Calvin’s Central Doctrine

Partee returns to the long debate over a central dogma in Calvin’s theology, questioning the older consensus that the absolute sovereignty of God and double predestination form the heart of Calvin’s thought and weighing the textual evidence.

Published
Source
Calvin Studies III
Pages
39–46

Calvin’s Central Doctrine

PDF, 8 pages, 333 KB

Download PDF

Full text

Corrections are welcome. This text was produced automatically from a scanned copy (OCR) and may contain errors. For the authoritative version, please refer to the PDF.

CALVIN’S CENTRAL DOGMA AGAIN by Charles Partee For a long time there was general agreement that the doctrine of the absolute sovereignty of God and its loglcal corollary, double pre- destination, represented the essence (one might say, the hard core) of Calvin’s theology. The former was usually regarded as the basic prin- dogma.t References to Calvin focused on the Issue of the truth or error of his view of predestination, but the accuracy of this interpretation was seldom questioned. Indeed, the evaluation of Calvin as the theo——— logician of ttsalvation by predestination alonett is stil1 widely held in popular clrcles.

However, this consensus has come under increasing scholariy attack to devise a logical system, and by those who reject the concept of rational ity, developed and maintained in the era of Reformed Orthodoxy, revolutton and the resulting suspicion of ati metaphysical systems con- tributed to this reappraisal, as did renewed interest in the rhetorical tradition, but in any case Calvin is now being interpreted by scholars more as a btbitcal and less as a philosophical theologian. Thus many recent Caivtn studies ignore or reject the possibiiity of finding a icentral dogmat in Calvin’s thought.

This means that Calvin’s theology may be approached from various directions. For example, in recent major studies, Torrance expounded Calvints anthropology,* Parker and Dowey deait with the, knowledge of worked on Calvints sermons.

None of these studies claims to present Calvin’s ticentral dogmatt but oniy a centraly important doctrine which is taken to iilumine Caivn’s entire theology. It is probabiy true that no central theme——— as opposed to a tcentrally important themett——— is writing. Nevertheless, this admirable caution does not obviate the kind of trreducibie insight.

Not only does the abandonment of a “central dogmatt in the older and “strong’t sense leave Calvin’s theology unfocused for non-specialists, but no one can start everywhere at once. In short, it is difficult, if not impossible, to approach Calvin’s theology without a point of view, and some points of viewing are more adequate than others. That is to say, various “centrally Important themes’t may be considered and the one judged to be the most comprehensive can be justifiabiy called Calvin’s relative way. The value of the search for a central doctrine or theme initial presentation of and continuing reflection on Caivin’s theology until such time as the complexity of his thought. can be more fully appreciated.

be several master keys, but this essay holds up one which seems to open many doors. This suggestion is based on three convictions. First, that. Calvin did not produce a deductive “tsystem,’t therefore it is futile to seek a basic principle in the philosophica’ sense. Second, that the and, therefore, contains not only the traditional topics of theology but also Calvin’s essential and “‘systematic point of viewing. Third, in Calvin’s shaping of his materlal for exposition, a root metaphor or central theologicai theme may be discovered, in the sense that the reader can find a clarifying organization without being required to an organizing principle. As a matter of fact, the older quest for Caivin’s central dogma did not, in the main, contend that Calvin himself ex- pounded the doctrine of God’s sovereignty (and predestination) for this purpose, but only that it was correct for interpreters to do so. is scarcely to be questioned, although Staufferts magistertai”work on Calvin’s sermons demonstrates necessary and: important modifications of the view of Calvin the theologian in terms of Calvin the preacher. Moreover, if Calvin did not produce a theological system’t in the strictest meaning of system, nonetheless he was a t’systematic theolo- gianti ln the sense that he devoted sustained reflection to theological flection, while cruciai for interpretation, Is not specified in any evi- dent way, and several have been suggested.

The four books of the final edition of the Institutes are often divided aiong the ines of the Apostles’ Creed into the doctrines of God the Father (Book I), God the Son (Book Ii), God the Hoiy Spirit (Book IIi), and the Church (Book Iv). The major objection to this division is IlI, nor are all the topics treated therein directly related to the Holy Spirit as would seem necessary if Calvin were using a Trinitarian out- 1ine. Another way of organizing the Institutes is to take as program-:. con- However, since Calvin does not deal with’ the “knowledge of ourselvestt in a sep- arate section apart from the ttknowledge of Godt in 1559, It ls unlikely final edition of the Institutes.

stil1 another approach is from the II-Iv). This division serves very wel1 for expounding the knowiedge of God but is imprecise in dealing with the knowledge of ourseives which is intimately connected to but not entirely subsumed under the knowledge of tric,”t there are ttanthropocentrtc moments’t when the knowledge of God as Creator and Redeemer forms oniy the background of the discussion rather than its focus. Moreover, while Calvin s obviously concerned about “knowing,” he is not unconcerned about “being.”

41 Doubtless ‘Calvin’s purpose in writing the Institutes was, as he de- clares, to instruct candidates In sacred theology, and his desire to be faithful to the range and depth of the subject. There is no evidence that Caivin thought the search for a central dogma or common theme or organizing principle was an essential feature of that task. Calvin did not find a key and build a house to fit it. Calvin did not set out to expound theology from the point of view of any one doctrine. Neverthe- with Christ in so many places and in such a significant way that that tunion with Christtt may be usefully taken as the central affirmation. Karl Barth even ciaims Colossians 3:3 as the center of the gospel. Thus most, if not all, theologians have deait with this doctrine in some fashion.” The “essential elementst of Christian theology are God,”t God in Jesus Christ.

Thomas Aquinas, for example, divides the Surma Theologica into God’s movement toward mankind (st.I) and the movement of mankind toward God (sT.Ia. IIae). These two movements are not entire- with God, but Thomas treates them more sequentially than Calvir. More- over Caivin, of course, does not sharply divide God from Jesus Christ entities but on reiationships. dealt in some sense objectively with the knowledge of God the Creator and Redeemer, whlle the work of God the Father revealed in Jesus Christ the Son, subjectively considered, is the domain of the Holy spirit. Thus he writes:. as long as Christ remains outside of us, and we are separated from him, al1 that he has suffered and done for the for us. Therefore, to share with us what he has received from the Father, he had to become ours and to dwel1 within us. For this reason, he ls called our Headt [Eph. 4:l5] and the first-born among many brethrenlt [Rom. 8:293. We also, in turn, are said to be tengrafted into him” [Rom. 1l:17], and to put on Christ [Gal. 3:27l; for as I have said, alt ‘that he 43im apog euo oau! moub am l!aun sn oa buiyaou si sassassod 13 him.

Using this statement as a pivot, the Institutes can be divided into two roughly equal parts: A.

God for us I.

As Creator (Book I) a.

His creation b.

His providence II.

As Redeemer (Book II) The revelat ion a.

The natures and person 0.

The offices

42 God in us B.

As Individuals (Book III) a.

Faith 1.

Regenerat ion Justification b.

Electlon II, As a Comrmunity (Book IV) The ministry a.

The sacraments C.

The state It cannot be demonstrated, and should not be asserted, that Calvin consciously organized the four books in an objective (God for us) / sub- jective (God In us) fashion. In fact, the growth of the Institutes from 1536 to 1559 more than 1ikely precludes a sharply defined over-arching or underlying structure in Calvin’s own mind. when Calvin recast his material in 155g he did not pour it into a precast mold. The present claim is only that this division t’fitsu Calvin’s discussion in a more comprehensive way than other suggestions, and if it fits well enough, then it wiil commend itself as attractive without argumentation but only i1lustration.

creation of and providence for all things, but especialiy of and for human beings. Caivin is quite eloquent and even passionate in describ- ing the Creatorts care for his creature. In Book II, after discussing the creature’s sin (chapters l-5), Caivin expounds the objective knowl- edge of God the Redeemer, affirming the central mystery of the incarna- tion in Chalcedonian terms and avoiding Eutychianism more cteariy than Having, then, explicated theology proper in Book I and Nestoriani sm.

Christology In Book II, he turns not to anthropology but to soteriol- ogY, that is, to the explication of the redeemed sinner in terms of faithteregeneration, and justification, and concludes with eternal elec- 16 tion.

Following the exposition of ‘the redeemed sinner in Book III, Caivin treats the redeemed community in Book IV: its ministry, its sacraments, and its relation to the civil government. Such an overview suggests and probably requires a viewing point——— if not exactiy on the part of the writer, at least by the reader. That is to say, it is not unimportant to est imate where Caivin is standing when brated in the union of God and ma-in Jesus Christ which is extended to Thus the doctrine of union with those who are joined to Christ.

Christ seems adequate to serve as a basis for surveying the Institutes from a central perspective. Having created al1 mankind (Book I),’ God becomes a man, Jesus christ, for the saivation of mankind Book II). In Jesus Christ, by the power of the Holy Spirit, God enters the 1ives of individuals (Book’Iii) and’of a conmunity (Book IV). since it is not the intent of this essay to analyze the doctrine of Institutes, but onlyi&o suggest its central 1ocation, the following re- 18 marks must suffice.

Calvin insists that God became a man in Jesus

Christ——— the ttobjective momentl! or the central affirmation about God——— and that in Jesus Christ humankind is united to God——— the ttsubjective momentit or the centrat affirmation about humankind. Calvin believes that ‘tsince God Is incomprehensible, faith can never reach to Him, unless it has. Hence al1 thinking about God out- immediate regard to Christ…

thoughts.19 Thus ttwe see that our whole salvatton and all its parts are comprehended in Christ [Acts 4:l2]. we should therefare take care not to derive the As God is known in Christ, so is man. we are not to consider God or ourseives apart from Christ. itherefore, that joining together of Head and members, that indwelling of Christ in our hearts——— in short, that mystical union——— are accorded by him outside ourseives from afar in order that his righteousness may be imputed to us but because we put on Christ and are engrafted into his Again ttif we desire anything more than to be reckoned among God’s sons and heirs, we have to rise above Christ. If this is our ultimate goal, how insane Moreover, if we have been chosen in him, we shall not find assurance of our election in ourselves; and not even in God the Father, if we conceive him as severed from’his son. christ, then,.2$ ‘the mirror wherein. we must.

… contemplate our own elec- Further, in his commentary on I Corinthians Calvin writes, ” tion. ?

declare that it is only after we possess Christ himself that we share in the benefits of christ. And I further maintain that he is possessed not only when we believe that he was sacrificed for us, but when.he dweils in us, when he. is one with us, when we are members of his fiesh,. in short, when’we become, united in one life and substance, in a manner of speaking, with him.2!

citations like these indicate the far-reaching importance of ttunion with Christtt for Caivin’s theological understanding. This understanding say, Calvin’s explication in Book Iil makes it clear that we receive the benefits of Christ on something more than a fiducial basis. Moreover, tton.

anple of the cross but also the secret. union by which we grow together with Him, in such,way, that He revives us by His spirit, and transfers Further; we.should note that the spiritual union which we have with Christ is not a matter of the soul alone, but of the body also, so that we are flesh of his flesh, etc. (Eph. 5:30). The occaslon to use the term ‘tsubstancelt in a positive sense, his rejec- tion of Osianderts view precludes a stmple ontological identification between the bel iever.and the redeemer. Calvin clarifies his position by insisting that the union with Christ is effected not,by the infiowing of 30 Thus perhaps one substance but by the.grace and power of the Spirit. ical sense) but real (in a genuine but unspecified and unspecifiable sense).

++ without denying or minimizing the importance and excellence of var- ious other ways of approaching Calvin’s thought, this essay has at- tempted to suggest the breadth and depth of doctrine of union with Christit as the central mystery of Calvin’s theology, which means that this viewing point is present in Calvin’s thinking about every other doctrine and with the expectatlon that it is a useful and comprehensive way of tntroducing and suggesting a theological rather than a philosoph- ical basis for the description of Calvin’s thought. To the extent that this claim is considered, the expositor will be forced to deal more with Calvin’s faith than his logic. The union with christ ls vigorously as- serted by Caivin, but. tt is not completely explained; perhaps it cannot be completely explained because for him it js not only a central but an position of the Christian faith. If, and to the extent that, this is true, the explanation of Calvin’s theology would do well to focus on this doctrine and some such sketch as that proffered here may be bene- ficial both for the Initial and the final understanding of Caivin’s theology.

Notes Press, 1949).

Raplds: wm. B. Eerdmans, 195g). and Edward A. Dowey, Jr.. The_Knowledge of God in Calvin’s. Theology (2nd ed.; New York:. Columbia University Press, 1965).

Calvin werner Krusche, Das wirken des Heiligen Geistes nach (Gottingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1957).

. David willis, Caivin’s Catholic Christology (Leiden: E.. u. Bri11 1966).

dication de Calvin (Bern: Peter Lang, 1978).

‘Edward A. Dowey, Jr., “The Structure of Caivin’s Thought as Influ- enced by the Twofold Knowledge of Godi in Calyinus Ecclesiae Genevensis Custos, ed. by wi lhelm H. Neuser (Bern: Peter Lang,1984); reflects the wiilingness to identify a central doctrire writing, we do not mean here to introduce a central dogma or systematic premise, but to describe the strongest element in a field of forcett (n. 8, p. 137). Dowey does not explain how tthe strongest element in a fieid of forcett differs from a “central dogma.”t Moreover, statements 1ike knowledge, thus, is the Enot ‘ta] fundamental and central category of Calvin’s theological thoughtt (p. 138), It is this duplex cognito Domini… that 1les at the root of the dialectlcal structure of Calvin’s thoughttt (p. 142), tlItl structures the basic dialectic of his thinkingtt (p. 146) certainiy seem to be describing what is taken to be a “systematic premise.’t 7see Dowey’s helpful ref1ections, ibid., pp. 136-7.

45 Inst. I. 1. l. (os III, 3l, 6-9). The Institutes (Inst.) in the Library of Christlan classics edition, edited by John t. McNeiil and translated by Ford Lewis Battles is’cited by book, chapter, and para- graph. The second part of the, reference is to the volume, page, and 1ines of the Opera Selection (os) edited by P. Barth and w. Niesel. Torrance (Edinburgh: T. & T. ciark, 1957), II, 1, 149. See also IV, 3, 2, pp. 539ff. where Barth deais with the union with Christ. According to Barth, this doctrne thas a comprehensive and basic significance for Caivin. Indeed, we might almost call it. his conception of the essence of Christianitytt (p. 55i). However, Barth, disagreeing with Niesel, sees jn Book II oniy ttoccasional references to union with Christ but not Barth is certainiy correct in hoiding that Caivin did not rewrite the Institutes in the iight of this doctrine. The present claim is that the icomprehensive and basic significancett of the doctrine of union with Christ tilumines the exposition of the Institutes in such an essential 11.

logical attention it deserves, especially in a century so vitally con- cerned and invoived with the dimensions of space on the one hand and the resources of earth (including animals) on the other. But see George s. Hendry, The Theology of Nature (philadelphia: westminster, 1g8o). (chicago: wi 11 iam Benton, 1952).

14.

Karl Barth, Church Dogmatics, I, 2, 24, sees a certain Iine from Paul and John through Docetism through Alexandrian Christology through Eutychianism to Luther. He also sees a line from the synoptics through Ebionism through Antiochean Christology through Nestoriani sm to Calvin. These two theses, Barth argues, are mutually related. the Hoiy spirlt is the bond by which the Father and on are united and the bond by which Christ unites us to himself.

theology, then it is understandable that predestination, which presents one aspect of this baslc doctrine so powerfuliy, couid be seen by syne- doche as the central doctrine of Reformed Christianity. the only way to know it is when He pours His iife tnto us by the secret efficacy of the spiritt Com. Un. 14:20 (co 47, 331). Calvin returns to the Importance of the unity between Father and Son and between Christ

46:and the believer in 17:21 (co 47, 387). In 16:27 (co 47,.371) Caivin says, The oniy bond of our union with God is union with christ.” The latest available English transiation of Calvin’s commentaries are cited by book, chapter, and verse and include reference to the volume and page of the Calvini Opera (co).: 18.

In Com. I Cor. 1:9 (co 49, 313) Calvin speaks of the assurance that can be derived from membership in the body of Christ. 19 W. Kolfhaus, Christusgemeinschaft bei Johannes Calvin (Buchhand——— 1ung des Erztehungsvereins Neukirchen’Kr. Moers, 1939) expounds Calvin’s view of union with cnrist at. length but does not regard it as central (p. 12). wiihelm Niesel, Reformed_symbolics, trans. by David Lewis (edinburgh: o1iver & Boyd, 1962), p. 18iff. suggests that It is. Neither scholar seeks to describe’ the possibility of its central loca- tion in the Institutes. See the brief interpretation in Charles Partee, Calvin and ciassical Philosophy Cleiden: E. J. Bri1l, 1977), p. 87ff. 22 Inst. II. 16. 19 (os III, 507:1,2-508:1).

23 III. 11. 10 (Os IV,191, 27-34).

Inst.

24 Inst.

III. 24. 5 (os. IV, 416, 21-4).

III. 24. 5 (0s IV, 415:39-416.4); emphasis added. Inst.

22-25).

27cf. Com. Rom. 6:4-5 (co.49, 106).

30c See Helmut Gollwitzer, Coena Domini. (Munich: Chr. Kaiser, 1937), p. 117ff, Also David willis, calvin’s Use of Substantia,tt: in Calvinus Ecclesiae.. Genevensis Custos, pp. 289-301. wi1helm Niesel, Calvin’s Lehre vom Abendmahl (Munich: Chr. Kaiser, 1930), pp. 50-1 points out that Calvin in the nsecond Defense Against Westphaj (co 9, 7of), re- jects and uses the concept’of substance side by side. ‘Calvin’s Tracts, ed. and translated by Henry Beveridge II (Grand Rapids: Baker,: 1983), 277, commenting on Eph. 5:30 (co 8, 382; 51, 768-70), Calvin insists that this sacred union (ceste union sacree) ls a miracle of the Holy Spirit and is not mereiy tispirituajit but lncludes our being fiesh of his flesh and bone of his bone. Doubtless this view helps to explain the importance which Calvin gives to the local presencett or the risen and integral humanity of Christ.

Cite this resource

Partee, Charles. “Calvin’s Central Doctrine.” Calvin Studies III, 1986. PDF. John Calvin Studies, Foundation for Reformed Theology. https://foundationrt.org/resource/calvins-central-doctrine/.

More from John Calvin Studies

All 95 Calvin studies

Stay in touch.

Receive seminar announcements, new bibliographies, and quiet word from the Foundation a few times each year.

See the work you support.

Small groups of around six to eight pastors read in advance and gather for a week, with a significant portion of their room, board and travel reimbursed.