Foundation for Reformed Theology
Calvin and Zurich
https://foundationrt.org/resource/calvin-and-zurich/
Calvin and Zurich
George examines the 1549 Consensus Tigurinus between Calvin and Bullinger on the Lord’s Supper, tracing its negotiation, its sacramental compromise, and its lasting significance for the unity of the Reformed churches of Switzerland.
- Author
- Timothy George
- Published
- Source
- Calvin Studies IV
- Pages
- 25–40
Calvin and Zurich
PDF, 16 pages, 483 KB
Full text
Corrections are welcome. This text was produced automatically from a scanned copy (OCR) and may contain errors. For the authoritative version, please refer to the PDF.
by Timothy George In late May: 1549, John Calvin, grieving the recent 1oss of his beloved wife Idelette, was urged by his friend Guillaume The document which emerged from this meeting, s1lightly emended by subsequent negotiations, was pub1ished two years’1ater (1551) as The sia”et D. Ioannis Calvini Ministri Genevensis Ecclesiae.1 significance of this document”known since the nineteenth century torians ofthe sixteenth century.
In an era marked by church stands out as one of the notable ecumenical achievements of the Reformation. The Basle historian Ernst Staehelin referred to the isticreformations wereajoined in everlasting wedlock as the one At the same time. however, the Consen vin’s eucharistic theology over a 1ingering, attenuated Zwingli- anism, or, conversely, Calvin’s unfortunate compromise with a less than fully adeguate doctrine of the Lord’s Supper? It is no coincidence that divergent interpretations of the Consensus stood at the center of the heated exchange between Charles Hodge of standing of the Reformed doctrine of the Lord’s Supper.4 It is pretive questions, the resolution of which would require thorough and sympathetic analysis of Zwingli and Buliinger no less than Calvin,-as we’l as an investigation of the influence of the Consensus on subsequent Reformed confessions. My assigned standpoint of Calvin’s development and reforming strategy. We shall first review the course of events which led to Calvin’s decisive visit to Zurich in 1549, then we shal1 examine the twenty-six articles which comprise the Consensus itself,. and finally we shall 1ist several conclusions andimplications this study all of which deserve further research and discussion. The Road to Zurich the Lord’s Supper goes back to his earliest adherence to the re- form movement. as his implication in the affair of the placards indicates. By the first edition of the Institutes (1536), he had sizing the spiritual nourishment of the eucharistic event rather than the mode of Christ’s presence in the bread and the wine. 25
26 resulting therefrom, Calvin avers that if this aspect of the Sup- per had been stressed, “there would have been quite enough to satisfy us, and these frightful contentions wouid not have arisen which of old and even within our memory have miserably troubled ity” of those who added to the simplicity of Scripture: some who said the bread itself was the body (read Roman Catholics); others, that it was the bread (read Lutherans): others, that only a sign and figure of the body were set forth (read Zwinglians). Calvin’s effort to carve out a median position on the confirmed in the following year at the eucharist was further ( synod of Bern in 1537.
The Swiss, who felt that Martin Bucer had conceded too much to the Lutherans in the recently concluded Wittenberg Concord (1536) asked Calvin. along with Farel and Viret, to draw up a Confessio fidei de Eucharistia. This brief statement denies the local presence ofChrist in the Supper and stresses that the Holy Spirit is the bond of participation in Christ. At the same time it declares that the Spirit “really feeds us with the substance of the body and blood of the Lord to everlasting iife..?
The word substantia which Calvin had al- ready used’ in a similar way in the 1536 Institutes. wouid become repudiated his early usage of it. Bucer and wolfgang Capito were sufficiently pleased with this statement to sign their names to it. with the additional blast against the error of teaching “that it is naked and bare signs that Christ sets fortn in his blessed Supper.”8 Calvin’s sojourn in Strasbourg (1538-1541) placed him at the center of the unionistic initiatives and dialogues promoted by Bucer and his colleagues. In his Short Treatise on the Holy pubtished upon his return to Geneva in the following year, Calvin advance of the gospel. For ‘the first time in a public work he criticizes by name the great protagonists of the Marburg debate: Luther should have clarified his views on the loca’ presence and the adoration of the sacrament; Zwingli and Oecolampadius should not have been so obsessed with opposing false views of Christ’s of Christ which is given by the sacrament. Still, ‘Calvin as- serts, one should not wonder that these great leaders did not understand such a difficuit matter with perfect clarity since they had so recently escaped from the “slime of error and the Concluding on a conciliatory note, Calvin longs for a “published formula”‘to resolve the differences which continue to divide true believers on the Supper (formulaire pub- 1ie ou fust arrestée la concorde). In the meantime, he offers his own formula as a basis for further progress: “we al1 confess that, in receiving the sacrament in faith… we are
27 truly made partakers of the real substance of the body and blood of Jesus Christ.”s When Calvin returned to Geneva in 1541 he had reason to be optimistic about his efforts towards eucharistic unity. At the Colloquy of Regensburgs he and Philip Melanchthon had come to a variata. In hopes of achieving Protestant unity on the Supper, “the body and blood of Christ are truly present and distributed [vere adsint et distribuanturl to those who eat in the Supper of the Lord,to the following reading: “the body and blood of Christ are truly exhibited with the bread and wine [cum pane et vino. vere.exhibeantur] to those who eat in the Supper ofthe Lord, r!
Calvin always regarded this new version as a break- through. As late as 1557 he wrote: “I do not reject the Augsburg The reformers of Zurich, on the other hand, never felt as sanguine about this document Calvin, and this remained a bone of contention as between them after the publication of the Consensus even Tigurinus.
1545, Luther himself is said to have seen it and to have com- Calvin was gratified by Luther’s the strife over the Supper.
response. and seemed eager to overlook his infamous irascibility everywhere.” In a letter to Bullinger in 1544’Calvin said of Luther, “If he were to call me a dexii, I should still regard him Throughout the 1540s Calvin seems to have thought that an accord with the Lutherans was with- in grasp. In a letter written shortly after Luther’s death but before Calvin had learned of it, he referred to the favorable formula on the sacraments! I do not think that Luther wi” prove so stubborn that we cannot easily reach an agreement with him on this, matter.15 In retrospect, we may judge that Calvin was overly optimistic about Luther’s flexibility or, to put it an- other way, perhaps he was looking at Luther through Melanch- Calvin’s strenuous efforts to reach an agreement with Zurich and the other Swiss churches on the eucharist was never conceived by him as an end in itself, but rather as an essential first step toward a wider pan-Protestant accord.
However, it was not Bullinger and the church of Zurich. but Luther himself who provided a new obstacle to such an ecumen- ical union with the pub’ication in September, 1544 of his Brief
16 Confession Concerning the Holy Sacrament Ostensibly directed veals Luther at his polemical worst——— or best! For fifteen years the embers of enmity kindled at Marburg had smoldered quietly. but now they flared’ forth in full blaze: “I condemn and reject the enemies of the sacrament——— Karlstadt, Zwingli, Oecolampadius, Stenckfeld, and their disciples at Zurich and wherever they are.” the same cake.”
Moreover, since Zwingli’s followers continue to honor him after his disreputable death on the field of battle, “I have abandoned all my hope-for their improvement… nor do I Calvin, of course, regretted this coarse display and urged Melanchthon to moderate his great col——— Ieague. if possible. In this context, Calvin himself wrote to in the faith. Melanchton, however, withheld Calvin’s letter from isch Switzerland might lead to further outbursts. The Zurich response to Luther’s attack appeared in 1545 as the True Confession. (warhaffte Bekanntnis). Drafted by Bullinger. this treatise.offered”a”hearty defense of the “faithful and praiseworthy ‘Zwingli and Oecolampadius, and characterized Luther’s book as ‘”full of devils. unchristian expressions. slanderous words. quarrelsome wishes, impure speech, anger. deception, fury and foaming.”
More importantly for our purposes.
it described the chief aspect of the Lord’s Supper as “the remem- of our sins.” The necessity ‘of faith for this act of remembrance was emphasized, and the Zwinglian Stishwort. credere est edere. to believe is to eat, was reiterated.
Calvin did not think highly of this work, describing it in At the same time he was eager to pursue a mutual understanding on the Supper with Bullinger. Calvin had first met Bullinger during his the meeting of a “pubh.ic synod” to resolve differences on dis cipline and doctrine.
Calvin now renews these appeals for a face-to-face encounter. In 1544 he writes to Bullinger: “If we were able to discuss the matter some time for only half a day: we would, I hope, easily agree, and not only in regard to the matter itself but even in regard to its formulation. Meanwhile, this or being one in him.23 This attitude, reciprocated by Bullinger: was to prevail during the course of the exacting and substantial negotiations which preceded and prepared the way for the Consen sus Tigurinus.
Before we survey the document itself, it is important to
29 flicting ecclesiastical and political considerations. without going into detail we can mention three such factors which quickened Calvin’s desire for an agreement with Zurich. First was the sensitive and fragile relationship between Geneva and dictional disputes between the two territories, and the political In an effort to pacify the Bernese, Calvin prepared twenty articles on the sacraments for a synod at Bern in March. 1549, a meeting he himself had been forbidden to attend by the magis- trates of Bern. while Haller, the reformer of Bern to whom the synod for fear of provoking further hostilities, these articles part, incorporated into the text of the Consensus itseif. Beyond the bounds of the Swiss Confederation two other situations of international political significance factored in Calvin’s desire for an agreement with Zurich. First, he advo- cated alliance with France. whose king, Henry II, was seeking king and thereby ease the persecutions against Protestant be- 1ievers in his native country. Bullinger, in keeping with a pol- icy which went back to Zwingli, opposed any alliance with’ the French. Aiso. of grave concern to both Bullinger and Caivin was the resurgence of the Roman Catholic forces. marked by the con- Augsburg Interim on the Protestants within the Empire in 1548. In urging Bul1inger toward an agreement, Calvin wrote in 1547: “If [the emperor’ were to enter’strasbourg, he would, you per- ceive, occupy an encampment whence he could invade us… By keeping silence, do you not, as it were, present your throat to When in October. 1548, the imperial forces did in threat and how dire the need for a united Swiss Protestant re- sponse. The Consensus Tigurinus was thus a timely response to an international political crisis as well as an ecumenical achieve——— ment drawing together the French and German-speaking Protestants of the Swiss Reformed Church.
The Consensus Tigurinus As pub1ished in 155l, the Consensus Tigurinus consists of twenty-six articles. In this finalform it could more accurately be called the Consensus Helvetiorum, since the published version formed’ churches of Neuchatel, Bienne, Pays de Vaud, the Grisons: Basle, St. Gallen, Schaffhausen, Mulhausen and even, after some initial resistance, Bern. In this sense the Consensus was an important precedent and step toward the promuigation of the
30 Second Helvetic Confession of 1566. For the purposes of analysis following five sections: a christological introduction (l-6), the doctrine of the sacraments (7-9), the defense against sacramental materialism (10-15), the negessity of faith (i6-20), refutation 1. Christological introduction (1-6). Unlike the major- ity of articles which derived from the confession Calvin had sent to the ministers of Bern in March, 1549. these introductory art- May of that year. Calvin later claimed that the entire agreement was settled in less than two hours. If this was not a rhetorical exaggeration, we may assume that much of this brief summit meet- ing was spent formulating and refining thesefoundational articles.
The christological concentration of these early articles reflects a theological orientation shared by Calvin and the Zurich tradition alike. Article 1 declares that “the object of Christ, as it is by him alone we come to God, who is the final end of a happy 1ife.” This echoes the third of Zwingli’s 67 Articles of i523: “Therefore, Christ is the only way (der eynig On1y weg) to salvation of all who were, are nows or shali ‘be. in this context can one speak of the instituta. deis the ordi——— nances of God. Calvin, too, had sounded thisnoteas early as the 1536 Institutes where he described the purpose of sacraments It has been Article 2 of the Consensus lends support to this formulation with its depiction of sacraments as “appendages of the gospei”——— a phrase, again, used already by Calvin in the first edition of the Institutes where he characterized a sacrament as a seal or con- pendix (tanquam appendicem quandam adiungi).
Articles 3 and 4 present a succinct statement of the Per son and work of Christ which delicately balances the objective Son of God, of the same ‘essence and glory with the Father.” he is sacerdos, rex: expiatrix: frater, reparator, intercessor. liberator, moderator, and Deus.verus. we are given this knowt- edge of Christ (cognitio Christi), however, not to feed our curi- osity, but rather that we may grasp the soteriological purpose of the offices and mission of Christ, namely, “that he may raise us to himseif… and to the Father.”Thus Articie 3 sets forth three stages in the ordo salutis: justification. regeneration. and sanctification: “ingrafted by faith into the body of Christ.. by the agency of the Holy Spirit we are first counted
righteous by a free imputation of righteousness, and then re- generated to a new 1ifes by which we are reformed into the image of the Heavenly Father.”i Article 5, entitled “How Christ communicates himself to ” was one of two articles——— the other was Article 23, “on the eating of the flesh of Christ”——— which was added, at Calvin’s urg- ing, after the Zurich conference in May of 1549. It underscores the necessity, already stated in Articles l-4, of the union of believers with Christ: “Moreover, that Christ may thus exhibit himself to us and produce these effects in us: he must be made body.” This ‘is only one of two places in the Consensus where the loaded word, exhibere, is used. This was one of Calvin’s favor ite words to describe the force of the Supper for believers: the body and blood of Christ are shown to us, presented or tendered. set forth for us in the sacrament. Calvin uses various forms of this word no less than 17 times in book IV, chapter 17 of the 30 It was this very word which Melanchthon had substituted for adesse in the Augustana Variata——— to Calvin’s delight. Bullinger, how- ever, had strongly resisted Calvin’s use of this word’since it seemed to imply a too-direct correlation between the creaturely signs and that which they signified. In the end, he acquiesced to the word (and the article) so long as it was placed in the introductory christological section where it could be applied to the sacraments only by inference. The only other usage of ex- hibere in the Consensus is in Article 8. where the reference is to the benefits “exhibited” on the cross rather than to the eu- charistic exhibition which Calvin is so fond of commending (simulque pro beneficiis his olim in cruce exhibitis). Article 6 serves as a bridge from the early emphasis on union with Christ to the more specific focus on the sacraments in the subsequent articles. It is significant that the opening pre- nesses to spiritual communion effected by the Holy Spirit, an em- phasis which must have been pleasing to Builinger. However, the parallel placement of preaching and sacraments is as thoroughly re “a settled principle that the sacraments have the same office as the Word of God: to offer and set,forth Christ to us, and in him the 2. Doctrine of the sacraments (7-9). Turning now to our second division ofthe articles as we have outlined them, Arti- cles 7-9 present a general statement on the sacraments in which the sacraments are said to be “marks and badges of the Christian life and fellowsh’ip or brotherhood… contracts binding us to
32 a pious life.” Al1 of these images recal1 the strongly communal character of the eucharist in Zwingli’s thought. In particulars the last phrase in Article 7 which describes the sacraments as public seais which confirm and ratify -what God has announced would fit nicely one of Zwingli’s favorite metaphors for the near his former parish at Glarus, where Swiss soldiers clad in their white-crossed attire. gathered to commemorate a famous mil- itary victory of their forebearsand to declare, and renew as it were, their own Swiss identity.
In his posthumousiy published lier memorialist view when he allowed that the sacraments could augment faith and recall the Christian to a deeper obedience and contemplation. Article 7 incorporates this tendency as well when it portrays the sacraments as visual aids which bring the death of Christ and al his benefits to our remembrance “in order that At the same time some concession is made to Calvin’s instrumen- talism in that the sacraments are said to be the means “through which (per ea) God testifies. represents. and seals his grace to us.”
If Article 7 is tilted toward the concerns of Zurich. Article 8 reflects one of Calvin’s major themes. namely that in the sacraments God truly effects that which he represents. To be sure, this article represents a reworking of Calyin’s original language which: in the form submitted to Bern, had spoken of the sacraments as “true signs of the grace of,God which truly exhibit Again, this Tanguage was”not’ acceptable to the Zurich ministers; here it is claimed that the Lord “truly performs inwardly by his Spirit that which the sacraments figure’ to our eyes and other senses.” The re- sponse of gratitude, which the proper celebration of the Supper evokes: points to its central iiturgical significance for both individual piety and corporate worship. Article 9 restates the balance the entire Consensus ‘s seeking to strike: there is a crucial distinction between signs and things signified, but no divorce or disjunction; so that all who in faith embrace the promises offered in the sacraments “receive Christ spiritually” and experience communion with him.
3. Defense against sacramenta1 materia1ism (10-15). The third grouping of articles offers a hearty defense against sacra——— mental materialism. Article 1o points beyond the “bare signs# to elements” which, apart from Christ, are nothing but empty masks (inanes larvae), and returns to the earlier theme of salvation through Christ alone. Each of the next four articles carries (Calvin) and a refusal to invest any salvific efficacy in the sacramental signs (Bullinger). Articie 12 picks up the theme of
33 accommodation: the sacraments are helps, adapted to our weakness: God uses them as instruments——— in such a manner, however. that the whole power of acting remains with God alone.” ‘Despite the concession of a qualified instrumentalist view, the word itself is resisted. In Article 13 the Zurichers substitute the word organa for Calvin’s original instrumenta.
In Article 14, how- ever,it is Bullinger who accepts wording he had previously re- jected in his correspondence with Calvin. He here agrees to re- fer to the sacraments as “aids” (adminicula), though only when it Article 14 contains one of the strongest statements of sacramen——— makes us partakers of himseif.A similar line recurs in Articie 19: “in the Supper Christ communicates himself to us.” It should be admitted, however, that while the phrase in coena suggests in both of these contexts a clear instrumentalist view, it is ambig- uous enough to allow for a looser interpretation. It might, for this way, it could be accommodated to Bul’inger’s mature euchar- istic ‘theology as set forth in the Second Helvetic Confession ism,” There, in Article 21, Bullinger says that when the bread is outwardly offered by the minister, “at the same time inwardiy, by the working of Christ through the Holy Spirit, they receive also the fleshaand blood of the Lord, and do feed on them unto The emphasis of ‘the Consensus, however, falls neither on Bullinger’s parallelism nor on”Calvin’s instrumental- ism, but rather on the (we might say, nervous) rejection of a kind of sacramental imperialism which threatens the apriority and freedom of divine grace. Thus Article 15 asserts that “al1 these attributes of the sacraments sink down to a lower place, so that not even the smallest portion of our salvation is transferred to creatures or elements.”
4. The necessity of faith (16-20). This point is further clarified and”refined”in”the”next five articles (16-20). which The priority and freedom of divine grace are most clearly seen in the correlation of sacramental efficacy and the doctrine of pre- destination.
“God does not exert his power indiscriminately (promiscue) in all who receive the sacraments, but only in the elect (16). While the signs are administered to the reprobate and elect alike, the reality (veritas) of the signs reaches the latter only (17). Again. this is an emphasis on Calvin’s side which goes back to the Institutes of 1536. There he had written: “The Holy Spirit (whomthesacraments do not bring.indiscrim- inately to all persons but whom the Lord exclusively Lpeculiari- God’with him.”3 This is not to deny that the grace of God is truly offered to ail in common, the pious and the impious, the believers and
34 the unbelievers alike. Article l8 of the Consensus makes that point. and in so doing distances the Reformed doctrine of the Lord’s Supper from every kind of Donatistic subjectivism. There is a kind of ex opere operato character to the sacraments: they “always retain their reality, their force” (guin semper yim suam retineant sacramenta).,”Efficacy,” which is how the Beveridge edition renders the word vis, is not perhaps the best translation of that word in this context. Not all, however. are capable of receiving the gifts of Christ in the Supper. The point of dif- ference iies not in the moral quality of the administrant, nor in the presumed obstacle of mortal sin in the communicant. but rather——— and ultimately——— in the eternal decrees of God since (Ar- ticle l6) he enlightens unto faith none but those he has fore- ordained unto 1ife. (Parenthetically, Nevin. who applauded Calvin’s robust doctrine of the mystical presence of Christ in the Supper. was most uneasy about’1inking eucharistic communion with the doctrine of election, while his opponent Hodge, who was less sanguine about a full-orbed sacramental theology, championed the eternal decrees. To speak anachronistically, it seems to me that in this respect the Consensus tilts a bit toward Hodge.) Article 20 moves beyond the distinction between elect and reprobate, and speaks of the advantage (utilitas) of the sacra- ments which is not restricted to the occasion of their adminis- tration. Just as in baptism elect infants who receive the prom- ise of the sacrament in their eariiest days but may not necessar ily be regenerated unti1 much 1ater in life, so it may sometimes happen that the use of the Holy Supper which, from thoughtless- ness or slowness of heart does little good at the time after lated this aspect of Caivin’s sacramental theology to: 36wider motif in this thought, the so-called extra calvinisticum. Just as Christ, the eternal Son, has a reality etiam extra carnem. so also Christ. once and for all offered on the cross, now ascended to the right hand of the Father, is present to believers by his Spirit ubi visum est, wherever he wills, that is to say, etiam extra coenam. This points to a genuine——— and striking——— objectiy- ity of the Reformed doctrine of the Supper as set forth in the Consensus: the effectus sacramenti is not limited to the temporal enactment of the Supper, but is operative, in accordance with the sovereignty of the’Holy Spirit, ‘throughout the 1ife of the be- liever.That can hardly be calied “mere memorialism.” 5. Refutation of specific.errors (21-26). The concluding six articles ofthe Consensusrefute specific eucharistic errorss and are. for the most part, directed against distinctively Lutheran doctrines. Article 2l denies the idea of local presence and declares that Christ “must be sought nowhere else than in heaven.” Article 25 further clarifies this theme, consistently shared by Zwingli, Bullinger, and Calvin aver against Luther: the human body of Christ is wfinite and is contained in neaven as its
35 place.” Hence it is “necessarily as distant from us in point of stantiation and “other follies (alias ineptias) in Article 24. The “other follies refer to various construals of the doctrine of local presence which either place Christ “under the bread is a strong denial of a literal interpretation of the words of institution. They are rather to be nterpreted figuratively, by “metonymy.”
Article 23 was one of the two articles which were added at the suggestion of Calvin after the Zurich meeting in May, 1549. It is entitled, “On the Eating of the Flesh of reality itself, since it has been called a sign, and especially since there has-been no word in the entire document about eating was a concession to Calvin, although the manducatio carnis (gquae hic figurantur) as wel1 as by the explicit denial, of any commixtio ortransfusio of substance. ‘The final article (26) re- Luther and Zwingli, namely, the proper posture and reverence due to the consecrated elements. The Consensus strongly countermands any adorationist tendencies since any undue veneration of the creaturely elements would border on or lead to idolatry. Conclusion We have rehearsed some of the steps which led up to the Consensus, and have reviewed its contents. It now remains for us to draw several conclusions and implications from our study. 1. The Consensus was an unmitigated victory for neither Calvin nor BulTinger;it represents instead a genuine intra- Reformed ecumenical achievement. It is certainly not correct to see the Consensus. as Doumergue. Kolfhaus: and others do, as Calvin’s victory in the sixteenth-century Reformed debate over the Lord’s Supper.!
Bullinger’s persistence. and his ability to drive a hard bargain, ensured a fair representation of the major Zwinglian concerns. Even in places where the Consensus uses language which would not have pleased Zwingli, one must ask whether this represents a concession to Calvin or, more likely. a development within Bullinger’s own sacramental theology. Still. it was Calvin who pushed for an agreement. It was he who, time and again, took the initiative in the negotiations. It was he with Farel who traveled to Zurich (in the days before there was the wonderful Swiss railway); Bullinger never came to Geneva. In this sense, to the extent that there was a Consensus at all. it can rightly be called a victory for Calvin.
2. Most Calvin scholars are agreed that the Consensus does not represent a complete: or some would say, even adequate
expression of Calvin’s eucharistic theology. Wendel. echoing Niesei among others, has warned that “it is unsafe to take the Consensus Tigurinus.
basis for an objective study of Indeed, in a letter to Bucer in which he attempts to defend the Consensus against certain of his friend’s reservations about it, Calvin concedes: “you piously and prudently desire that the effect of the sacraments and what the more fully than many aliow. Indeed it was not my fault’ that that, which cannot’ be”corrected.u3 Calvin’s second thoughts about the Consensus were reserved, however. for his private cor- respondence with”intimate friends. Publicly, he was a zealous defender of it, claiming exuberantly at one point that neither that’ even Luther himself would have agreed to it. More im- portantly, in his treatises in defense of the Consensus, Calvin ism, repeatedly referring to the sacraments as “means of grace. and saying at one point that “the ministry of our reconciliation with God is..
. contained in them——— language which must have made Bullinger wince.
The Consensus, then, “did not say al’ about’the sacraments, only what he was not prepared to omit.14 3. Philip Schaff once referred to the Consensus as the #innocent occasion of the, second sacramental war. This de- scription reminds us that (as Otto Strasser put it some years ago the 400th anniversary of the Consensus) the Zurich Agreement was as ‘ much an Abgrenzung as it was an Einigung: it bound Caivin de- cisively with the other Swiss Protestants while at the same time it drove a greater wedge between the Reformed and Lutheran com- munions. It is clear that Calvin did not intend this latter re- sult, nor did he anticipate the virulence of the gnesio-Lutheran reaction. He was genuinely surprised when Jan Laski forwarded him a copy of Joachim Westphal’s Farrago of..Confused.and Di- vergent Opinions.on the. Lord’s.Supper Takenfrom the Book of the Sacramentarians(1552).This was afrontaTassau1t on the Con- das Kalbe, Buliinger as der Bulle and Laski as a Polish bear. Caivin responded with his Defense of the Wholesome and Orthodox Doctrine of the Sacraments”(1555)in which he counteredthe at- tack of Westphal, calling him a “hothead” and “son of the devil.” The last ten years of Calvin’s life were preoccupied with a con- tinuous and, one must say, not entirely edifying, pamphlet war with Westphal, and Tater, Heshussius. Calvin continued to hope that a moderating Lutheran eucharistic theology would prevail was bitterly disappointed when Melanchthon remained silent and aloof in the face of Westphal’s attacks. In 1557 when Calvin visited Strasbourg. then in Lutheran control, he was not even
permitted to preach in the city. Thus. in terms of what one historian has called “calvin’s almost pathetic craving for Reformed to secure among themselves, and in its contribution to what might well be called the developing confessional conscious- ness within the Reformed tradition.
Notes The Latin text of the Consensio Mutua is in CR 35,.733- 48, and in Calvin’s Opera Selecta, ed. p.Parth and G. Niesel (Munich: C. Kaiser, 1952),2:241-58. An Eng1ish translation is given in Calvin’s Tracts.. and..Treatises. ed. Henry Beveridge (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans,1958),2:212-20.
2ror recent scholarly appraisals of the Consensus, see 1 (1949): 1-16; Ulrich Gabler. Das Zustandekommen desConsensus Tigurinus im Jahre 1549,” Theologische Literaturzeitung 104s no. 5 (1979): 321-32, and “Consensus Tigurinus,” Theologische Realen- zyklopadie 8 (1981), 189-92. I have also benefited greatly.from the unpublished paper by Paul Rorem, “The Sixteenth Century Re- formed Doctrine of the Lord’s Supper: John Calvin and Heinrich ity School of the University of Chicago, is currently pursuing a Calvin’s Teaching on the Lord’s Supper.”
Quoted, Reinhold Seeburg, The History of Doctrines (Grand Rapids: Baker, 1977). 2: 417 n.2.
John Nevin, The Mystical Presence and Other writings on delphia:United Church Press, i966). Nevin was pronounced in his proper 1ife.of the Reformed’Church must be a1lowed to have been exceedingly external and accidenta1″ (Ibid.s 42). On the contro- versy between Nevin and Hodge, see Brian A. Gerrish, Tradition and the Modern World (Chicago: University of Chicago Press. 1977), 49-70.
Edition, ed. Ford Lewis Battles (Atlanta: JohnKnoxPress: 1g75): 141.
Perennis: Essays on Calvin and the Reformation in Honor of Ford 1981)27-47.
38 ipso particpationis agnoscimus, sed ita ut nos ille carnis et sanguinis Domini substantia vere ad immortalitatem pascat. et eorum participatione vivificet.” 8.
Ibid.: 436.
9calvin: Theological Treatises, ed. J. K. S. Reid (Phila- delphia: Westminster Press,1954), i64-66. The French text is given in 0s 1: 503-30. 10.
Melanchthons Werke 6: Bekenntnisse und kteine Lehrschrif- Cf. also Tylenda. Ecumenical Intention,* 35. On Melanchthon’s “defection” from Luther’s doctrine, see Hermann Sasse, This is My Body (Minneapo1is: Augsburg, 1959), 311-20. 11co 16:430.
12.
cf. Co 15:305. Cf. also W. Nijenhuis, “Calvin and the Augsburg Confession, Ecclesia Reformata: Studies on the Reforma- tion (Leiden: E. J. Br111,1972):97-114. 13co 10/B:432.
and M. Greengrass (New York: St. MartinsPress: 1983). 13l-32. This 1letter is dated March 17, 1546; Luther had died on February 28 of the same year. 16.
Kurze Bekenntnis vom nei1igen Sakrament, wA 54:14l: Eng. Trans.: LW 38:287-319. 17 lw 38:267-88, 291. 18.
39:698; 40:10.
(Zurich: Froschaur, 1545). I fo’Towthetranslation inRorem, “Reformed Doctrine,” 22. lus ieiunus est et purilis, quum in multis pertinaciter magis quam erudite,” Westminster, 1974): 17.
39 12:666.
24 CR 40:590. “Der Consensus,”g-14. An exceilent theological anaiysis of the Abendmakelsstreits im 16. Jahrhundert (Darmstadt: WissenSchaf- thiche Buchgese11schaft, 1962): 234-99. Cf. a’lso Hans Grass, Die Ver1ag, 1954): 193-241. Pipkins (A11ison Park, ‘pA: pickwick publications, 1984) I:17. 27 Institutes: 1536 Edition. 93. 28.
Brian A. Gerrish, “Gospel and Eucharist: John Calvin on go: University of Chicago Press, 1982), 107. tention,” 31-32. 32 4:218. 231. ohn Knox Press: 1982), 170-71:Gerrish, 01d Protestantism, 124. 36 Journa1 of Ecclesiastical History 21 (January 1970): 43-64.
37 Rorem, “Reformed Doctrine, 60-61. 38.
Francois Wendel, Calvin, 330. 39c licet.”
40 CR 37:11; 43:212.
40 more than I should. I have deliberately done this, so that if any. even now, should remain opposed to us then hateful is their obstinacy, and that the learned, who are in agreement with us and whom I see to be less courageous than is fitting, may have an ap- propriate excuse.”
CF 15:255-56.
42 Gerrish 0ld Protestantism, 124.
Cite this resource
George, Timothy. “Calvin and Zurich.” Calvin Studies IV, 1988. PDF. John Calvin Studies, Foundation for Reformed Theology. https://foundationrt.org/resource/calvin-and-zurich/.
More from John Calvin Studies
Stay in touch.
Receive seminar announcements, new bibliographies, and quiet word from the Foundation a few times each year.
See the work you support.
Small groups of around six to eight pastors read in advance and gather for a week, with a significant portion of their room, board and travel reimbursed.
