Foundation for Reformed Theology
Richard Niebuhr on the Kingdom of God
https://foundationrt.org/resource/richard-niebuhr-on-the-kingdom-of-god/
Richard Niebuhr on the Kingdom of God
Dr. Leith offers a review and theological assessment of H. Richard Niebuhr’s work, engaging his thought on the kingdom of God and its relationship to culture and history.
- Speaker
- Dr. John H. Leith
- Recorded
- Length
Richard Niebuhr on the Kingdom of GodDr. John H. Leith, 1970
0:00 of 39:16
Keyboard shortcuts
- Space or K
- Play or pause
- Left arrow or J
- Back 15 seconds
- Right arrow or L
- Forward 15 seconds
- Home
- Back to the start
- M
- Mute or unmute
The letters and arrows work anywhere on this page except in a text field or on another link or button. Space and Home act on the recording only while the player has focus, so they still scroll the page as usual.
Transcript
Transcribed from the 1970 recording. Corrections are welcome. The text was produced automatically from the audio and may contain errors; section headings were added only as reading aids. The attached audio recording is the authoritative source.
In this lecture
The Influence of Niebuhr’s Book
In this particular lecture, I shall attempt to supplement what we did in discussion groups by summarizing in one piece, as it were, what Richard Niebuhr has to say about Revelation. The importance of this book in American theological thought has been documented anew in the recent publication of the Sprunt Lectures of several years ago by Professor George Wright of Harvard University. In this book, he refers to Niebuhr’s meaning of revelation as setting the normative pattern for theological thought in America or having given the normative answer to certain problems in biblical theology. Few books have exercised a kind of influence in theological thinking and development in America, as has Richard Niebuhr’s The Meaning of Revelation. Hence, it is important for us to get the main thrust of this book.
And as I indicated before, the book serves very well to help us to orient our own particular stance, our own particular point of view as theologians. It helps us to understand the way we go about the theological task. Now, Niebuhr begins his study of Revelation with a chapter entitled, A Point of View. This chapter is very characteristic of Niebuhr’s theology. He had learned from the German sociologist, philosopher, and theologian, Troeltsch, that everyone has a point of view, and everything a man thinks or does is historically conditioned and determined. Niebuhr also learned from Karl Barth that God has spoken a message that breaks into our history with a uniqueness and an absoluteness that is not conditioned by history. Now in this book he tries to put these two insights together but he begins characteristically with the point of view. In this opening chapter, Niebuhr emphasizes the importance for the theologian of historical relativism and of religious relativism.
Defining Historical Relativism
It is important for us to define relativism as is used in this chapter to understand the meaning of the word. I had the impression that in our discussion group, some difficulty centered precisely here. an ambiguity as to the meaning of the word relative as it is used in this particular chapter. Relativism refers to a state of being dependent on or determined by something. My knowledge, for example, is in part dependent on and determined by my history. I see and understand things in the light of my having been a Southerner, a middle-class white American, a Presbyterian read in the Presbyterian church. If I were a Britisher, if I were an Episcopalian, if I belonged to another race, I would see things differently from another point of view. My knowledge is dependent on or determined by the fact of my history.
So we begin with historical relativism. A man’s theology is always conditioned by the time and the place in which he lives. It is also conditioned by such factors as race, age, family, background. Niebuhr mentions in particular three factors that condition our theology the historical background the will to believe and the specific interests of the social group to which we may belong in sum the theologian’s point of view is never universal never wholly objective never neutral The point of view is always particular, of a particular man living in a particular time and a particular place with a particular history. Now the question can be asked, does this historical relativism that characterizes our theology lead to subjectivism or to skepticism?
Why Relativism Is Not Skepticism
Niebuhr’s answer is is an emphatic no. He answers no for two reasons. First, the man who knows that his view is conditioned by his standpoint does not doubt the reality of what he sees. Niebuhr put this matter very well on page 18 of his book. Let me read you these lines. Relativism does not imply subjectivism or skepticism. It is not evident that the man who is forced to confess that his view of things is conditioned by the standpoint he occupies must doubt the reality of what he sees. It is not apparent that one who knows that his concepts are not universal must also doubt that they are concepts of the universal, or that one who understands how all his experience is historically mediated must believe that nothing is mediated through history.
While we are aware that our own particular standpoint is conditioned, it does not mean that we doubt the reality that we perceive. And secondly, Niebuhr says that historical relativism does not lead to skepticism and subjectivism because of the critical character of theology. A historically conditioned faith in theology can be subjected to criticism. Man has some freedom from the history of which he is a part. For example, self-awareness, the self-consciousness of my being a Southerner gives me, in some measure, freedom over my being a Southerner. Therefore, I have the capacity to subject my particular faith, my particular theology, to criticism, to the criticism of logic, to the criticism of consistency, for example. To be more specific, I can subject it to the criticism of what it does, the fruits that it bears.
A theology or a faith is justified by its fruits. someone has said that we really know the essence of a theology when we see it embodied in a life we can criticize our theologies and the various ways we can bring critical disciplines to focus upon them and moreover faith and theology are not private and subjective they take place in community, particularly in the church. Here again, let me read Richard Niebuhr on this particular poem. Having said that we criticize theology on the basis that we are not the only one to have experienced it, others have experienced it, we can compare our experiences, we can separate the peripheral from the essential in our experiences Niebuhr then concludes when a theology that has been convinced of its historical relativism speaks of revelation it means not only that in religion as in other affairs men are historically conditioned but also that to the limited point of view of historic Christian faith a reality discloses itself which invites all the trust and devotion of finite temporal men.
Such a theology of revelation is objectively relativistic, proceeding with confidence in the independent reality of what is seen, though recognizing that its assertions about that reality are meaningful only to those who look upon it from the same standpoint. One can speak of God only from a particular historical point of view. Now Niebuhr goes on to say that one can speak of God only from the particular point of view of a particular faith in him. Historical relativism, now religious relativism.
Religious Relativity and Faith
Niebuhr is fond of quoting Luther’s statement Faith and God hold close together The counterpart of faith is God The human counterpart of God is faith The 19th century theologians Schleiermacher and Ritschl were very much aware of this point though they failed to carry through fully Niebuhr’s criticism of Schleiermacher The American ritual is very perceptive, but it is not our primary concern. For our purposes, we need not concern ourselves with this analysis. But the main point for us is that thought about God, theology, must begin in faith. And therefore, in a particular faith, for there is no other kind of faith. I can only speak about God in terms of the particular religious experience out of which I have known God. I speak about God as one who believes in him.
To quote Niebuhr’s own words on page 37, the theology of revelation as it is developing in our time is a consequence of this understanding of theology’s religious relativity as well as of its understanding of historical relativity. If the historical limitations of all thought about God demand that theology begin consciously with and in an historical community, its limitations as an inquiry into the nature of the object of faith require it to begin in faith and therefore in a particular faith since there is no other kind. because God and faith belong together. The standpoint of the Christian theologian must be in the faith of the Christian community directed toward the God of Jesus Christ. Now Niebuhr turns from the point of view to his second chapter which is entitled The Story of Our Life.
The Story of Our Life
Christians have always communicated the faith by telling a story a story of what has happened in the community a story of a history that is also the history of their lives when a Christian communicates the faith he tells a story of what God has done in history and therefore done in and through his life the old hymn about the telling of a story is true theologically sooner or later we communicate Christian faith we have to tell a story and the telling of this story is the story of our own life we belong to a history and in the light of this history we see nature read science and understand experience now the historical character of Revelation poses certain problems which Niebuhr mentions. First of all, what is seen in history is never universal but always particular.
A particular historical person is known only by a limited number of people. There is nothing universal about any historical event. It is limited, somewhat parochial, somewhat provincial. The Christian, therefore, has a problem with the particularity of revelation. How can the particular become universal? And secondly, history can always be regarded from an objective scientific point of view. It can be studied in terms of causal relationships. And thirdly, if revelation means history, then it is identical or it would seem to be identical with belief in past events. now noting these three problems of locating history revelation in history Niebuhr gives brief answers to these problems and then he moves on to find a solution in part but only in part to these problems in this particular book in the fact that the history in which revelation occurs is what Niebuhr calls internal history history has two aspects or it can be seen from two points of view it can be seen from the internal point of view or from the external point of view internal history is the story of my life that i may confess and tell to you external history is what historians or psychologists or medical doctors can learn about me.
Internal and External History
Now, in certain situations, what the medical doctor knows about me, my external history, is very important. This is especially true if I happen to have pneumonia. But in another sense, a really important history is the internal history, the history as I see it, as I experience it, and which can only be confessed. When we speak of revelation in the Christian church, we refer to our history, to the history of selves, or to history as it is lived and apprehended from within. In external history, we deal with objects. In internal history, we deal with subjects. Internal history always has an objective point of view or an objective aspect. And this objective history is important for internal history. Scientific American history is important for me as an American citizen.
It corrects some of my misapprehensions of this history. It serves to correct my attitudes on certain problems. It enables me to understand the external history that the scientific historian can write about America. is very important. Perhaps I need to read the history of America as written by a British citizen rather than by an American in order to see my own internal history as an American from an external point of view. The critical study of scripture, for example, is very important for me as a Christian. And Niebuhr goes on to point out in this connection that groups who do not share in any way our internal history, who are enemies to our internal history, may have important things to say to us about our history. For example, the communists may not know the truth about Christian faith, but the communists may know a truth about Christian faith that is important for me to hear.
Thus, objective history, as seen by the outsider, or objective history as studied by the scientific historian, is important for internal history. The knowledge of the criticism of the scientific historian and even of the alien group must be taken seriously. Now, a further check on our internal history is its communal character, as I’ve already indicated. This is especially true in the Christian community. Subjectivity does not mean isolation or non-verifiability. Our internal history can be communicated. persons can refresh the memory of other persons persons can criticize the memories of other people their memories of what has happened to them in their common life and this happens continually in the Christian faith as one another living together, living together in a common community we refresh each other’s memories we criticize each other’s recollection of what has happened to them in the common memory of the Christian community.
Now I hope that something of the meaning of confessional is beginning to become clear. On the one hand I can recount the history or the facts of American life as an observer as a critical historian and on the other hand I can tell the story of America as the story of my own life. I can confess my Americanism. I can also recount the facts about Christian faith and the Christian community as an observer, at least in part, and report that a group of Christians living in a particular time and in a particular place believe that God confronted them in Jesus Christ. but I can also tell the story of Christian faith as the story of my life this is what has happened to me Abraham, Isaac and Jacob Paul and John Augustine and Calvin are my family tree I belong to the community which they are a part Revelation is an event that has occurred in my own life and experience Now, my confession is limited by my location in a particular time and space and by my particular religious experience.
For example, the way in which a man who was converted in a frontier revival would confess the faith would be significantly different from the way in which a person read in a Christian home growing up in the Christian community with no sudden crisis. would confess his faith. Religious experience makes a difference in our understanding of the faith. Our faith is relative to religious experience as well as to our historical experience. But while acknowledging this, I can still maintain that the limitation is in my apprehension of the divine reality, not in the reality apprehended. so while my confession is limited historically and limited religiously it does not follow that I doubt the reality of that which I have experienced I can only confess that this is what has happened to me but the fact that I can only confess this does not mean that I am uncertain that a reality overpowering and at the same time fascinating has confronted me and challenged my life. Niebuhr has said that our apprehension of Revelation is relative and that the locus of Revelation is our internal history.
Revelation as Intelligible Event
Now he defines more specifically what he means by Revelation. Revelation means for us, Niebuhr writes, that part of our internal history, our inner history, which illuminates the rest of it and which itself is intelligible. Or to put it another way, revelation is the intelligible event that makes all other events intelligible. Revelation is that illuminating experience that enables me to understand the various facts of my life, to put them together in some kind of rational pattern. Revelation is the event that illuminates my experience. Revelation is the discovery of a rational or meaningful pattern in life. It is far from being, therefore, contrary to reason. Revelation enables us to be more rational as it were in Kantian terms the reason that is correlative or that correlates with revelation is a practical reason reason conquers the evil imaginations of the heart not the adequate images of the observing mind Reason does not contradict what we learned by science From science It does not contradict what we learned in scientific history Reason, revelation is not opposed to science Not opposed to scientific history Revelation does correct the evil imaginations of our heart Niebuhr has a very suggestive treatment here of imagination, which we cannot go into at this particular time due to the limitation on this film.
These evil imaginations range from the image of the persecuted self to that of the master race. I may interpret my experiences with you in terms of a persecution complex. I may believe that everyone is persecuting me. And then I organize all the facts of my experience in the light of this image that I have of myself. I think this makes it clear that revelation is not opposed to the facts. The counterpart of revelation is the image in the light of which we organize the facts. The Christian revelation would be focused against The image of the persecuted self, for example, or again, the image of the master race. Revelation, therefore, does not contradict facts, but it conquers evil imaginations. Let me quote again from Niebuhr on pages 108 and 109. the heart must reason that’s the practical reasoning the participating self cannot escape the necessity of looking for pattern and meaning in its life and its relationships it cannot make a choice between reason and imagination but only between reasoning on the The basis of adequate images and thinking with the aid of evil imaginations, neither the primitive images of animism nor the impersonal patterns of modern scientific and indeed of any kind of purely contemplated thought supply a basis for the rational understanding of the self in its community and history.
But there is an image, neither evil nor inadequate, which enables the heart to understand. And the event through which that image is given, Christians call their revelation. Revelation, therefore, is set against imagination. the revelatory event that provides us with an adequate image for understanding our life understanding the history of which we are part serves to make the past intelligible to see the past as one part of one process and in the second place it enables us to remember what we had forgotten and to use it in our life and in the third place the revelatory event enables us to appropriate a past.
The Finality of Revelation in Christ
The Christian becomes an immigrant into the empire of God through the event of revelation. The revelatory event enables one to appropriate the history of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, to appropriate the history of Paul and John, of Augustine and Calvin, so that this now becomes my history, the story of my life. And to achieve our own past, to remember our own past, is also to achieve community with all mankind. for the God of our own past in Christian revelation is the God of all mankind. Here we have a suggestive treatment of revelation in general but the main point for us is that revelation centers in Christ and this revelation is a final revelation not in the sense that God ceases to reveal himself not in the sense we cease to experience this revelation.
But the revelation in Christ is unique, decisive, and it is final in the sense that it is a judge of all other revelations. In the light of this revelation, we shall understand any other revelatory experience. It is final in the sense that it is unique and it is definitive of any other revelatory experience. It is not progressive in the sense that we can ever substitute another revelation for the revelation of Jesus Christ. It is progressive in the sense that we can grow in our understanding of the meaning of this particular revelatory experience. Now Niebuhr goes on in his definition of revelation to point out that revelation is not discovery. Revelation is not a human achievement. There is no way that we can program revelation. There is no way that we can plan it.
There is no way that we can coerce it. The intelligible event is not our discovery. It is always something that happens to us. Niebuhr puts this remarkably well on page 139. We do not mean that we have freely chosen one section of our history because we found that it made sense of the remainder. We mean rather that something has happened which compels our faith and which requires us to seek rationality and unity in the whole of our history. Revelation is like the kingdom of God. If we seek it first of all, other things are added to us. But if we seek it for the sake of these other things, we really deny it. The kingdom proves itself to be the kingdom of God not only by its immediate worth but also by its instrumental value in leading to secondary goods.
And revelation proves itself to be revelation of reality, not only by its intrinsic verity, but also by its ability to guide men to many other truths. In other words, revelation validates itself by the very experience. It is self-validating. We know that it is true in the experience. But it also validates itself. In that it enables us to understand life. In other words, the Christian claim is that the Christian revelation enables us to understand life, to make sense out of life, to do justice to the facts of life in a way that no other revelation whatsoever does. The assurance of revelation grows in part out of the intrinsic experience, experience in part out of the ability the capacity for the revelatory experience to enable us to understand life it also grows out of social corroboration we are not the only people who have experienced this revelation we live in a community that shares in this common revelation community is necessary for the corroboration of the experience To be a Christian is, in one sense, to be the church.
In other words, assurance grows out of the immediate perception plus social corroboration and out of neither of these alone. In Revelation, we are first of all known by the revealer. To know a knower is to begin with the activity of the other who knows us or reveals himself to us by his activity. Here again, let me quote from pages 152 to 153. Revelation means a moment in our history through which we know ourselves to be known from beginning to end, in which we are apprehended by the knower. It means the self-disclosing of that eternal knower. Revelation means a moment in which we are surprised Surprised by the knowledge of someone there in the darkness and the void of human life.
Revelation Reconstructs Rather Than Informs
It means the self-disclosure of light in our darkness. Revelation is a moment in which we find our judging selves to be judged. Not by ourselves or our neighbors, but by one who knows the final secrets of the heart. Revelation means the self-disclosure of the judge. Revelation means that we find ourselves to be valued rather than valuing, and that all our values are transvaluated by the activity of a universal valuer. Now, revelation imparts no factual knowledge, no knowledge about science, no knowledge of historical facts. at least in Niebuhr’s understanding it does involve the radical reconstruction of all of our belief it does involve the radical reconstruction of the facts that are at our disposal here Niebuhr differs from protestant orthodoxy that frequently identified revelation with the inspiration of the bible for protestant orthodoxy revelation did communicate facts For Niebuhr, it does not.
Niebuhr’s position here is made clear, I think, in a statement on page 174. Revelation of God through Jesus Christ does not include the communication of the propositions that Jesus was born of a virgin, that the scriptures are inerrant, and that history is catastrophic. it does make necessary a transformation of the opinion that Jesus was only a carpenter’s son or an illegitimate child as some Jews asserted that the Bible is only another book like all the others that men write that human history is just another cycle of seasons In other words, Revelation does not communicate facts, even such facts as the virgin birth. But it does demand that we reconstruct our attitude toward the person, Jesus of Nazareth. Niebuhr also recognizes that men have some ideas about God, apart from the Bible, apart from Christian faith. this would be true of someone who read in isolation from the Christian community but it’s also true of those of us who read in the Christian community we have some ideas about God that we do not immediately get from the Christian community and even though all ideas about God in the western world may be shaped by the history of the Christian community in the western world certainly the history of religions proves that men in general have some ideas about Now, is it possible to have a natural theology that builds upon these ideas about God that are given in some kind of general revelation or that belong to man universally?
Is there a natural knowledge of God prior to revelation in the sense that Niebuhr has been using it? Here again, for Niebuhr, the chief point is a conversionistic motif. Revelation does not supplant the ideas that we may have about God. It reconstructs them, reorders them, purifies them, clarifies them. It converts them. And this is a process that is continually going on. For the Christian, there can be no Christian natural theology. The Christian never begins with these general ideas. He always begins with the revelatory experience in Jesus Christ. But this does not nullify the significance of the general ideas. Niebuhr can accept these ideas on the basis of his theology. What Revelation does, and this Revelation is a starting point always for the Christian, it takes these ideas, reconstructs them, puts them together in a new pattern, purifies them, and clarifies them.
Let me read you again from Niebuhr’s own words on page 182 to 183. Revelation is the fulfillment and the radical reconstruction of our natural knowledge about deity through the revelation of one whom Jesus Christ called Father. All thought about deity now undergoes a metamorphosis. Revelation is not a development of our religious ideas, but their continuous conversion. God’s self-disclosure is that permanent revolution in our religious life by which all religious truths are painfully transformed and all religious behavior transfigured by repentance and new faith. It is revolutionary since it makes a new beginning and puts an end to the old development. It is permanent revolution, since it can never come to an end in time. Life in the presence of revelation, in this respect, as in all others, is not lived before or after, but in the midst of a great revolution that continues throughout one’s life.
Summary and Confession
This is the way that Niebuhr understands the meaning of revelation. Historically conditioned Religiously relative It occurs with In the internal history So revelation takes place In the story of our life Not in the external history That can be observed by the scientific historian Revelation does not contradict facts Rather it reorganizes facts It transfigures facts It provides patterns of coherence and consistency. Revelation corrects, not facts, but evil imaginations. Revelation is not something that we can program, course, plan, demand. Revelation always comes as a free gift. It is something that happens to us. a moment in which we are confronted by a knower who knows us and who values us and reveals himself to us and this revelatory event enables us to make sense out of all of our life it enables us to reconstruct the facts of our life to renew our own experiences and to change the direction of our personal and social behavior this is our confession and we confess it and we invite other people to stand where we do and share this faith
Cite this recording
Leith, John H. “Richard Niebuhr on the Kingdom of God.” 1970. Audio recording, MP3. Sermons & Lectures, Foundation for Reformed Theology. https://foundationrt.org/resource/richard-niebuhr-on-the-kingdom-of-god/.
More from Sermons & Lectures
Richard Niebuhr on the Kingdom of God
0:00 of 39:16Muted
Stay in touch.
Receive seminar announcements, new bibliographies, and quiet word from the Foundation a few times each year.
See the work you support.
Small groups of around six to eight pastors read in advance and gather for a week, with a significant portion of their room, board and travel reimbursed.
