Foundation for Reformed Theology
Calvin’s Treatise Against the Anabaptists
https://foundationrt.org/resource/calvins-treatise-against-the-anabaptists/
Calvin’s Treatise Against the Anabaptists
Swezey examines the contemporary significance of Calvin’s 1544 Brief Instruction Against the Anabaptists, considering how Calvin identified his opponents and what his polemic still offers the church facing perennial questions of baptism and order.
- Author
- Charles M. Swezey
- Published
- Source
- Calvin Studies I
- Pages
- 1–15
Calvin’s Treatise Against the Anabaptists
PDF, 15 pages, 1.0 MB
Full text
Corrections are welcome. This text was reproduced automatically from the original document. For the authoritative version, please refer to the PDF.
The Significance of Calvinrs Tract for the Church Today Agalnst the Anabaptists by Charles M. Swezey
Introduction
when Professor Leith invited me to give a paper on calvints BRrEF INSTRUCTION FOR ARMING ALI, THE GOOD FAITHFUL AGAINST THE ERRORS OF THE COMMON SECT OI’ THE ANABAPTISTS (154t+), he kindly del ivered me frorn being responsible for the type of historical knowledge that experts on Calvin are expected to have. He asked me to speak about the significance of the tract for today’ not to place it in historical context. Despite ny amateur capabilities as a sixteenth century scholar, let me begin by mentioning some of the problems contemporary readers have in discerning who calvin is speaking against. r am aided in this task not o41y by Professor Farleyrs clear translation and helpfu] introduction,l but also by the able and energetic book by Inlillern Balke.’
First, in the opening and largest section of this three-part treatise, calvin responds point by point to the BROTHERLY uNroN 0F A NIIMBER OF CHILDREN OF GOD CONCERNING SEVEN ARTICLES (L527)r orr as it is more popularly knornm, THE SCHLETTHETM CONFESSToN. This rexr was probably written by Michael Sattler, a mernber of the Swiss Brethren, and has recent”ly been trans1ated with schol.arly notes by John Howard Yoder.r The prohlem i,s that Calvin did not have an ori.ginal text, but a French translation which was not who11y a-ccurate. Ttre inaccuracies are a cause of disputes. For example, the second article refers to those who t’slip and fa1l into error and sin, being inadvertently overtaken.r’ calvin junps on the word “inadvertently’t and argues that Anabaptists believe they sin only through ignorance and inattention, but not willingly. Yoder observes that calvinrs reading rnay have grounds in the French translation, but it is a misunderstanding to say that Anabaptists distinguish between forgivable and unforgivable sins and that only inadvertent sins are within the reconciling concern of the congregatlon. That is an exarnple of one problem, namely, the accuracy of calvints view of the Anabaptists in light of the French translation.
A seconrl problen concerns the style of Calvinfs writing. Since the appearance of Francis M. Hi.gmants book about Calvints French polemical treatises’ interpreters of Calvin have been keenly aware that Calvin
lro* cAlvrlrrs TRACTS AcATNST THE ANABAPTISTS AND AGAINST THE Ll-liliRTTl;lis. Translatign, Introduction, and Notes by Benjanin Wirt Farley (in press, Baker Book House). 2Wi11″‘ BalKe, CALVIN AND THE ANABAPTIST RADICALS, trans. Trrillianr J. Heynen (Grand Rapids: William B. Eer<lmans Publishing Company, 1981), 338 pp.
3Joho H. Yoder, ed. and trans., THE LEGACY OF MICHAEL SATTLER (Scottdale: Herald Press, 1973), pp. 34-43.
uses certain “persuasive techniquestt to convince his readers of the truth of his views. For example, Calvin artl-culates his or^m positJ.on by using a pious and btblical vocabulary, but the views of his opponents are portrayed by use of colloquial and sometime vulgar language. In Hignanfs wordsr. his adversaries rrare not described, they are charicatured.tt- They are stupid, confused, inmoral, and blasphemous. Their teaching is like the vomit of a drunkard! Animals, if they could speak, would speak more wisely. Their departure from Calvints views turns them into a people with fantasies or instruments of the devil. Thus again, in view of Calvinfs style, there is a historical problem in aseertaining what Anabaptists actually thought and taught.
A third problem is that Cal-vin attributes theological beLiefs to Anabaptists which alL Anabaptists did not hold. In the second and shortest section of the tract, Calvin refutes those who deny the true hunanity of Jesus. Professor Farley points out that the ttcelestlal fl-esh” theory of Melchoir Hofmann ls probably in nind (the writings of Menno Sirnons only eame to Calvinrs attention in 1545). Although Hofmann did teach a docetic theory, and though Menno Simons is not wholly orthodox in hls Christology, it is not clear that all Anabaptists in the sixteenth century denied the humanity of Jesus. Calvin, however, deelares the silence of The Seven Articles on this matter to be a ruse. Again, the third and final section of Calvinrs tract, a reworking of a previous essay, refutes the doctrine of the sleep of souls, namely, the teaching that souls are separated at death fron their bodies and sleep until the day of judgment without consclousness. However, modern historians attribute this view to Spiritualists, not Anabaptists.
In sum, it is clear that Calvinfs polemic does not provide an historically accurate portrait of ttthe conmon sect of the Anabaptists.rt Franklin Littell claims [hat no major flgure I’understood less” about the Anabaptists than Calvi.n,- a view which probably has sone merit. In any event, twentLeth century readers have a problen in discerning who Calvin is speaking against and whether these persons and their doctrines are i.n fact Anabaptist. In the face of these formidable historical problems, Willen Balke adopts an admirably devious strategy.
We will handle the concept rrAnabaptism” the way Calvin hiurself did. Although there is sorne real question as to whether Calvin himself distinguished clearly between the various radical currents of the Reformatlon and whether he treated the Anabaptists properly, we plan to liurit ouH treatment to the image of the Anabaptists that Calvin hiurself had.-
4Frarr”l” M. Higrnan, THE STYLE OF JOHN CALVIN IN HIS FRENCH POLEMICAL TREATISES (London: Oxford University Press, 1967), 191 pp. The quotation is frorn p. 131. The styl-e of Calvin’s rhetoric should be viewed in historical context; see Higrnan, pp. 170-176. 5Franklin H. Littell, THE ORIGINS OF SECTARIAN PROTESTANTISM (New York: The Macmill-an Company, 1964), p. L47. 6B”1k”, CALVIN AND THE AI{ABAPTIST RADICALS, pp. 10-11.
This sounds like a strategy of capitulation. However, if onets purpose is to get at the intentions of Calvin and to assess the significance of his rnajor affirmations ——— while foregoing the requirements r:f scholarly accuracy about the sixteenth century context ——— Balkers strategy i-s not as bad as it sounds. rndeed, r shall adopt something very much like i.t myself.
My task is to talk about the relevance of this text for today. Because I know no contemporary Anabaptist writer who denies the humanity of Jesus or argues for the sleep of souIs, I have chosen to focus on the first sectlon of the treatise ——— the largest section which is a response to Sattlerrs Seven Articles. I shal1 then attempt to state the significance of calvinfs affirmations by bringing them to bear on the r4rritings of a tr^rentieth century Mennonite, John lioward Yoder, who certainly cannot b9 characterized in the derogat.ory terms of the sixteenth century.’
Part I
I hesitate to surrnarize Calvinrs point by point consideration of The Seven Articles, which can be read, and all the more because no sutnmary can capture the nuance of the original. Yet I also know that Professor Farleyrs translation is not yet available, and that many of you have not read the tr6ct. Further, ilY sunmary git’es a hasis for the moves I will rnake later.
First, on INFANT BAPTISM, Calvin agrees that instruetion about God precedes baptisrn for adrrlts who are not rnembers of the household of faith (pagans). Rea.son and Scripture agree that a profession of fajth and repentance precede baptf.sm i-n this instance.
However, this practice is not an argument against jnfant baptism which is grounded in the covenant ” the promise of salvation whi-ch God gives to believers and their children. Reason and Scriptut:e agree that circumcism in the O1d Testament is analogous to baptisrn in the New Testament. Infant baptism in the church is a sacramental sign of the covenant of nercy made in Jesus Christ with all of us as children of God. Pastorally, infant baptisn is a visible sign ruhich assureFi believers that God accepts their children into the fellowship of the church. If the New Testament does not explicitly state that infarrts are baptized, neither does it explicitly state that women are to receive ttre Lord I s Supper.
7’For a positive appraisal of Yoder, see Stanley Hauerwas, ItThe Nonresistant Church: The Theological Ethics of John Howard Yoder, VISION AND VIRTUE: ESSAYS IN CHRISTIAN ETHICAL REFLECTION (Nocre Dame: Fides Publishers, Inc., L974) r pp. 197-22I. 8My “r.ro*.ry draws upon the wording of Professor Farley’s translation.
Second’ on THE BAN, Calvin agrees that it is a necessary means for ordering the church. The church is disflgured if this forn of church discipline is not practiced, but the existence of the church does not depend on the proper institution of the ban. The use of the ban by the Anabaptists ——— those who inadvertently fall into error are warned thrice ln private, and on the third occasion are publicly banished ——— iurplies that it is possible to have a perfect church.
However, it is not possible to have a perfect Christian comnunity. The church is inevitably tainted. The New Testament comnunity at Corinth is an example of this inevitable imperfecti,on, with its diverse parties’ corrupt morals, and doctrinal errors. The inperfections of the church include not only those hypocrites and contemptuous persons who lead seandalous livesr but also the irnpurities of the faithfuL. Still, though our sinful nature inclines us to be suspicious of others, it is very difficult to make human judgments on these matters with certainty. we must reaLize that the church contains both the good and the bad, the grain and the weeds. Therefore, though discipline belongs to the substance of the church, we should define the existence of the church by the preaching of the word and the administration of the sacraments.
This deftnition means it is lawful to receive the Lordts supper even in a church not properly regulated by the ban. The sacrament is for people who need to be rescrred frour irnperfection! Paults statement that we should not partake unworthily (r cor. 11:28) means we should examine ourselves. rt does not mean that as private individuals we should exarnine others, for the office of the ban must be exercised with the consent of the people. Again, Paulfs statement that we are not to conmune with those who lead scandalous lives (I Cor. 5:11) means that it is in our power as individuals not to associate privatel-y with the wicked. To receive the Lordrs supper, however, is not a matter to be based on our individual, private decisions.
Thus again it is clear that the Anabaptists are perfectionistic in their use of the ban. They believe that whoever sins inadvertently (out of ignorance, without intention) is to be rejected. This naive view of sin benumbs the Anabaptists into thinking that persons sin only out of ignorance. rn fact, Anabaptists teach that it !.s unforgivable to sin willlngly (a sin against the Holy spirit). This would cast us i.nto despair, for most everyone must confess, not only that s/he has sinned, but that s/he has sinned willingly. rn sum, the Anabaptists are like the Donatists and the cathari; they think it possible to have a church without sin. The comfort of the Christian, however, is that God has the sole authorlty to forglve sin, and God has promised to forgive both willing sins and sins of ignorance (Lev. 4-5).
Third, on the BREAKING 0F BREAD, Calvin agrees that no one dares come to cornmunlon who is not truly of the body of Christ, worshipping one God along with all believers, and serving God in a good and lawful vocation.
Fourth, on SEPAMTING FROM THE WORLD and its wickedness and evil, Sattler includes not only the renunciation of ttpopishtr works and idolatry, but also the use of weapons of violenee (the sword) against enemies or to protect friends. Calvin agrees that trpopish[ superstitions should be renounced, and he agrees that individual christians should not use the sword to resist evil. rndividual Christians should suffer patiently rather than use force or violence.
But it is blasphemous to condemn the public use of the sword. Calvin here spins out a large portion of what operates in his writings as a just-war theory. His theory, incidentally, is almost identical to what is found in the writings of st. Augustine. The uragistrate is a minlster of God for our benefit and on our behalf (Rom. 13:4) for the purpose of restraining and preventing the violence of the wicked (cf., “crimett). The sword is placed in the hand of the magistrate, not just to protect the public good by punishing domestic evil, but also (and by analogy) to repulse those who unjustly assail a country. of course, the prince must pursue every means of peace, and may resort to the sword only when necessary (last resort). The Christian believer, when called to serve the prince in this context, does not offend God by taking up arms, but fulfills a holy vocation. The use of weapons is permissible, as necessary for the defense of a country, €.g., munitions, fortresses, and shoulder-arms.
Fifth, on SHEPHERDS rN THE CHURCH (the office of pastor), calvin says little. He carefully states agreement with what he calls their present position, namely, that every congregation ought to have an ordained minister. Calvin also writes that the Anabaptists should agree with hin that the laity should adhere to du1-y constituted ministers who faithfully exercise their office, and that Anabaptists should not be offended to hear a Reformed sermon.
Sixth, on the MAGISTMTE (he has already dealr wirh rhe sword), Calvin agrees that temporal power is an ordinance of God. He disagrees with the Anabaptists when they imply that this ordinance (the office of justice) stands outside the perfection of Christ and is an illicit or forbidden Christian cal1ing. Calvin argues that it is illogical for the Anabaptists to have it both ways.
The crucial argument here is that the moral- law of fihe Old Testament (elsewhere identified in Calvin aii-aturaT lawt) provides a
9Th” “.”onciary account of natural law in Calvin which I find urost persuasive is David Little, RELIGION, ORDER, AND LAW: A STUDY IN PRE-REVOLUTTONARY ENGLAND (New York: Harper & Row publishers, Harper Torchbooks, 1969), pp. 33-56. See also, David Little, ‘fCal_vi.n and the Prospects for a Christian Theory of Natural Law,” NORM AND CONTEXT IN cHRrsTrAN ETHrcS, ed. Gene H. Outka and Paul Ramsey (New Yi rk: charles Scribnerrs Sons, 1968), pp. I75-I97. Cf., John T. McNeill, I’Natural Law in the Teaching of the Reformers,rr JOURNAI OF RELIGION, vol. 26, no. 3 (July L946) r pp. 168-182; and Arthur C. Cochrane, “Natural Law in Calvin,” CHURCH-STATE RELATT0NS rN ECIIMENTCAL PERSpECTTVE, ed. Elwyn A. Snith (Pittsburgh: Duquesne University Press, 1966), pp. 176-217.
guideline or rule of life both for Jews of old and for christians. christ does not add to this law, but restores its true rneaning. of course, the proper office of Jesus is the forgiveness of sins. Jesus rejects the temptation to become a pol-itical king, not because it is an evil calling, but because it is not his calling. Again, Jesus refuses to divlde, Property between brothers, not because it is unlawful to make judgments about property, but because it is not his calling. Thus Calvin rejects any understanding of the life and teachings of Jesus as a “higher’r law which is incompatible with the ways of the world.
The office of the magistrate ——— wielding the sword, administrating civil disputes about propertyr etc. ——— ls a high and proper Christian vocation. Like the calllngs of the cobbler and the tailor, it serves the common good. Calvin willingly asks the question of consequences here. What would happen if there rrere no magistrate ordained by God to administer justice in the civil- order and maintain the cornmonwealth of property? What would happen if the civil order were maintained only by ttprivatett admonishments? What would happen would be disorder, whol-esale robbery, and the ushering in of brigandage. tr{ithout civil government, the world would be ruined.
seventh, and finally, on THE 0ATH, calvin agrees it would be better not to swear than to take swearing too lightly. But just as rre do not totally condemn the use of wine because of drunkards, we should not try to correct the abuse of oaths by altogether prohibiting them. That would miss their proper meaning and their proper use.
The proper meaning is associated with the comandment not to take the name of God E Ertt (U*. 2O:7), a commandment which inplies a l-egitlnate hray to-tlE-eod’s nane. This is (sonehow) courpatible with the statement of Jesus, ttDo not srdear at all” (Matt. 5:34), for again, Jesus does not add to the law a higher way. The teaching of the law in the Old Testament is a rule for right living, both then and now.
Scripture and sound reason agree that one may lawfully swear when it is a matter of rendering testimony to the truth, when it is expedient or profitable for preserving charity among ourselves, and when ttnecessityrt requires it. This is lawful, provided that the intention (ae.!$.r.ti* – motive, reason) and ain Ggl_lg – purpose) are proper, and proceed from a proper ttfear” (motive, reason) for sanctifying the name of God. under these conditions, swearing is not an idolatrous reliance on hunan strength, but a proper invoeation of Godrs ald.
0n a first reading’ many of the matters discussed in this tract seem l-argely irrelevant to the concerns of our day. what was worth dying for in the sixteenth century appears to be of greatly reduced significance today. Indeedr p€rsons in Reformed circles seem noril to have switched sides on several of the issues. For exanple, apart fron an occasional exhortation, no one in the Reformed circle of the Presbyterian Church, U.S., tal-ks about the ban or church discipline in the urode of Calvln. Indeed, the revisions for church order before the Presbyterian Church, U.S., include no provision for excomnunication at
all’ and the matter was not even debated on the floor of the General Assenbly. The matter of infant baptism is not judged to be a erucial issue today. Indeed’ some of those who call themselves Reformed, both in America and abroad, argue for believerrs baptisn. on the matter of rrar, the enphasis on ttpeacemakingtt has apparentLy placed just-war theory on the back-burner. on the matter of the magistrate, we are all probably disenchanted with the politieal process, on the one side; and we see contemporary Anabaptists avowing the need to participate in the Itprlncipalities and powerst’ on the other side. In r-spect to courts of law, I suspect that each of us has at least some suspl-cions about their effi-clency, if not their fairness; on the other hand, we live at a time when some Anabaptists are going to court as a form of protest on selected moral issues. on the matter of oaths, r have not heard a serious discussion of swearing since I r,ras a sophomore at Washington and Lee.
So at first gl-ance, it looks as if many of the issues dealt with in this tract have been passed by. My suspicion is that the i.ssues between Anabaptists and Reformers today stand behind the explicit issues discussed in this tract. so r want briefly to characterize some of these lssues r and on that basis r will enter into dialogue with the views of John Howard Yoder.
Part II
one disputed topic among students of calvin is the relation of reason and revelation. I tend to agree with those who enphasize the Augustlnian elements in his writings. To avoid credulity (as well as theological stupidity and rnoral error), faith seeks to understand itself, and faith uses reason to construe the world j.n a theological framework. Faith and knowledge of God, discerned on a confesslonaL base, appropriately uses reason to inEerpret the world. Further, clains for the intelligibility of this interpretation can be addressed to those who do not share this eonfessi.onal base. rndeed, pagans can be held accountable for sone of the discernments of falth.
A najor issue in Christlan ethics concerns the approprlate sources of knowl-edge to use in moraL argument. In the tract before us, I am struck by the variety of sources to which Calvin appeals. He refers to the christian tradition, to sound reason, to moral or natural law, to humane learning, to comron sense, and to the calculatlon of consequences. These appeals appear amid repeated reminders that Scripture is the authority for theology and ethics.
On occasion Calvln sounds like he adheres to a literal princlple of sola Scriptura. For hirn, the Anabaptists are not as bad as the Libertines because they at l-east accept Seripture, and Calvin indicates he is more than wllIing to work on the basis of what scripture really teaches. However, what scripture teaches is not always clear, for even the devil (and the Anabaptists) quote the Bible. CaLvin endearrors to arrive at the true significance of biblical texts and to harnonize the whole by using certain principles of interpretation, e.g., the relation of the O1d to the New Testament is understood in a particular way, Jesus
does not annul,but declares the true meaning of the moral law which is a guide for conduct’ etc. This |thermeneuticrt Just does not function like a literal application of a sola scriptura princlple. Reason, humane learning, and all the resr,-;; appe;Ga-to without embarrassment.
The lssue of the relation of reason and revelation stands ttbehindtt the text before us. It is not directly addressed. Calvinrs strategy is to appeal to the Anabaptists on the basis of their high regard for the authority of Scripture. He argues that their interpretation is not correct, that their doctrinal positions are not tenable exegetically. Even Balkefs lengthy book does not confront the reason-revelation issue directly, but is content to observe that Calvin challenges theLr interpretation of Scripture.
This is ironical because, at least retrospectively, one of the classic disagreements between Anabaptists and t’mainline’f Christians in the sixteenth century is about natural law. Roman Catholics continue to articulate a theory of natural law. Natural law also appears in somewhat different guises ln both Luther and Calvin, and later in Anglican theology. For Anabaptists, however, the naturaL moral law traditlon is left behind. The one source of authority is Christ. In the words of Sattler, ttChrist teaches and commands us to learn from him, for he i6 ureek and lowly of heart and thus we shall fj.nd rest for our souls.tt^” The person of Christ and his teachings becomes a ttnew lawtt for Christians. In contrast to Calvin who stresses the continuities between the natural moral law, the Decalogue, and the moral teachlngs of Jesus, the Anabaptists stress the discontinuity between the trnew lawtt and the rfold law.rt
The role of natural moral law as a legitimate source of knowledge for chrlstian ethics is a problen addressed directly by John Howard Yoder. In the name of |tbiblical realismrtt Yoder argues that conformity to the teachings and life of Jesus nake ethlcs Christian. Christian discipleship is following the way of Jesus to the cross; those who derive moral knowledge from non-Christian or natural sources do not follow this way. For exampl-e, categories like rrthe fittingrr or “responsibil-ityrr (H. Richard Niebuhr) or I’the realistic’r (Reinhold Niebuhr) do not provi-de Christian guidance, but give counsel based on tteor.on sense and the nature of thingsff which is rooted in ttan epistemol?Ey for which the classic label is the theology of the natural.”” Calvinrs probl-em, Yoder observes inEEE6nEft, is TE!ffieason or nature cannot be the source ofra different set of standards from those revealed in Godrs word.tt” ——— that is, Christian ethics loses its radical distinctiveness.
l0Yod.t, ed., THE LEGACY OF MICHAEL SATTLERT pp. 39-40. llJohn Howard Yoder, THE POLITICS OF JESUS (Grand Rapids: Wllliam B. Eerdmans Publishing Conpany, 1972), p. 20. l2Johr, Howard Yoder, THE CHRISTIAN WITNESS TO THE STATE (Newron, Kansas: Faith and Life Press, 1962), p. 65. There is merit to this observation.
Yoder is unwavering in his polernic against natural rnoral knowledge. For exarnple, the Haustafeln or tthousehold precepts’r of the New Testament ——— “wives be subSFElTr husbands” and the iike; col. 3:lg-4:l; Eph. 5:2I-6:9 ——— are not teachings which the early church took over from the Hellenistic world’ as many scholars would have it. Instead, they ernbody a distinctively Christian ethics of ‘rrevolutionery subordinationn which derives,its shap, its meaning, and its language t'{rorn the novelty of the teaching and the work and the triurnph of Jesus.tt” From yoder’s point of view, use of the sogial sciences as a positive aid to ethical reflection is suspect.’-
Yoderrs writings presuppose two prirnary audiences. One audience is mainline Christendom which he calls to radical discipleship. The other audience is his fellow Mennonites who misconceive the Christian life as withdrawal from the worl-d. Withdrawal is r{rong because the cross of Christ is understood best as a genuine political alternative to the ttEssene optionrt of withdrawaL. The cross i-s also understood as a political alternative to the option of the Sadducees who sought to be effective by cooperating with the governing authorities, and the option of the zgqlots who resorted to violence i-n an attempt to control history.’- (rncidentally, these options, including the cross, are ways to rfread the situation’r which do not depend on the social sciences.) So Yoder calls both audiences to an agg5essive but non-violent engagement with the princtpallties and powers.———
Decisive for this non-violent but aggressive eBgagement with the world is ttthe pacif ism of the messianic community. t’t’ This ‘rnegative intervention”isbestdefi”eaffi”(atermcornf,atib1e with hatred or with passive resignation), but as ttself-giving, nonresistant loverr which ref-uses to use political means for self-defense, which seeks nej.ther effectiveness nor justice, and which is willing1f,o suffer any loss or seeming defeat for the sake of obedience. ^” Self-giving, nonresistant love is decisive, and it obliges christians to give a direct witness to the state by calling it to its proper task.
l3Yod”r, TliE POLITICS OF JESUS, p. 183. 14S.” John H. Yoder, “Theological Perspectives on tGrowth with Equityrtt and rrTheological Refl-ections on Economic Realities,t’ GRolmH wrrH EQUTTY: srMTEcrEs FoR MEETTNG Htn{AN NEEDS, ed. Mary Evelyn Jegen and CharLes K. Wilbur (New York: Paulist Press, L97g), pp. 9-16, 2rL-220. l5Joh’H. Yoder, THE ORIGINAI REVOLUTION: ESSA’S CHRISTIAN PACIFISM (Scottdale: Herald Press, I97I), pp. f3-33. 16Yod”r, THE POLITICS OF JESUS, pp. 135-162.
17Johr, H. Yoder, NEVERTHELESS (Scottdale: Herald press, 1971), p. r23. l8Yod”r, THE ORIGINAL REVOLUTI0N, p. 49 and p. 59.
How do Christians address a state which does not share its distinctive faith and vocabul-ary? Yoderrs problem is to understand within a christian framework how judgnents may be formulated and addressed to officials in the political sphere who do not share the Christian confession. To preserve the distinction between revelation and reason (or natural law), Yoder adopts a strategy of ttmiddle axioms.r’ These funetlon not only to mediate between general principles and more precise pollcies (as in J. H. Oldharn and John C. Bennett), they also frmediate bgfi,ween the norms of faith and the si.tuation conditioned by unbelief.t’^’ In other words, these axioms are not inforned by the ttorder of naturett (which is arbitrary), they are formulated solely on the basis of revelation, but in a way that nagistrates can understand.
From revelation (that is, from Rom. 13 and I Peter 2), yoder perceives two functions or two standards for the nagi.strate: to protect the innocent and punish the guilty. Nelther gives a blanket authorLzation to use violence, though both require fair judicial processes. The constant temptation of the state is to use its legitinate police function without holding violence to a mininum. Mlddle axioms, based on the standards of protecting the innocent and punishing the guiltlr caD be formulated so that more precise guLdance is given’ grounded in revelation and uncorrupted by reason or natural law. For example, on the matter of capital punishment, Yoder argues as follows:
In a society sufficlently influenced by Christian witnessing that other more offensive and more corrlgible forms of lethal viol-ence have been largely eliminated, to have policemen unarmed and to abolish capital punishment is an intelligent and available possibility because it Ls wLthin reaeh. In a society ——— such as those of the Middle East, for example ——— which has no due process of 1aw, to begin by attacking the legislative provision for the death penalty would be to raise the wrong issue first. This does not mean that capital_ punishment is ever justified; there may, however, be times when it is not the nost offensive cf the unjustified things which the state ls doing.
In other words, the best alternative for the Christian witness to the insist on due process before seeking to abolish capiral-;::[rffil.f2o.o
The reason-revelatlon Lssue looms large in contenporary Christian ethics, and Yoder bri-ngs it to sharp focus. Mainstream Christians may agree or disagree about Yoderrs position on particular moral issues.
1()”Yoder, THE CHRISTIAN WITNESS TO THE STATE, p. 33. 20ftfa., pp. 36-37, p. 50. Incldentally, the legitimacy of the police function does not inply that a Christian can be a policeman. Though Yoder does not categorieall-y rule out thls possibility, he says he has ttmet no one testifying to such an exceptional call-t'(Ibld., p. s7).
Hbwever, the substantive issue for Reformed ethics is to formulate a basis for ethics whlch is not only true to the normative witness of Scripture, but which also is responsive to other sources of knowledge ——— responsive to the things Calvin takes into account through his concept of the natural moral 1aw. The contemporary problem, clearly, is that traditional natural law has fallen on hard days (for legitimate reasons). A vacuum has thereby been created. Followers of Barth, for example, continue to argue that there i.s no such thing as a natural social institution of marriage; rather, the sanction ior marriage is found in the irnrnediate commands God gives to individual men and individual women. The substantive and practical issue is to find a contemporary equivalent to natural law.
Another major issue (not unrelated to the first) is the relation of nature to grace, traditionally formulated by the question, How is knowledge of God the creator and sustainer related to knowledge of Godrs redemption in Jesus Christ? Sattler advocates separation from the evil and wickedness of the world. He renounces weapons of violence. He states that the ordering of the sword is outside the perfection of Christ, and that Christians do not enter disputes about worldly matters such as property. calvin responds by articulating a just-war theory, by arguing that the magistracy is a christian calling that serves the cofirnon good, and that judgments about worldly matters like property disputes can receive Christian sanctlon. In back of these disagreements are different understandings of the relation of God to the wor1d.
Yoder addresses the grace-nature problen in a way which is true to his Mennonite heritage but which avoids any blatant charge of withdrawal from the world. He argues that there simultaneously exist two overlapping aeons. One aeon looks backward to human history outsj.de of christ; the other looks forwar$,to the fullness of the kingdom of God. chrlst rules over both realmsr” but in different rrrays. As the Lord of history he rules over the old aeon. This is the tfworldt’ of the principalities and powers’ created by God to provide a network of norms and regulations. This world, however, isrqow fallen and enslaves humans by deuranding their unconditional loyalty,” though the principalities and powers are still necessary for baslc human exi.stence. On the other hand, Christ is Lord of the church and rules over the new aeon which is a radical break from the old. Through the cross christ breaks the sovereignty of thg”principalities and powers by nonresistant, self-giving love.-” (Although Yoder is christocentrie, his is not a christology of the second person of the trlnity. His enphasis is on the Person and teachings of Jesus, not on Jesus Christ as the first-born of the whole creation or the high christology of the Logos. The distinction of Troeltsch between church- and sect-E]fe-christologies remains pertinent.)
2lrnn oRrcrNAr, REVoLUTToN, pp. 58-62. 22tun por,rrrcs oF JESUST pp. 144-146. 23run oRrcrNAL REVoLUTToN, pp. 58-62.
The question to put to Yoder ls whether Godts power and presence in the cross of Christ is set in opposition to Godts povirer and presence as creator and sustalner of the principalities and powers of the world. Are grace and nature split so that Godfs dominion over the world must be overcome through Godrs rule through the non-resisting church? (A sirnilar question can be asked about the relation of love and justice. In Yoder, justice and love appear to be set in opposition.)
Calvin does not have this kind of dualism. Though he distinguishes Godfs work in Christ frorn Godts rule over the whole creati.on, Godfs redeeming work is not set in opposition to his purpose as creator and sustainer. The substantive task of a contemporary Calvinist is to articulate a perception of the reality of God which does not place grace and nature in opposition (and which does not juxtapose l-ove and justice).
Three other major theological issues are present in the dispute between Calvin and The Seven Articles, and each is brought to contemporary focus by Yoder. I state them briefly. One concerns the relation of sin and evil to the good. What is the extent and location of evil, and how ls it related to the por{er of goodness? For Sattler, evil can be identified and located in the world, and at least certain manifestations of evil can be overcome. Calvin finds sin and evil more pervasively present, and thinks it unlikely that some of its manifestation.s can be eradicated. He therefore charges the Anabaptists nith being naive about sin, though it is also clear that Calvin has no intention of capitulating to the powers of evil.
Contemporary Calvinists can perhaps charge Yoder with underestinating the power of goodness in the principalities and powers and of overestiurating the purlty of the distinctive values of the nonresistant Christian community. On the other hand, a contemporary Reformed position must be sensitive to charges from Yoder that Calvinists accomodate evil too easillr and that Calvinlsts are reluctant to do what is truly possible to achieve the good. I suppose there is no Reformed pastor who does not face this dileuuna daily: to be realistic about the perniciousness of sin and evil, yet be steadfast in seeking the tenporal good. My suspicion is that this requires an eschatology which is not as oriented to the distant future as is Yoderrs.
Another issue concerns l-aw and gospel. Cleariy Calvinfs three uses of the law discern a greater continuity between the Decalogue, the natural moral law, and the teachings of Jesus, than do Anabaptlsts who distinguish more sharply between the o1d l-aw and the new. The Calvinist eharge of perfecti.onism is accompanied by the charge of legallsm, though this is somewhat ironic because Calvinists have often been charged with being legalistic.
The same issues can be discerned in Yoder. The central problern is to define the neaning of legalisn. In ny judgment, the insistence that policy t’xtt must be followed if a moral good is to be achieved or a moral- evil is to be avoided, is not by definition legalistic. Legalism, I learn from Roman Catholics, refers either to an excessiveLy scrupulous
conscience or to a predetermination of what is right. with yoder, this issue concerns the non-use of viorence “”-.;;;”;etermination of what is right. This problem needs attention and refinement.
The last of the three issues to be mentioned briefry concerns the relatlon of the christian community to the “o.ia or the church_world problen’ The issue of t’church” versus tt””.ii-i.s been transformed to no sna1l extent in our denominational, voluntary “o”i”ty. stated briefly, r believe the central issue here.concerns the prior question of Godrs relation to the world. My own view, which r judge to have affinities with calvln (the affinitils with H. Richara nl”etutrr are clearer), is that the christian coumunlty is not so much the locus of Godrs presence as it is the sphere of conscious_acknowreagernerra “i-c”j;”-ilrl-. presence and purpose for the whole creatioi. -i rirra it difficu..rra make sense of yoder’s claim ttr”t tt” world exists for the “h,rr”hl:2[o
There are other issues which courd be calred to attenti’n, for exanple, the relation of hurnan freedom to G;;;;’soverei.gnty. r conclude my remarks, however, with brief cotrunents about two moral issues, church discipline and jusr-war rheory. rhere has been;”;;;;;r’;;;i””ance in historical studies of the 5ust-war rradition,””;”;i;;25′”;;”:;” scholars are now trying to revise this tradition for use in the nuclear aile.to In the life of the church, however” just_war theory does not receive much attenti.on. The statement on peaceuraking (,,peaceuraking: The Believers’ calling”) adopted by the Generai e””..ury of both of the major Presbyterian denominations, for exa*ple, is in major respects a very unReformed document. rt counsels ” ai”po”itional ethics which is not correlated in any meaningful way with any oi tr,”,,hard,, issues facing us. Are we for or “giirr”t a nuclear ireeze? Are we for unilateral or bilateral disarmaurent, or for no disarmament at alt? rs deterrence immoral, or can it be justified, o. 5rr”aified only within linits? rs a tactical use of nuclear r.”porr” rnirally permissible, or
24rrn cHRrsrrAN wrrNESS To rHE srATE, p. 36.,’The stare, or more generally the organization of society, exisis according to the of the New Testament for the sake of the work of the church and message not vice versa. It
25J”r.” Turner Johnson, JUST wAR TRADrrroN AND THE RE’TRATNT oF wAR (Princeton: prlnceron universitl_!:.::, 19gljt Janes Turner Johnson, TDEOLOGY’ REAsoN, AND THE LrMrrATroN oF hrAR (princeton: princeton university Press, Ig75); Frederick H. Russell,-iHu.Tusr I{AR IN THE MIDDLE AGES (Lon-d_on:_ Cambridge University fress, Lg75); LeRoy B. walrers, Jr., FrvE clAssrc JU5T-WAR THEoRiEs cpt,.o. disserrarion, yare University, IgTI),
26J”*.” F. childress, MoRAL REspoNsrBrlrry rN coNFlrcrs (Baton Rouge: Louisiana state universitl pressr 1gg2); lJilliaur v. o’Brien, THE CONDUCT oF JUST AND LrMrrED I{AR (irew york, p;;;g”r special srudies, 1981); Michael walzer, Jusr AND rin.lusr-wans ?1r”” york: Basic Books, 1977).
not? Are conventional wars moral-Ly permisslbl-e, and lf so, under what conditions? Can a counter-insurgeney be conducted justly, and if so, what are the linits? etc. These issues are not addressed in this docunent. Instead, we are directed toward an attitude, a Gesinnungsethik. Furthermore, all the issues that used to be talked about under the umbrella of ttsocial- Justicert ——— issues which call for hard thought and particularity ——— non reappear under the rubric of ttpeacenakitrg.tt Agaln, only an attitude is counseled. To ny mlnd, it is a discouraging sign of the times that the best contemporary book on just-war theory (walzerrs JUST AND UNJUST waRS) was not rrritten by a Christlan, to say nothing of a Reformed Christian.
It is very clear today that on the issues of war and peace we sinply cannot repeat Calvinfs repetition of Augustine. Further, we know that some judgments ttfor peace and against wartt are warranted, especially if they are made ririth precision and discernment. It should be remembered that Calvln used just-war theory to restrain or prohibit the use of violence on several occasions. rf our judgments trfor peace and against l^rarrr are justified soleI”y on the basls of an attitudinal disposition toward peacemaking, we shall have been untrue to our Reforned heritage. Reading Calvinfs tract against the Anabaptists should make us ask, Is it possible to revise and retrieve just-war theory in such a way as to enable us to make discerning and discriminating judgnents about the use of force and threats of violence in the contemporary world? This questi.on presents an arduous task.
The other moral problen I mention is the issue of church discipline. It is a maJor problem. Is it possibl-e to have an ordering of the life of the church which exhibits a distinctive Christian identity in the contemporary world? I do not think that helpful discussions of church discipline can be carried on today in the sixteenth century mode of John Calvin, if that is taken to mean the inposing of external norms through the use of a ban. In this eontext, the growth of conservatlve churches as described by Dean M. Kel1ey (and elaborated somewhat differently by proponents of church growth) ig not, in my judgnent, the wave of the future. I believe that the issues are broader and deeper than either Kelley or proponents of church growth percei.ve. I find analyqes like Wade Clark Roofts recent article in DAEDAIUS more helpfuL.’t
Calvin also says that the ban is irnposed only through the consent of the coumunity. Perhaps the active consent of the church is the key to church discipl-ine today. I have found Don Bror+mingts discussion of church discipline to be suggestive. In THE MORAI CONTEXT OF PASTORAL CARE, he writes
Discipllne is first of all a matter of deeply inplanting wirhin the character of a people the basic normsr patterns, values, and sensibllities that govern the culture of the group. Diseipline
27w”d.” clark Roof, rrAmerlcars Voluntary Establishment: Mainline Religion in Transition,r’ DAEDAIUS, Vol. 111, No. I (trIinter 1982), pp. 165-184.
. lis] the task of forming and maintaining the emotlonal sensibilitiesi v2[ues, and behavioral norms of a people called Christians.
The rnode of this discipline changes from age to age. However, Broming suggests that the internalization of Christian values cannot take place if the church is a cornmunity which caters priurarily to this-worldly self-fulfillnent ——— a polenic, of course, against recent modes of pastoral care. Wtrat is required is a church structure which meaningfully addresses major moral issues as these irnpinge on the actual lives of church members. For example, the significance of marriage as an institution, the meaning of death and dying, and the issues of war and peaee, are matters which need to be explored in a normative context with the active participation and consent of the congregation. This type of inquiry ——— the process of inquiry is as iurportant as its product! ——— is THE MORAL CONTEXT OF PASTORAI CARE. I hope Brorrmlng’s vision is not just a romantic dream. In any event, I see sonething like his vision as the necessary social conditj.on for ordering the church in todayrs world. It is a vision that is true to the Reformed heritage.
28non S. Browning, THE MORAL CONTEXT OF PASTORAL CARE (Philadelphia: Westminster Press, 1976), p. 59.
19 March 1982
Cite this resource
Swezey, Charles M. “Calvin’s Treatise Against the Anabaptists.” Calvin Studies I, 1982. PDF. John Calvin Studies, Foundation for Reformed Theology. https://foundationrt.org/resource/calvins-treatise-against-the-anabaptists/.
More from John Calvin Studies
Stay in touch.
Receive seminar announcements, new bibliographies, and quiet word from the Foundation a few times each year.
See the work you support.
Small groups of around six to eight pastors read in advance and gather for a week, with a significant portion of their room, board and travel reimbursed.
