourse of major Calvin attacked the Schoolmen for a long series of unlovely traits: for immodesty, presumption, subtlety, curiosity, and disputatiousness; for pretending ta know things of which they were ignorant; for intellectual dishonesty, therefore, and incomprehensibility, and for barbarism and ignorance. He contrasted them at some length with the Fathers. The Fathers, he believed, had been opposed in their own day to the dedicatory epistle of the Institutes, had “abhorred with one voice” and had “detested the fact that God’s Holy Word has been contaminated. by the subtleties of sophists and nvolved in the squabbles of What, if the fathers were now brought back to dialecticians….

life, and heard such a brawling art as these persons call speculative theology, there is nothing,they would less suppose than that these folk I also want to quote here a somewhat longer passage (from Calvin’s commentary on First Timothy) where the biblical text denounces people Here, Calvin says, St. Paul “had in mind the kind of question that today is dealt with in the schools of the Sorbonne, to make a display of intellectual ability. There one question leads to another, for there is no end to them when everybody indulges his vanity in seeking to know more than he ought. and these give rise to infinite quarrels. As fn hot weather thick clouds cannot be dispersed without thunder, so these thorny questions are bound to break out in disputes… If anyone investigates carefully the kind of questions that are of burning concern are concocted out of nothing… the sophists… have no concern for edification and turu God’s Word into trivialities and a source of These figures are: in a word. the system builders. Their discourse reflects, not real human concerns and -practical needs, but professional pressures to perfect the systems 6.

It is of particular interest that even a scholar as sensitive to the historical element in Calvin’s thought as Ford Lewis Battles did not regard Calvin’s references to “scholastics” and “scholasticism” as significant enough for inclusion in the index to his excellent edition of the Institutes, although he did list “sophists,” an epithet that——— like other humanists——— Calvin sometimes applied to the Scholastics. Institutes of the Christian Religion, ed. Ford Lewis Battles (London,”i961), l, 22; hereafter cited as Inst. and by book, chapter, and section.

Comm. I Tim. 6:4. Ali references to Calvfn’s commentaries are to The translations are my’own, though I have referred to other translations.

complete it, make it alrtight and——— not altogether incidentally——— to promote the reputatlons of those engaged in these tasks. I have quoted here at some length because I want to place, side by side with these passages from Calvin, two others. I would like to keep the names of their authors in suspense for a moment: although I know This prattling of the dialecticians will never come to an end. It throws up summaries and definitions like bubbles. matter indeed for endless controversies; but for the most part these people know nothing of the real truth of the things they talk about.. The best way to deal with this brood, with their studied air of insouci- ance and empty curiosity, is to launch at their heads some such invective as this: “You wretched creatures, why this everlasting Iabor for nothing, thfs expense of wit on silly subtleties? Why, in total oblivion of the real basis of things, will you grow old simply conversant with words, and with whitening hair and wrinkled brow, spend all your time in infantile babble?

And here is another text aiong somewhat the sane Iines: I do not so much admire those things, the so-called metaphysics, and the modes of significations and other things of the sort: which or admire like the epicycles of the planets; nor do I think it of difficulties that it would be better to ignore, since they impede our knowledge of better things. I will not bring any arguments to support this, though I could do so; but I will cite the ancient theologians, Cyprian, Lactantius, Hilary, Ambrose, Jerome, Augustine, who not only have not dlscussed these things in their books but have not even mentioned them. Out of ignorance, perhaps? But how could that be?…the writings of the fathers were most cultivated (latinissimi), while the modern (theologians) are almost barbarians. I will keep you in suspense no longer. These quotations come from the two most original and influential among the Italian humanists. The first is from Petrarch’s Secretum and is part of a long denunciation of scholastic theology by “Franciscus,” to which “Augustinus” replies, “I agree that nothing half gevere enough can be said of this monstrous The second ls from Lorenzo Valla’s Encomion on Saint.Thomas Aguinas.

In Francesco Petrarca, Opere, ed. Giovanni Ponte (Milan l968), although I generally follow the translation of William H. Draper (London, 191l). pp. 29-30 for the quotation.

10.

In Lorenzo Vaila, Scritti filosofici e religlosl, ed. Giorgio Radetti (Florence, 1953). My understanding of the Encomion has been Rinascimento: Encomion s. Thomae——— l457, Memorie Domenicane, n. 7 (1976): 1-140.

27 of these works. This is possible, but I care so little that I have made no attempt to look into the matter, although I doubt that the attempt to establish a direct connection would be successful. What I want to suggest here is that, in his attacks on the scolastici, Caivin identifies himself, clearly and decisively, with the attitudes of Renaissance humanism. Developing first in Italy, these were undoubtedly mediated to (unlike Luther), Calvin rarely expressed hostility. Further: once we have accepted Calvin’s identification of himself with Renaissance humanism, I think that much else about him, both in the substance of his discourse and in Calvin’s intentions, fall into place. Difficult questions——— questions slmply fgnored or begged in the received version of Calvin as systematist——— can then be answered.

First of all this identification helps us to recognize the degree to which Calvin abhorred systematic theology as a matter of principle. He saw himself as a biblical theologian, working with and following texts, not coercing them with logic. He contrasted what he described as the most beautifui economy of the Scriptures” with the philosophical On the other hand, his repudiation of system had its positive corollary in his recognition of the'”paradoxes at the heart of the gospel, which, he noted, “are contemptuously rejected by the common That God became a mortal man, that life is submissive to death, that righteousness has been concealed under the likeness of sin,”t and so 12 on.

It is hard to understand how anyone who has read Calvin could still maintain the systematic nature of his theology.His writing is filled with powerful imagery, unexpected imaginative insights, psycholog- ical apercus, rhetorical elaborations, digressions and repetitlons that were intended to serve a polemical, instructional, or other practical purpose. Calvin expressed himself in the style of Renaisaance humanism. A second major consequence follows for our understanding of Calvin once we have identified him as a humanist. Humanism: as a movement, had.always displayed a remarkable sensitivity to the concrete historical. circumstances in which it had unfolded. It was, broadly speaking: a self-conscious reform movement, concerned to reform not all times but so with a sense of urgency that was.a major element in its rejection of speculative system-building, which seemed a kind of Iuxury that the times could ill afford. The times called for action! And humanism’s the power to stimulate human beings to appropriate action. 11 Inst. III, vi, l.

12 Comm. John 18:38: see alsa comms. Luke 2:12, Rom. 3:5, I Cor. 1: 21.

28 These aspects of the humanist program are all directly relevant to understanding Calvin. Like other humanists he felt keenly the urgency “How many,”t he will exclaim, “are the distresses with of the times.

[He could vary somewhat the duration of the crisisl. How many are the does not appear that these have done any good.” ‘He embroidered on the 13 And the disasters: wars, famines, pestilence, vices of every kind. central motive force of Caivin’s ife was not to set forth a true theology for the ages, but to remedy the particular evils of his own age. He aimed, not to state truths——— he rarely made truth claims——— but to galvanize other human beings to appropriate action, to induce activity. to obtain results. His instrument for doing so was rhetorical discourse; he was a deliberate, self-conscious rhetorician, who combined the eruditio of his biblical and patristic studies with the Persuasio of an eariier humanist tradition to achieve practical results. Calvin was this was humanly possible——— than to change it. He believed that this was what Christianity was about.

His concern to achieve results explains his introduction into theology of a characteristic humanist preoccupation with what is required for this purpose in the real historical world: power, energy, passion. but it is only one dimension, by no means original with Calvin, of a dynamic rhetorical theology with characteristically humanistic epistemo- logical, anthropological, and other implications. Basic to this rhetorfcal theology is Calvin’s understanding of spiritual reality not as something ideal that can be contrasted with the material, but as power and activity, which ought to interpenetrate all levels of existence. His vocabulary in discussing spirit commonly employed a language of warmth, movement, coming alive, quickening vivificatiol: the language of energy and vitality associated also with Machiavelli. Thus, since God is pure spirit, he must far Calvin be all activity, power in action. So, he declared, God’s virtue [virtus——— He “can another Machiavellian wordl “consists in motion and actfon.” never rest; he suatains the world by his energy he governs everything. This was why Calyin could not endure Aristotle’s conception of God as unmoved mover.

Calvin’s God is always in action.

And this is how we experience him: in his mighty acts. 13.

Com. Is. 9:10.

14.

For this analysis of the stages in the development of Itallan Renaissance humanism, see Camporeale, cit. n. ll. 15.

For what follows I am particularly indebted to Margaret R. Miles: “Theology, Anthropology, and the Human Body in Calvin’s Institutes of the Christian Religion,” Harvard Theological Review: 74 (1981), 303-323. 16.

Comms. Ezek. 1:24, 10:17: cf. comn. Gal. 6:10. 17 Cf. comm. Ezek. 10:17.

29 Correspondingly: human beings, spiritual because of their creation “Men were created to in God’s image and Iikeness. must also be active.:18 Inactivity and idleness; As Calvin saw talents and advantages with which God has endowed us. it, rest is for the wicked, not for the saints. sin, what sin basicaily consists in, how it displays itself in us. sin is of course manifested in death, the total collapse of vitality but also in a whole series of premonitory experiences. The death that came into the world through sin has,already seized on us all; we are already partly dead. We experience this as drowsiness when we shouid be alert. as dullness when we should be attentive, as coldness when we should be In when diligence is required, as weakness when we’ need strength. this conception we can perhaps detect more than a hint of acedia, that thirteenth cegtury, was also spreading among the laity. Petrarch had felt it too.

But these conceptions also point to the significance for Calvin of rhetoric, which, as Quintiilian had pointed out, is an art designed to exciteswarmth in the coldest hearts: stir up the feelings, (I have found similar language in ignatius Loyola). and impel action.

From this standpoint, then, if we follow out what I take to be Calvin’s line of thought, just as sin leads to paralysis and death, so salvation is manifested as recovery of the capacity for action and life. As its etymology suggests salvation consists in the recovery of health and vigor. The aim of the Christian ministry must therefore be to restore the dying to activity and life. And this is its only purpose. The ministry is an utterly goal-oriented and practical affair. It was, of course. Calvin’s objection to the old church, as he perceived it: precisely that it was failing in this respect. Its doctrine, frozen by truth-claims that were in fact mistaken, had become cold, lifeless, and ineffective. It “tortured the mind with empty 18.

Comm. Gen. 2:l5.

19.

Comm. Ps. 127:1.

20 Among numerous examples, see comms. Dan. 9:13, Is. 44:2l, Matt. 26:75, Ps. 84-7 and 119:33; Inst. III, i, 3 (dullness, coldness, apathy. sloth, weakness).

Thought and Literature (Chapel Hill, l960). 22.m This is one of the vices for which he condemns himself in the Secretum.

23.

Institutio oratoria.

30 subtleties and speculations instead of teaching “what is beneficlal or It was incapable of inducing warmth, enthusiasm, and action.

But for Calvin it was crucial to the identification of right doctrine——— this came close to being his only criterion of truth in theology——— that it could produce practical results, that it could engender that warmth, enthusiasm, and action appropriate to the needs of his time. This principle governed his approach to Scripture, which he described as “the school of the Holy Spirit, in which, as nothing is omitted that is both necessary agd useful to know, so nothing is taught Calvin praised what he found in proved useful. The doctrines he discovered or uncovered in Scripture are not so much truths as they are statements about how the spirituai transfused into human beings, and what the consequences of this transfuslon should be. Such practical knowledge was, for Calvin, the only kind accessible to human beings. Here too he thought Catholicism in error insofar as it claimed access to “the real truth of things. identification of himself with the humanists of the Renaissance. He understood the Reformation as a great effort, mediated by language, to ability to act. And this, for Calvin, was a supremely rhetorical task: a task of communicating by words what was appropriate to an audience, in action, obedience, and service. His nodel was God’s own communication by way of Scripture a communication in which God, the best of orators, conveys to human beings what is useful and to the purpose, adapting his message, in accordance with the rhetorical principle of decorum: to times, places, and other circuustances. From this standpoint Christ was himself the great accommodation to human capacity, a revelation of God not as he is in himself, but as he is to and above all for human beings——— which is all we can kow, all we need to know——— as a stimulus to 26 love. obedience, and action.

Here, I think, lies the central principle for understanding Calvin’s theology, the key to reading his intention, and the solution for a good many of the problems and.controversies surrounding hls theology, which was dfrected not to all time but to his own. Here is 24 Coum. Phil. l:lo.

25.

Inst. III, xxi, 3.

26.

Cf. Ford Lewis Battles, “God Was Accommodating Himself to Our Capacity,” Interpretation, 3l (1977), 19-38. Among other passages in Calvin, cf. Inst. Il, vi, 4 on the incarnation as God’s accommodation to us.

31 “It the principle, in the most succinct statement that I have found: would be really a frigid way of teaching if the teachers did not deter- mine carefuliy the needs of the times and what suits. the people concerned, for in this regard nothing is more unbalanced than absolute balance. I should like to close by offering two examples of what Calvin taught, suggesting in each case how differently they appear when they are understood as expressions of a rhetorical theology directed to practical results rather than as elements of a systematic theology intended for the ages. The first is Calvin’s teaching on predesti- nation, which so often in later periods has seemed terrible and repug- nant. Calvin himself readily admitted that this teaching was,beyond all But the It was in practice a source of enormous relief for people consumed with anxiety about their salvation, paralyzed by it, half dead with fear, to know that the absolute power of God guaranteed their salvation. The only alternative to this doctrine in Calvin’s time was to make human beings, however cold, apathetic, inattentive, unreliable, and weak they were, responsible for their own salvation. “Here,” Calvin wrote of is our only strength.

Predestination was true chiefly in the sense that it functioned as a liberation into life, but only, of course, if one avoided speculating about it, avoided converting it into a body of truth claims (and when Calvin became defensive about t, he did not always avoid treating it in this way nimself).

My second example is Calvin’s teaching about the consequences of original sin, which was often expressed in extreme, unbalanced Ianguage. of a kind that has often been taken to mean that he held God’s fmage and obliterated by the fall. Indeed, he argued explicitly against the claim “let us hold this as an undoubted truth which no siege engines he wrote, can shake la piece of rhetorical manipulation of the reader. lf there ever was one!l, that the mind of man has been so estranged from God’s righteousness that it conceives, desires, and undertakes only that which.is impious, perverted, foul, impure, and infamous. The heart is sa steeped in the poison of sin, that it can breathe out nothing but a loathsome stench. If some men occasionally make a show of good, their But here again, I would argue, we have another situation in which, for Calvin, a 28 29.

Inst. III, xxi, l.

30 Cf. comm. John 17:22.

32 balanced statement would have been unbalanced in respect to the needs of the time, which called for repentance and humiiity. For a more “balanced” statement we would need to turn to other passages in his writings that at least imply a very different view: for example, Calvin’s rebuke to Job for cursing the day of his birth on the ground thataJob long after 31 I hope I have safd enough. then, to suggest that an understanding of the historicity of theological discourse may be essential to a proper interpretatfon of its substance.

31 Serm. Job For the fullest and most balanced statement of Calvin’s position on this question that has come to my attention, see his sermon on John l:l-5, col. 480.

Cite this resource

Bouwsma, William J. “Calvinism as Theocentric Humanism.” Calvin Studies II, 1984. PDF. John Calvin Studies, Foundation for Reformed Theology. https://foundationrt.org/resource/calvinism-as-theocentric-humanism/.

More from John Calvin Studies

All 95 Calvin studies

Stay in touch.

Receive seminar announcements, new bibliographies, and quiet word from the Foundation a few times each year.

See the work you support.

Small groups of around six to eight pastors read in advance and gather for a week, with a significant portion of their room, board and travel reimbursed.